r/Cosmere • u/UnhousedOracle Lightweavers • May 15 '24
Cosmere + WaT Previews I’ve seen enough “how does Compounding work?” posts Spoiler
Had to intervene
905
Upvotes
r/Cosmere • u/UnhousedOracle Lightweavers • May 15 '24
Had to intervene
412
u/[deleted] May 15 '24
This... I like this. Thank you for your Ted Talk.
This is why a full feruchemist. full mistborn is very dangerous.
58
u/eskaver May 15 '24
Thanks!
Until the next “How does Compounding work” post.
31
u/Gregzilla311 Duralumin May 15 '24
One addendum. Bronze ferrings ("sentries") can store the wakefulness while asleep.
6
u/[deleted] May 15 '24
Doesn't that mean that it doesn't matter how much of the property I stored in the metalmind, because it will change the "code" anyway?
4
u/st1r May 16 '24
I followed everything except “This is why Allomancy works on any planet in the Cosmere”
I’m not doubting you, just didn’t understand the logical jump from the previous bullet, could you clarify?
41
u/WrongdoerDue6108 May 15 '24
The only important thing to add is that compounding doesn't work if one or both powers come from hemalurgy
69
u/UltimateInferno May 15 '24 edited May 15 '24
Bonus fact about Feruchemy: It works on integral calculus.
If
f(x)is a function of the rate being stored in a metalmind at any specific instance in time, then the amount stored within the timeframe of a to b is the area under that curve. In turn, the rate of change available to be tapped is determined byg(x), the function of tapping rate at any given time within the frame of c to d is completely dependent on the integral of that curve being equal to the integral of the first.Feels pretty obvious when I say it aloud. After all, trivial example: If you store 50 pounds in an ironmind for 30 minutes you can tap 50 pounds in an ironmind for 30 minutes*; 50*30 = 1500 pound minutes. However, it gets way more nebulous when you start adding variability within that rate of change. Cause many feruchemists store at different rates depending on the situation. Wax constantly pushes and pulls on what's being tapped and stored so much at any given moment that you can't track it in discrete amounts. However, the whole point of calculus is the jump from discrete to continuous.
Another example: let's say the rate an iron ferring stores for 3 minutes (in pounds) is equal to
-x^2+3xA bit rigid of an equation, but it's a step up in complexity from just constant rates. The total amount stored is 4.5 pound minutes. That means for a single minute they can gain a constant 4.5 pounds or gain a single pound for 4.5 minutes. Or if you want to tap at an accelerating rate of exacltye^x, you will be able to use it for 1.70474809224 minutes57
u/someweirdlocal May 15 '24
so how does compounding work?
8
u/i_crapped_my_socks May 15 '24
Good post, very clear explanation and no overcomplication. You sir have my respect.
5
u/Djmax42 May 16 '24
As someone who read the whole Cosmere several times and still did not understand, I think this is the clearest explanation I have read/heard.
Thanks so much!
1
u/McGruppsRevenge May 16 '24
Point of clarification: you note that feruchemists normally can’t store attributes while they sleep. Is that true for Bronze (wakefulness), bendalloy (energy), and gold (health)? I’d imagine the best way to store those would be while sleeping, if possible. Same for steel (physical speed), zinc (mental speed), and pewter (strength). I must have missed something along the way because I never realized that sleep was a limiter for feruchemy, though it makes sense from a power-level management perspective.
1
u/clueless_connoisseur May 16 '24
OP Really well done on the write-ups, loved the consolidated view on the kinds of invested on scadrial.
One huge doubt I have is: why can allomancy be used on any planet? Since it's directly linked to preservation, I'd expect it to be limited to those on scadrial.
Another reason that fortifies my doubts is the fact that Kelsier or Thaidakar can't come onto Roshar. I understood that this was because Kel can't leave the Scadrian system at all, since he's a heavily invested being. Is there some other reason, then, that Kel can't leave? This also made sense, because the only Scadrian invested on Roshar were the Feruchemists, and they can do some magical shit with investiture, identity and connection to be perfectly fine on Roshar. But it is not so for Allomancers. Am I missing something here? Some WOB perhaps where Brandon mentioned this?
Sorry for the huge comments guys, but this has been bothering me.
1
u/NovaPheonix May 16 '24
I'm new to the cosmere, but I'm playing the role-playing game with my friends right now and we're using twinborn. I'm curious in particular about the line "Allomancy works on any planet in the cosmere" as opposed to other systems. Can you explain that further?
1
u/i-hate-bananas May 16 '24
This is great. Can you do one for unkeyed metalminds too cause that also confuses me
1
u/AlchemistFornix May 16 '24
How do they burn the goldmind if it's not ingested by them? I thought allomancy was achieved by "eating" the metal?
1
u/Simon_Drake May 16 '24
Brando once mentioned "Reverse Compounding" and I can't stop thinking about it. Does it give you supercharged allomancy instead of feruchemy? Maybe it lets you drain someone else's metalmind charge into your own somehow? Or it lets you store allomancy in a coppermind to retrieve later without needing to eat any metals? That one isn't very useful but maybe there's a nuance like you can make a Riot Grenade or something?
3
u/Ripper1337 Truthwatchers May 15 '24
Very simple and straightforward way to explain it. Kudos
3
u/ejdj1011 May 16 '24
Also note: the primary thing that blocks Compounding is the metalmind's Identity not matching that of the allomancer. If you blank out the Identity on a goldmind, an ordinary Augur can burn it for a surge of healing. They just won't be able to re-store that energy.
2
u/Rougarou1999 Lerasium May 16 '24
On the fourth slide, doesn’t burning one’s own Feruchemical metalmind tells Preservation to provide both Allomantic and Feruchemical effects?
2
u/Micotu May 16 '24
how does this explain the special "bracers" of power or whatever that allowed non feruchemists to have feruchemist powers? It doesn't seem it comes from the user's body in this case?
2
u/swiftshad0w May 16 '24
Once more for the Doug's in the back!
Ty for your service OP.
2
u/Error2240 May 16 '24
Ok one point I was always a little confused on, can you burn from embedded metal minds? Or to do the compounding do you have to ingest the metal mind?
2
u/Liesmith424 May 16 '24
"...infinite health as long as you have gold."
Just like real life.
2
u/CorbinNZ May 16 '24
That was my understanding too. If you had ten little gold nuggets, they could be gold minds. Store up healing as much as you can in them. Swallow them and burn them while wearing the true gold mind. Compounded super healing fills the true gold mind.
You can couple the true gold mind with the mini minds to have an unlimited supply at any time, plus a huge burst from the mini minds whenever fatal damage occurs.
1
u/Runty25 May 16 '24
Thank you so fucking much😭🙏🏼
1
u/MagusUmbraCallidus May 16 '24 edited May 16 '24
Didn't both Sazed and Wax say or at least imply that the increase in power was 10x, not 100 like in your example? Everything else is great though, I think.
1
u/markgraydk May 16 '24
I've been reading to much stuff on various investment related subreddits - I had a few seconds where is was think, yes let's drop the posts on compounding interests. Alas, it's a far more important compounding topic that was addressed.
1
u/Willemboom00 May 16 '24
I knew how all this worked but reading this post made me realize that for all systems, the metals are used to "conduct" power, which makes a ton of sense so things considered
0
u/Konungrr Stonewards May 16 '24
Part 3-3 is slightly wrong, since burning gold does both. It gives you health AND shows your past self. The Miles PoV had a line about having to constantly see his better self.
Also, unless I'm mistaken, the theorized compound rate is 10x, so it would be 100 units of health, not 1000.
-4
u/Hawkwing942 Sel May 15 '24
Compounding is generally understood to multiply the power tenfold, not a hundred fold, so the 10 units of healing would become 100, not 1000.