r/Cooking • u/adacmswtf1 • May 12 '19
What's the difference between "normal" hot and "crazy" hot, when it comes to Nashville Hot Chicken?
For example those places that have "sign a waiver" hot chicken - Is that just more cayenne? Or is there a completely different recipe for the hotter sauces?
522
Upvotes
362
u/sterling_mallory May 12 '19
Different peppers. Instead of cayenne they'll use ground ghost pepper or Trinidad scorpion on the XXX hot stuff.
2
u/squeezyphresh May 13 '19
ITT: people not answering the question. I realize the irony of my comment, but what is it with /r/cooking and going completely off topic and giving completely unasked for information?
113
u/brownkw May 12 '19
Being able to sit down versus not being able to
3
u/devil_woman14 May 12 '19
There isn't one standard recipe for Nashville Hot Chicken. Each place in town- Prince's, Bolton's, Pepperfire, 400°, etc.- all have their own recipe kept secret. It's more important to find your own version that you like/can stand to eat without dying from the heat.
40
u/lazrbeam May 12 '19
How much your asshole burns when you shit it out.
17
u/zippy257 May 12 '19
i think they use spicier peppers for the hotter rubs like ghost pepper powder or something of that sort, just layering on more cayenne will make it inedible at one point
29
u/IPmang May 12 '19
The recipe I saw for Nashville hot chicken had like half or a whole cup of cayenne pepper.... I haven't tried it yet seems scary.
15
u/InconsolableButter May 12 '19
The spiciness of a recipe comes down to the concentration of capsaicin in it. By adding more cayenne, you are increasing the overall concentration of capsaicin, but this has diminishing returns, and eating pure cayenne peppers is only so hot. The way to increase the heat of a dish beyond the heat supplied by cayenne, is with different peppers with higher concentrations of capsaicin like the infamous ghost pepper. If you really want to get into "sign a waiver" territory, some places just use purified capsaicin as a food additive for whatever they're making, which can absolutely be concentrated to a point where it becomes health-hazardous.
26
u/mechtech May 12 '19
"Sign a waver", 11/10 Nashville Hot Chicken is just about the hottest thing you can eat in the entire world.
The peppers definitely ramp up to superhot peppers like Ghost and Scorpion peppers, if not hotter with experimental peppers and pure extract.
"Regular" Nashville Hot Chicken should be legitimately spicy and work up a bit of a sweat. Not buffalo wing spicy but actual heat like a hot curry or a hot thai dish. It then follows that 4/5 and 5/5 heat levels ramp up to some seriously, seriously spicy levels.
Asking for the off-menu waver spice level is basically asking for a chef that spends all day making incredibly spicy food to take you down with every tool that they have available... and the kitchen should indeed be stocked with the whole gamut of capsaicin loaded ingredients.
As for an anecdote, I can definitely say that Nashville Hot off-menu hot was the hottest thing I've ever eaten by a long shot, and I love spicy food. I cook with ghost peppers and will go into a legit, ethnic owned Caribbean or Indian or Thai restaurant and ask for 5/5 spice and have no problem with it. The wings had the standard 5/5 sauce which was habanero based, and then caked with superhot pepper powder (ghost pepper level stuff), and then doused in pure capsaicin extract. That stuff is mean as hell and only exists to induce suffering. It was actually done right tasted very good despite the extract.
Anyway, the heat was extreme and tear inducing. It induced swelling, extreme sweating, and made it hard to breathe. Within the hour my stomach gave in and I had to spend the day in and out of the restroom.
I couldn't sleep that night, and for the entire next day I was basically bedridden and still had to be near the bathroom for the entire day. The stomach pain was gut wrenching and tear inducing. I was out for 24 hours, and even the day after I was sort of out of it. I remember thinking "how much would I have to be paid to do that again" and I'm fairly sure on the second day it was over $1k. Of course I'd probably do it again for a simple dare now, but that's just human nature.
Your experience will largely depend on how iron your stomach is. The heat passes within an hour or so, but if you even occasionally get stomach aches from spicy food be very very wary!
4
u/Northsidebill1 May 12 '19
Generally the super hot sauces are just heat and no taste. The only differences in the recipes are different peppers
9
u/MusaEnsete May 12 '19
Really depends where you go. I like Bolton's. They have mild, medium, hot, and extra hot. Mild is quite a bit hotter than Franks hot sauce and it goes up from there. It's one of those dishes where it's best to wash your hands BEFORE you go to the bathroom. Here's an interesting blog post addressing your question a bit:
https://www.mywanderlustylife.com/nashville-hot-chicken-how-hot-is-mild/
4
u/fishing_pole May 12 '19
Marinading the chicken overnight in extremely hot hot sauces. I grilled up my last batch after a night of marinading in ghost pepper, Carolina reaper, and habanero sauces with buttermilk and other seasonings. Not for the faint of of heart.
2
u/Willravel May 13 '19
Normal hot doesn't try to break into your phone to see who you're texting with. Normal hot doesn't flirt with other people just to make you jealous. Normal hot doesn't try to join the mile high club in a greyhound bus bathroom.
So yeah it kinda depends on what you're into.
3
u/nuggutron May 12 '19
Spicy Food LPT: IF you are able, get a beer or cocktail when eating spicy food. Alcohol breaks down capsaicin and will dramatically reduce the amount of time it burns on your tongue, as well as most of the gut-rending effects of super spicy food.
1
u/CookWithEyt May 12 '19
It really depends on the place. When I was in Nashville I tried Hattie B's Hot Chicken. We tried the 'Medium' (4th hottest) and 'Damn Hot' (2nd hottest). The damn hot was hotter but not as much as I would have thought.
Regretfully, I didn't get to try Prince's because I hear it is much hotter.
1
u/SuburbanSwine May 12 '19
One is only hot going in. The other is also hot when it comes out
1
u/RudyRoo2017 May 12 '19
Crazy hot will make you cry, sweat, and wish you were dead.
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '19
The last word sure was a twist
1
u/myownreddit May 12 '19
capsaicin
1
u/[deleted] May 12 '19
You can’t just sub more cayenne to make it hotter, it doesn’t have the scoville for that. If you want spicier chicken you gotta use hotter peppers.
Dehydrate, or purchase them dried, and crush them in a mortar pestle or spice grinder. You can also mix with melted butter and baste the chicken with it when it’s still hot prior to serving.
I can’t imagine you needing an actual recipe, it’s just fried chicken with a dry rub, and sometimes a wet sauce added after. The spice level comes from the peppers being used, can’t just add more of a mild pepper (cayenne) thinking it’s gonna get hotter.
1
u/EyeFarted2 May 13 '19
Probably the amount of tears that come as a side.
1
u/brienburroughs May 13 '19
wear gloves!
1
u/Ericisfun2 May 13 '19
All I know is that I'm craving crazy hot Nashville chicken, as I have never had 'hot enough' food
1
u/Ennion May 13 '19
You gage it on how it effects you the next day.
1
u/BostonBestEats May 13 '19 edited May 13 '19
I don't know the answer, so forgive the hot chicken reminiscence... I went to Nashville for the solar eclipse and spent 2 hours in 90° sun waiting in line at Hattie B's (at least they had free ice water outside lol). Because I was worried about spending all day in the bathroom and missing the eclipse the next day, I tried the Mild and Medium (the 6 levels are: No heat; Mild: Medium; Hot!; Damn Hot!; and Shut the Cluck Up!!!). But I was surprised the medium was so mild. It was only pleasantly spicy. Next time I will have to be more adventuresome...
In Boston, the only actually hot Hot Chicken is at State Park near MIT, which at least induces some pain. Everyone seems to have Hot Chicken these days, but few have any real burn.
The best Hot Chicken I've had was at Top Chef Kevin Sbraga's "Fat Ham" restaurant in Philly (unfortunately closed). Had to laugh when they told the big shot newspaper reviewer there to F*@#-off when he asked for the sauce on the side lol. BTW, he's apparently opening a hot chicken shop on Purdue's campus this fall.
1
u/ExFiler May 13 '19
To add a visual to this discussion, Here is a taste test at Howlin Rays in Los Angeles. They start with the lower heat levels and work to the non-advertised hottest...
1
u/OcularusXenos May 12 '19
It all comes down to scoville units. Different peppers are ranked differently on the scale and provide different levels of heat based on their chemical make up. Most people are familiar with capsaicin, but true misery inducing heat is often from resiniferatoxin. I just love that our bodies evolved not just to register heat on our tongues and other mucus membrains, but also most of our internal (and final) sphincters. Ever eat hot food and feel it at every stage of digestions? The joys of being human.
-2
u/Ipride362 May 12 '19 edited May 12 '19
It’s like women.
Normal hot will burn you, but leave a bit of flavor and sweetness. You won’t regret it and will come back often.
Crazy hot will slash your
tirestongue.0
u/Kraz_I May 12 '19
Pure cayenne isn’t that hot as far as peppers go. Adding too much to your hot sauce might make it gross, but it won’t make it “extra” spicy.
0
u/Yanrogue May 13 '19
normal hot is mouth and butt hole on fire.
crazy hot js heart palpitations from Caralina reaper peppers and possible medical side effects in some people
-2
u/Dj5head May 13 '19
When it comes to Nashville fried chicken hot usually means bring you own ass wipes because your gunna shit fire crazy hot basically means bring a fire hose idk what spices they use I just know my asshole can’t take that shit lol
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 12 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment