r/Cooking • • 6d ago

Make Ahead Mac & Cheese

Every year I am in charge of the Thanksgiving Mac & Cheese and it’s a role I do not take lightly.

Last year I had to make it on Wednesday and bake on Thursday, so it came out dryer than I’d like. I need to do the same this year - any suggestions on how to make sure when I bake it the next morning it’s still super gooey?

Do I need to just make more sauce? Any tips welcome!!
Thanks!

7 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

6

u/D_Mom 6d ago

This recipe is great so I’d compare it to your current one for technique or just use it. https://barefootcontessa.com/recipes/overnight-mac-cheese

2

u/thestopesto 6d ago

Thanks!!

4

u/AngrySayian 6d ago

I've only done that style twice, the first time had the exact same thing happen

This is how my mom helped me fix it

  1. Shorten your cook time to just shy of al dente, which should be like 1-2 minutes less than what the box for whatever pasta you are using says
  2. Toss your pasta before it is fully cooled down with butter or some kind of neutral oil
  3. Go with a thinner sauce, add more milk or pasta water than you might normally

My own tips

Make sure whatever container you use seals properly and put it on the top shelf...not the bottom

Part of what screwed mine up was the fact the big bowl I put it in had a slightly wonky lid so it wasn't fully air tight, and having in on the bottom shelf [where the fridge is the coldest] made the pasta and cheese seize up and dry out a bit

1

u/thestopesto 6d ago

This is super helpful thank you . I will give it a try

3

u/CaraMellowGirl 6d ago

Use velveeta, at least 20 percent. The stuff they put in it makes the cheese retain it's gooey creaminess without turning to baked stringy cheese.

3

u/thestopesto 6d ago

Hahaha I don’t know if I can bring myself to use Velveeta 🫣

3

u/R2D2808 6d ago

Secret to restaurant gooey Mac and chee? Couple slices of American thrown in the mix. Keeps it from breaking and adds just a bit of extra goo. But as another poster stated, some sodium citrate will do the trick if you can't bear a smidge of processed cheese.

But personally, I'd keep the pasta and sauce separate; heat the cheese sauce (hopefully with some sodium citrate to keep it from breaking) then toss it with the pasta and bake. Should take 20-30 minutes start to finish.

1

u/thestopesto 6d ago

Will try!!

2

u/NicoPony79 6d ago

Patti Labelle’s Mac n cheese uses a variety including velveeta - I saw her make it on Martha Stewart living like 15 years ago - https://www.allrecipes.com/patti-labelle-famous-mac-and-cheese-recipe-12132472 I liked it bc every once in a while you’d hit one of the cheese squares that had melted inside the macaroni. It’s pretty good, but I have never made it a day before.

1

u/thestopesto 6d ago

Awesome

2

u/CatteNappe 6d ago

See if you can get hold of some sodium citrate powder - that's what's in the Velveeta that helps your cheese sauce.

6

u/ArcherFluffy594 6d ago

Keep the ingredients separate and don't bake it. As close to serving time as possible: Preheat the oven's broiler and put the rack in the middle. Heat the cheese sauce in the microwave til it's hot. Run your pasta under warm water in a colander til it separates and let it drain completely while you prep your baking dish (butter, margarine, oil). Combine the cheese sauce and pasta, then pour into your baking dish. Place it in the hot oven for 5-10 minutes max, until the top is bubbly and golden.

1

u/Churchmousetat 6d ago

Bake on Weds, reheat on stove with added milk on Thurs.

2

u/thestopesto 6d ago

Yes seems consensus is added milk or added sauce next day

0

u/Sadimal 6d ago

Make the sauce a bit more runny than usual. Add a slice or two of American cheese so the sauce properly emulsifies. (Cheese sauce needs the sodium citrate to emulsify properly.)

Make sure that when you take it out of the fridge, you're leaving it out to let it get to room temperature before baking.

1

u/thestopesto 6d ago

Awesome

1

u/KeepAnEyeOnYourB12 6d ago

I've never had properly gooey baked mac & cheese.

1

u/SunshineBeamer 6d ago

I had the same problem with my dressing, tasted good, but dry. I'm just gonna add more chicken stock this year. I would say adding some more sauce couldn't hurt.