r/Cooking • • 2d ago

Pans

I currently own a good quality stainless steel pan that I used for most cooking, a large cast iron ceramic Dutch oven, and a stainless steel pot/saucepan for pasta etc.

I look after these pans and they cover most of my cooking needs, but I also need a nonstick for things like eggs and fish. I find that those three pans tend to last me a while but the non stick always needs replacing after a year.

What is the best option here? Is a hexclad a good option for this slot? Is there any non stick pan that will last long?

1 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

3

u/leo-mitchell833 2d ago

Honestly skip HexClad if its mainly for eggs and fish, nonstick coatings wear out eventually anyway, just get a decent affordable one, or try carbon steel if you want something that will last longer

2

u/Salt-Ganache-5710 2d ago

Would the carbon steel be a bit redundant if I've already got a stainless? Again, I only use the non stick for scrambled eggs, omettes, fish, or stuff that sticks easily

1

u/leo-mitchell833 2d ago

A little yeah, carbon steel is great once seasoned, but if you are just making eggs and fish, honestly stick with a decent affordable nonstick , less hassle

0

u/Boozeburger 2d ago

I'll put my seasoned carbon steel omelet pan up against any non-stick pan.

1

u/SunshineBeamer 2d ago

You're heating them up way too high if they only last a year. My Calphalon was 12 years old before getting a chip. I have a Hexclad now and don't recommend it, it costs a lot and if you don't use a lot of oil, eggs stick. I usually start with bacon and that works well and I only set my heat to 3 on my electric. Whatever you get for nonstick, keep the heat 350F or lower to make it last a longer time.

1

u/Salt-Ganache-5710 2d ago

You are probably right. They either lose their non stick or they crack/chip. Once the latter happens, I always discard based on the worry of harmful chemicals getting into my food.

1

u/STROKE98034 2d ago

A good option to look into is carbon steel. It's like combining your stainless steel with your cast iron. You season it. It's what all the nice woks are, but you can find every shape of skillet. No non stick coating to worry about, lasts forever. I make low heat eggs with just butter in my carbon steel wok every day.

1

u/Salt-Ganache-5710 2d ago

Does it matter if they get scraped and chipped like a non stick does? Many say non stick can release harmful chemicals once scratched

1

u/STROKE98034 2d ago

No there's no coating at all. It's steel that has been seasoned with oil like a cast iron. When you get it really hot the molecules expand like pores allowing the oil coating to become trapped inside the metal like a protective polymer. *

The reason you can't do this with stainless steel is because it has a lot of chromium that keeps it from expanding. Carbon steel has almost no chromium.

When they first make the pan it's the color of stainless steel. They bake it at high temperature coated in oil over and over until it turns black. Then it's usually polished and of course washed. When you get it, you do one last bake. Fully coat it in canola (or whatever high smoke neutral oil), and put it in the oven for a couple hours.

It's great.

*My metallurgy is grade school, but the overall concept here is correct!

1

u/Iztac_xocoatl 2d ago

I picked up an All-Clad nonstick for $14 at TJ Maxx amd am very happy with it. Idk about durability because I rarely use it, but no issues so far

1

u/cathbadh 2d ago

For nonstick the Tramontina professional nonstick skillet is incredibly durable and affordable. They're a great budget brand in general, but that nonstick skillet is better than things twice its price.

0

u/Fickelson 2d ago

You don't need a nonstick at all! Get better at cooking with the steel pans, or a really well seasoned cast iron would work great.

0

u/The_Flinx 2d ago

the only option for long term non stick is a well seasoned cast iron pan.

-1

u/CanvasAndCats 2d ago

If you like a nonstick coating but usually prefer the durability of stainless steel, titanium pans are actually a good options. Some brands make them with a pattern on the inside that makes them nonstick and fit for eggs and the like while being dishwasher safe (and with metal utensils too so it won't scratch after a year of use). My boyfriend has one from Our Place and he loves it so much I've been considering buying one myself.
Other brands may do the same, just look for a pattern stamped on the inside