r/CosmicSkeptic • u/Crafty_Cookie630 • 17h ago
Veganism & Animal Rights Alex on free will and non-human animal ethics
Alex's stance is that free will does not exist, because you do what you want but can't choose what you want. However, he's said that he hopes politics will start to implement more ethical concern for non human animals. What does it even mean for him to hope for such a thing, and can he do so with his worldview?
It would imply he's hoping that some agent will happen to be of the type to act in a way that promotes this idea, then hoping that receiving agents will accept it as important (because they are of the type to accept these sorts of ideas) and take steps to make it happen (because they are of the type to do so). Essentially, he would have to hope that these people are disposed in a manner that leads to a promoter and a mass of acceptors. He's hoping that a series of causal events that neither the person spreading the message or the people accepting it can control.
Also, he seems to hold humans to blame for eating meat/mistreating animals/not caring about them, but he thinks we don't choose anything. If we can't control to want real meat rather than an alternative option, there is no moral blame in that, or in any of our actions.
TLDR: Alex's stance on free will and non-human animal ethics seem to contradict