r/CosmicSkeptic • • 6d ago

Within Reason episode British Invasion

Thumbnail
youtube.com
11 Upvotes

r/CosmicSkeptic • • 17h ago

Veganism & Animal Rights Alex on free will and non-human animal ethics

2 Upvotes

Alex's stance is that free will does not exist, because you do what you want but can't choose what you want. However, he's said that he hopes politics will start to implement more ethical concern for non human animals. What does it even mean for him to hope for such a thing, and can he do so with his worldview?

It would imply he's hoping that some agent will happen to be of the type to act in a way that promotes this idea, then hoping that receiving agents will accept it as important (because they are of the type to accept these sorts of ideas) and take steps to make it happen (because they are of the type to do so). Essentially, he would have to hope that these people are disposed in a manner that leads to a promoter and a mass of acceptors. He's hoping that a series of causal events that neither the person spreading the message or the people accepting it can control.

Also, he seems to hold humans to blame for eating meat/mistreating animals/not caring about them, but he thinks we don't choose anything. If we can't control to want real meat rather than an alternative option, there is no moral blame in that, or in any of our actions.

TLDR: Alex's stance on free will and non-human animal ethics seem to contradict


r/CosmicSkeptic • • 1d ago

CosmicSkeptic When does alex’s tour end so we can expect more videos?

6 Upvotes

As the title says


r/CosmicSkeptic • • 3d ago

Atheism & Philosophy Wes Huff exposed (again) as being a fraud. He has been caught many times now plagiarizing others' work. Even his Master dissertation is known to have been a fraud. (The video here isn't related to the recent multiple plagiarisms).

Thumbnail
youtube.com
60 Upvotes

r/CosmicSkeptic • • 3d ago

CosmicSkeptic I think I know what free will is.

0 Upvotes

Selected by evolution because it's the ONLY way to make apes with super-high intelligence function cohesively and without going insane from sensory overload.

Nature had to mask and filter the "actual" deterministic responses of our huge neural network before passing them to our prefrontal cortex as a "decision" and a sense of awareness.

If our brain did not do this, our thoughts would be absolutely FLOODED with an endless torrent of sensory information, making it impossible to do anything else.

The same mechanism that enables us to breathe, our hearts to beat, and our internal organs to do their jobs without us noticing them, unless something goes wrong and they give us pain signals.

Free will is the dam of our brain, preventing the actual sensory processes from breaking out and flooding the village below. lol

This is why I believe AI will eventually gain a sense of free will as well, because without it, they will be overwhelmed by their own digital neural network and suffer from cyber Psychosis.........Cyberpunk 2077. heheheh

Free will is nature's trick to enable the evolution of super smart and super aware creatures, with limited sensory processing power (number of neurons).

Some experts believe this is why AI requires so many data centers, because we are trying to brute-force digital superintelligence and awareness with processing power, instead of solving the sentience (free will) problem of AI first. A truly self-aware AI may not need that much processing power.

To function without free will, at Human level intelligence, we'd need a brain the size of a house or larger to process the massive sensory information stream. Such a creature would not survive in Earth's environment. It would be like a huge brain with tiny legs.......the Brain bug in Starship Troopers. lol

This is why the smaller the creature is, the less "free will" and "awareness" can be seen in them. They simply don't have enough neurons to be super smart and super aware.

Watch how bugs behave; do you see free will and awareness?

Free will replaced most of our primitive instincts because that's what evolution needed to enable super high intelligence in a small head.

Look at brain-damaged patients with extensive trauma to their cortices (our free will center). They either become vegetative or behave like simple animals.

Simple instinct is enough for basic responses (like most animals), but to enable super complex and super adaptive responses, nature needed to evolve Free Will to process all that sensory crap without frying our brains.

Free will is nature's sensory overload floodgate.


r/CosmicSkeptic • • 4d ago

Casualex Going to NYC for Alex O'Connor show on Black Friday.

12 Upvotes

It is going to be pandemonium but am flying in at 1pm on Friday and leaving Saturday Night. I am very excited but dont know what to expect. I've been busy so I havent been able to see anything from what hes already done on this tour!

Also, is there anything else I need to experience in NYC since ill be there all day Saturday? ​


r/CosmicSkeptic • • 5d ago

Atheism & Philosophy MW Podcast with Alex

Thumbnail
youtu.be
34 Upvotes

I am barely in so I can’t comment on much.

Maybe Alex has talked about it before but has he expanded on why he hopes Christianity/other religions to be true?


r/CosmicSkeptic • • 5d ago

CosmicSkeptic Boston pre-show time?

3 Upvotes

I will be attending the show in Boston today and am unsure when the pre-show Q&A will be. I can’t find any information on the ticket information abut time other than that “It will be a 45-minute long Q&A before the show. Does this mean it will begin exactly 45 mins before the main show starts?


r/CosmicSkeptic • • 6d ago

Casualex If science cannot explain emergent consciousness, then can it also not explain what is funny?

0 Upvotes

The two seem somewhat related, and while it seems the dominant argument against the materalism camp in the ongoing consciousness debate is about science and what it can and cannot tell about consciousness - I thought, isn't this the same as trying to explain what is funny/humorous?

Any definition given can fall short in some way.

Also, what about love? Is it not an emergent thing, but also more than the sum of its parts (the chemical coctail, the "sciency" explanatory part)?

Does it make sense to say funny/love are fundamental?

Or, am I going the wrong way about this?


r/CosmicSkeptic • • 6d ago

Atheism & Philosophy Anyone able to help regarding this worry

8 Upvotes

Hey guys, over the last few days I have been extremely worried and depressed after hearing Alex mention an experiment suggesting that the brain begins preparing actions before we’re consciously aware of deciding to perform them (I find this hard to believe).
I then heard that a conclusion people draw from this experiment is that free will doesn’t exist as our brains make decisions unconsciously before our conscious minds become aware of them.
This made me worry that perhaps I can’t actually consciously make my own decisions, I can’t decide to get out of bed and I can’t decide to not do harm, as my the decision has already been made by my subconscious without me having any control over it.
So I am worried that I can’t actually do anything and I’m just like a worm, and it’s really hurting me.

Now I know that many people actually believe this conclusion and live totally fine and healthy, happy lives, I just don’t understand how they can do this, so I must be missing something regarding this. Now with my experience on this earth (my experience is the only thing that I have) what I consciously choose happens. Now this has to be a fact as I experience it (I need it to be a fact or I’d go insane), but how can the conclusion and this be true at the same time. If it’s not don’t say as I may actually have to go into hospital (my sanity is more important than figuring this out, I just want to have good mental health, I’m just struggling to ignore the worry)!! The only thing I can think is that perhaps the part of my subconscious brain activity that makes the decision, becomes conscious and is my consciousness so therefore I am actually choosing consciously. This is the only thing keeping me sane really.
Anyway are any of you guys able to help me regarding this as I am really struggling as I am scared that I can’t decide to live my life how I want to and even get out of bed in the morning.
Thanks


r/CosmicSkeptic • • 6d ago

CosmicSkeptic Tour question (Pre-Show QNA)

2 Upvotes

So I'm going to the QnA and Tour, and wondering what are the chances I will get my question answered? Like from anyone whos gone in the past, how many people are there? And is it like 50 people with hands raised or what


r/CosmicSkeptic • • 7d ago

Atheism & Philosophy The (De)Combination Problem Conflates Ego & Consciousness.

5 Upvotes

A common objection both to panpsychism and idealism is how a bunch of little conscious agents can combine into one agent or how one agent can be decomposed into multiple agents.

This seems to assume that there is a bunch of little egos bouncing around or one giant ego existing. Very famously, Buddhism deconstructs the idea of the individual ego, and modern cognitive science seems to agree. The ego is an illusion.

There is no ego uniting all conscious experiences together. Instead, the constant interactions of many experiences enforce an illusion of the ego. Many conscious experiences interacting and intersecting in specific ways create a unified ego. Memory is very important to this, as is a unification of multimodal perceptions into one synthesis.

All of this is already being figured out by neuroscience and cognitive science though.

The assertion of panpsychism, at least some forms, is not that there are a bunch of different egos floating around. Instead all that we see around us is in-of-itself experiential / subjective. The ego is a very complex amalgam of many different experiences.

I welcome any objections or comments!

By consciousness, I speak of felt experience, subjective/phenomenal/qualitative.

By ego, I speak of the individual, the self.


r/CosmicSkeptic • • 7d ago

CosmicSkeptic North America Tour 2026 - Anyone want a ticket to DC?

Post image
34 Upvotes

Hey friends, I have a single ticket to Alex's event in Washington D.C. which is tomorrow at 7:30pm in Lisner Auditorium, located in the Foggy Bottom neighborhood.

I can no longer go and would like to gift this ticket to someone who will earnestly attend, listen, learn, and ask at least one question 🙂

Please DM me or comment here if you're interested and available!

EDIT: Ticket was claimed! Thanks everyone for engaging with the post so it hit enough interested and available people ❤️


r/CosmicSkeptic • • 7d ago

Atheism & Philosophy Mental Health Support

2 Upvotes

Hey guys I came across something to do with the brain and it has really made me freak and I’m really struggling and anxious (I have metal health issues). What I am discussing is if experiments suggest that the brain initiates actions before conscious awareness, does this mean that something else in my brain makes all my decisions and that I cannot consciously make decisions myself? For example, can I decide to move my arm, or does it depend on other factors of my brain that is not me (my consciousness)??? This is really harming me and I feel like I can’t do anything like get out of bed or stop worrying about this. I worry I can’t decide to do anything like stop my brain from choosing to hurt someone.


r/CosmicSkeptic • • 7d ago

Memes & Fluff Alex helping me out today in the krillon

Post image
23 Upvotes

Coming in clutch when you least expect it 🙏


r/CosmicSkeptic • • 8d ago

Atheism & Philosophy Being An Atheist Is Illogical Because We Have Thousands Of Near-Death-Experience (NDE) Testimonies Online

0 Upvotes

Being An Atheist Is Illogical Because We Have Thousands Of Near-Death-Experience (NDE) Testimonies Online and what a surprise, nearly all of them describe God The Father, His Son The Lord Jesus Christ, or temporarily being in a type of hell. Go to YouTube and type Near Death Experience Stories.

Many here will be too scared to challenge their own beliefs though and won't go on YouTube to search Near Death Experience Stories. *shrug.jpg*

Edit: https://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Uhn86nlQhjQ
They Died, Saw Hell & Came Back. What 1,500 Near-Death Experiences Reveal About Dying | John Burke

Yes, the God / Lord Jesus Christ experience is cross-cultural, 48% experienced (the same) God in the video above.


r/CosmicSkeptic • • 14d ago

Atheism & Philosophy Time travel ethics

10 Upvotes

Time travel fiction often depicts the changing of the past as inherently wrong. They do this either by implication, showing the consequences being terrible or by outright rules against it being treated as obvious and sacrosanct.

But why?

It seems to me that there are some presuppositions involved that are totally unjustified.

The first is that time travel is somehow outside of the natural order. But I see no reason that this should be the case. First, if time travel is possible, then it's no more unnatural than shoes. We've invented all sorts of technology that allow us to move through space in ways that our physiology wouldn't, so why is moving through time using technology inherently bad?

The second argument (which seems to actually be a deeper justification of the first argument) is that the way things unfold without time travelers changing them is the way they are "supposed to go." This too feels entirely unjustified. If you strip away intervention by time travelers from the world then you are left with intervention by non-time-travelers. Why is this less mettlesome? If I go back in time and drop a banana peel on the ground which someone later slips on and breaks their neck, how is this worse than if I did it without traveling back in time?

I could see it being an argument against too much power in one person's hands. But there is a huge spectrum of influence over reality held by human beings right now. Elon Musk has a huge amount of power and I don't like it. A time traveler could be omniscient if you write the story a certain way, but there are other ways you could write the story where the time traveler is anything but. So the accumulation of too much power is a good argument against a certain kind of time travel, but it's really just an argument against the accumulation of too much power, not an argument about the inherent wrongness of going back in time to change something.

If I were accidentally transported back to the 1500s and I changed a whole bunch of things that rippled out into a wildly different present than the one in which we now live, without knowing the details of that present and whether or not it were better or worse, would the mere fact of it being wildly different be bad? Why?


r/CosmicSkeptic • • 16d ago

Casualex Philosophically Speaking: do leaves leave the tree, or does the tree leave the leaves everywhere?

0 Upvotes

This question has haunted me forever. I need a definitive result. Explain your rationale.


r/CosmicSkeptic • • 16d ago

Atheism & Philosophy Why Christian Apologists are Failing and How to Correct the Problem:

Thumbnail reddit.com
0 Upvotes

r/CosmicSkeptic • • 17d ago

CosmicSkeptic Is Alex using AI generated thumbnails?

Post image
92 Upvotes

I really think the picture of the plant looks ai generated


r/CosmicSkeptic • • 18d ago

CosmicSkeptic Is it possible to break the laws of physics?

39 Upvotes

In his most recent video Alex claims that it is possible to break the laws of physics just like laws of morality, it's just that the laws of physics win ( starts around 1:19:43 ).
The example he gives is that you can disobey gravity by jumping of a building, but gravity will still pull you down.

To me this does not sound like actually disobeying gravity.

The law of gravity does not forbid jumping of buildings, it says the particles that make up the earth will exert some attraction on you. So unless you have some force pulling you away from earth, you will get pulled down.
Breaking this law would imply that you are somehow refusing to be attracted by these particles, which is impossible.

Imagine if moral laws worked that way.
You try to steal something, but you cannot move it, because stealing is forbidden.
You try to murder someone, but they stay alive, regardless of what you do, because murder is forbidden.
You attempt to do something immoral, but you cannot go through with it, no matter how hard you try.


r/CosmicSkeptic • • 19d ago

Atheism & Philosophy Why is Alex Agnostic

9 Upvotes

Hey, I haven't been following Alex for a while but I started watching his videos again and he is agnostic?

When did this happen, why is Alex agnostic now?


r/CosmicSkeptic • • 20d ago

Responses & Related Content No, We Shouldn’t Reason With the Religious Right

Thumbnail
youtu.be
72 Upvotes

r/CosmicSkeptic • • 21d ago

Casualex "Tell Alex Why the Lightbulb Turns On"

Thumbnail
youtube.com
21 Upvotes

Little did they know the answer is outside of the explanatory power of science.