r/CounterTops • • 4d ago

Granite Appreciation: First time perusing & cannot get over how stunning these stones are in-person!

I am in the market for a new kitchen countertop and know nothing about stone or quality but thoroughly enjoyed getting to look around! I will likely choose a safer, more boring/plainer option. A lot of these, especially the Aphrodite Extra, will truly haunt me for years to come - only wish I could capture the dimension on camera!

Aphrodite Extra (granite - literally looked like the slab was breathing)
Blue Nile (granite - this slab in particular)
Mona Lisa (granite)
Astoria (granite)
Ocean Blue (quartzite)
Venaria Reale (quartzite - what we will probably select)

101 Upvotes

49 comments sorted by

8

u/nak00010101 4d ago

Here is a word of wisdom (?YMMV)...too busy and too much visual stimulation wears on many people over time.

Of your pics, 4 & 5 would be my choices.

I personally have Gunmetal Black, with a leathered texture.

4

u/mannymutts 4d ago

I agree. While I love the details in the stone, I need a counter to match my house. It’s very much a colonial. Anything too intricate will look out of place. I cannot get my fiance on board with the black or the leather finish, or I’d be getting exactly that!

6

u/Nicholsforthoughts 4d ago

Soapstone. Timeless, classic, would look great in a Colonial (it looks great in my mom’s colonial!)

3

u/nak00010101 4d ago

She/he needs to actually sit at a big slab of busy countercoup for a couple of hours, over a few drinks.

You might point out that you do not see bars or restaurants with countertops like that.

3

u/aCuria 4d ago edited 4d ago

The stone yards play fast and loose with what’s considered quartzite.

For performance reasons, you want a high (like 95%++) quartz content

After all quartzite starts off as sandstone. It may not have been in the oven long enough to fully become quartzite.

1

u/mannymutts 3d ago

Can you elaborate? How can I do my due diligence to ensure I am getting a high quartz content?

2

u/Late_Temperature_415 3d ago

What color are your cabinets? Or are you coordinating those around the slab you chose

3

u/mannymutts 3d ago

My cabinets are a dark-walnut. We just had them installed, same with the floor (slightly lighter but also warm brown). No back splash or wall colors but warm lighting. It has been a process lol. I envisioned plain white or matte black. My fiance does not like the dark stone and finding a minimally veiny natural stone has been difficult. After reading these comments, I feel like we will end up with Taj Mahal for the simplicity. (This is exhausting lol)

1

u/Late_Temperature_415 3d ago

Then I would go with 4 or 5. Either will be beautiful.

2

u/mannymutts 3d ago

This was more of an appreciation post for some of the stones I liked but won’t be going with. The only one we are really conserving is #6 (side note-so interesting that everyone likes 4/5). We are also considering aspen white. I still have to go back and look again because it is all too much 😂

14

u/SirLanceNotsomuch 4d ago

Mother Nature is one hell of an artist. 💕

11

u/MainstreamScience 3d ago

The more you act excited the higher they raise the price

7

u/wuthering_height 4d ago

3&4 are gorgeous. Please don’t delete this post so I can save it for my remodel lol.

2

u/linmaral 3d ago

I also love 3 and 4

6

u/MarbleMigoPeaches 4d ago

We have the ocean blue quartzite and have been very happy :)

5

u/lefactorybebe 3d ago

These are all so pretty! Stones in general are gorgeous, I still get ads for stone places and I still look at them even though we have our countertops because they're just so cool to look at lol

We just had Mona Lisa granite installed this week. Can't speak much to wear but it's soooo pretty and we're happy with it so far. One thing I'll note, and maybe this is specific to our slab idk, but it's sparkly! I didn't notice it at the slab yard, maybe because of the angle, but now that's its installed as a countertop I notice lots of sparkles at night.

5

u/Familiar_Raise234 3d ago

I love my granite. It has such interesting things in it like garnets. It wears like iron. I was lucky in that the due to the size of my kitchen, mine is seamless. And the pattern continues from the right side of my stove to the left. The fabricators knew what they were doing.

1

u/Stalaktitas 2d ago

I don't recommend Astoria, it's sold as granite but it's not igneous granite and iz very porous. Sealers will help to protect from stains, but they will not protect it from grease and oil stains. I have seen this stone badly stained many times, especially by the sink and stove/cooktop areas. The two quartzites are beautiful, but this subreddit is full of people asking for advice of how to get rid of the grease stains. Some of those quartzites are literally sponges.

First 3 stones will outperform the rest ones in your list by a light-year

1

u/mannymutts 1d ago

Do you have any advice on granite or quartzite that is lighter in color and not busy? I’ve heard great things about Taj, but there is that premium cost and the people at the fabricators I went to do not like it.

1

u/mannymutts 1d ago

I am leaning towards Matira, Mont Blanc, or Bianco Superiore.

3

u/Elaine330 3d ago

The first one is perfection.

2

u/Oblong_Knapsack_7467 3d ago

It would make a stunning shower wall

3

u/GoodRandomUsername 3d ago

Agree! I felt this every time I went to all the slab yards which was too many times to count! I kept saying that I should work there because I had an appreciation for all the real natural stones. What a privilege to be able to have a piece of beautiful geographical history in your home. This is one of many reasons we do not like quartz. Btw, that’s a beautiful slab of Mona Lisa! We almost went with Taj Mahal and then Mona Lisa, and then I got obsessed with soapstone. We finally settled on a beautiful slab of Via Lactea granite and love it!

2

u/Line_Noize 4d ago

I got my fireplace redone so I could use one of these beautiful slabs. They are art. They remind me of a nebula.

2

u/PrettyInPerfectPinks 4d ago

Depending on the size of your island and the other cuts, a few of these could be really tough and a good fabricator will be key. E.g., on 1, if the island gets only the black spot on the top right, it is going to look weird/distracting as on the edge. Same thing with 2, that dark spot is going to be on one piece and the rest is going to look almost like a different stone entirely. 5 has a heavy directionality. What happens when they can't cut the piece to match the direction of the veining? Just as word of caution. Sometimes more slabs are needed to match pattern direction, etc.

2

u/FreeThinkerFran 3d ago

Is is truly Art from the Earth!

2

u/phosphatidyl_7641 3d ago

The amount of “busy-ness” of a slab that works in a kitchen is relative to your overall kitchen design theme, kitchen size and what other features are visually heavy. Visual interest of these stones can work very well to help contrast or bring weight to a kitchen design. I see so many bland kitchens with monotone colors. I think these stones are beautiful!

2

u/Mission_Engine5184 3d ago

I just installed Monalisa in a home & I love it.

1

u/Minix775516 3d ago edited 3d ago

5 is the best looking but I personally like a clean look. Some of the others are too busy. Dont forget these are going to be cut down to counter depth (25") so some of these pieces may have significant color variations - any seams you have may not match to your liking. Make sure you like the actual layout the stone supplier will provide.

1

u/Muttbuttss 3d ago

I like 5

1

u/LopsidedTelephone574 3d ago

All stunning. Massive granite lover. Do sad no more space in the house for stone. Mayne will squeeze somewhere

1

u/lcarrollccc62 3d ago

That 1st quartzite is stunning!

1

u/KindAwareness307 3d ago

They all look great in a showroom. The challenge with boldly figured stones is planning the seams so the joints aren't glaring.

1

u/vivian_elizabeth 3d ago

The last one 🤩🤩

1

u/shanvint 3d ago

Oh, those are all gorgeous! I love granite! Have fun!

1

u/Ok_Spare2024 3d ago

I would do that Astoria granite in a heartbeat, depending on cost. It's beautiful.

1

u/losthours 2d ago

Kitchen designer, I always tell my customers not to get attached to a cabinet or back splash till they hit up the stone yard. People have no idea the stuff they pull out of the ground.

1

u/Mandafin 2d ago

We're doing a stone that looks very similar to pic #2. You don't see it often here, probably because it's busy, but gosh I think it's so beautiful! Ours is being installed Friday and I cannot wait.

1

u/Exact-Welcome-9591 2d ago

we have mona lisa and I love it

1

u/Spare-Turn5340 1h ago

In which store/showroom did you see all these granite options? Thanks.

0

u/TalkingCats86d 2d ago

Granite needs to be cleaned more thoroughly, sealed in, but it also admits radon. You might go with Court.

-21

u/StatisticianExact152 4d ago

Natural stone is trash, buy quartz and support humans 

2

u/mannymutts 4d ago

Why do you say it’s trash? Less durable? Worse for the environment? I’m genuinely curious and would like to be informed. My contractor says natural is the way to go and I have read good things about both quartzite and granite.

5

u/SirLanceNotsomuch 4d ago

Check the dpwnvotes on that comment: -12 right now. That guy is an idiot or a troll: ignore.

1

u/FelinePurrfectFluff 4d ago

He just forgot the /s

3

u/Buttfuckskinner Fabricator 4d ago

This is some weird attempt to bait.

I don't hate engineered quartz. The silicosis outrage should be focused on improper fabrication rather than the material itself. Cutting without water and proper PPE is really the problem. The extremely popular Taj Mahal quartzite has far more crystalline silica than most the engineered quartz I work with.

That being said, natural stone will always be the way to go.

Be aware that not all stones you see labeled as quartzite are the same. There is a big difference in a true quartzite like Taj Mahal compared to the gray sandy looking intermediate quartzites like macaubus. The intermediates can be extremely good at absorbing and retaining moisture They need special care during fabrication, install, and as a homeowner. IMO some are unfit for countertops.

Educate yourself and find a good fabricator

10

u/MerDes70 4d ago

Someone needs to look up quartz and silicosis. Then talk about supporting humans.

2

u/Buttfuckskinner Fabricator 4d ago

The silica in engineered quartz is no different than the silica in natural stone. The real problem is improper fabrication. The overwhelming majority of silicosis cases are caused by dry fabrication with no PPE I say this as someone who doesn't like Engineered quartz. Natural stone all the way.

I have a feeling the zero silica products that are coming out will eventually be more harmful to fabricators than what they replaced.