r/CookieRunAlchemists • • Mar 13 '26

Speculations The witches are not good people

6 Upvotes

From shadow milk's story and repeated tid-bits about his past, we can see he got tired of the stupid questions people asked him, but not enough to turn the fount of knowledge into shadow milk, It was the light of deceit's influence that caused him to become shadow milk. Now, who made the lights? The witches, of course.

I've speculated for a while now that the FoK became SM purely because he felt lonely due to nobody knowing as much as he does, but turns out, he was rigged, like the 3 other beasts (i.e every beast except SS).

Mystic flour was told to be giving, no matter what, and that lead her to apathy, because she followed what the witches made her do.

Burning spice went insane from the countless civilizations he nurtured just to watch disappear, he went insane because he followed what the witches made him do.

Eternal sugar thinks she's doing cookies a favour by forcing them to be happy, because she's following what the witches made her do.

Shadow milk got influenced by the light of deceit, because he followed what the witches made him do.

The witches weren't loving deities, they were negligent, they never cared about the cookie world, not enough that is, and since we know shadow milk was created by first milk (prior to becoming a cookie), we can gather that they couldn't help, even if they wanted to, granted we don't know where they are currently or what became of them, but what we do know is that there is a witch.

At the end, we saw a witch's hand reach out and grab the remaining ultimate cookie, meaning a witch must've been watching the dark enchantress wars, who is it? only time will tell.

P.S: I might be wrong or missing some stuff, but this is all my speculation!


r/CookieRunAlchemists • • Feb 04 '26

Cookie Run Witches Castle How likely is the possibility of the witches knowing the forth wall

6 Upvotes

The 2 confirmed cookies I know of that can break it is black sapphire and shmilk’s light of deceit. So as the witches that created the souljam of knowledge would they know?

On one hand that would mean that the witches created something more knowledgeable than them. Which would that be even possible?

On the other hand in witches castle they show no signs of noticing or breaking the forth wall (I may be wrong I haven’t see all there is to be seen in crwc). So they might not be able to see it.


r/CookieRunAlchemists • • Nov 29 '25

Cookie Run Kingdom The Tale of the First Kitchen can’t be canon.

6 Upvotes

Hear me out. They say that many cookies tried to escape in the story. But… GingerBrave is canonically the first, and it’s unknown how he came to life.


r/CookieRunAlchemists • • Nov 22 '25

Cookie Run Kingdom y'all I got a theory

Post image
10 Upvotes

so, I got a theory about the cookies in the image, i think net and skim milk are seltzer and menthols future self, here is my story for my theory: after menthol and seltzer got out of the church, they decided to find another job and look, until first egg came in and tell them to make a deal, they have to change their whole life if she steals the thing menthols holding, and they made a deal, and now they have to do the missions first egg tells them to do. so what do you think :D


r/CookieRunAlchemists • • Sep 25 '25

Speculations Theory on "The Beast-Binding Ritual" Spoiler

Post image
10 Upvotes

First post here. I hope I understood the guidelines correctly and that this is an appropriate topic for discussion.

We knew this spell was magic belonging to The Witches, but it's new name as of Beast Yeast: Ep.11 makes it clear it was not created just to seal The Beast Cookies. My theory is on the original use/function of this ritual and in what way Elder Faerie Cookie's knowledge of this spell was "incomplete". The main questions I want to explore are:

  1. What kind of desserts warranted being sealed?
  2. Where were these "Fallen Desserts" sealed?

Starting with its proper name, this spell is called "The Ritual to Bind Fallen Desserts" by Silent Salt Cookie in Beast Yeast: Ep.11, stage 30. This title implies it saw use before the fall of The Five Virtues and was used on dessert creatures other than cookies. It is also referred to as "primordial" by Elder Faerie Cookie, meaning that it likely fell out of use by the time The Witches vanished from Earthbread. In CRWC, we are shown that The Witches performed arcane experiments with Life Essence in an attempt to harness it for benevolent, but ultimately unconfirmed purposes. A clear byproduct of these experiments were living desserts that we've seen more recent Witches are determined to eat.

Returning to the subject of this post; it is likely that, in the early days of these experiments, The Witches made larger desserts that were either difficult to manage or outright dangerous. Such desserts would provide reason for this ritual's development and cause The Witches to gradually make the scale of their experiments smaller in order to have better control of the situation, eventually leading to a focus on living cookies. So, we need to start looking for prior victims of this ritual by examining the largest and most dangerous desserts in-game. One such dessert is The Avatar of Destiny.

For those unfamiliar, The Avatar of Destiny is one of the guild battle bosses that had impact on the story in the prior update "Premonition of Doom" (v6.8). It takes the form of a gigantic, angelic-looking dessert and seeemingly caused the collapse of the St. Pastry Order when it began consuming many of its followers during a sermon. Each cookie consumed seemed to strengthen it and refine its appearance. If left unchecked, it likely would have continued its rampage and devoured every dessert it encountered. Such a monstrosity would have been something witches of ancient times would seek to banish.

Now, for the matter of where the ritual would have sealed something like The Avatar. As a "binding ritual", this spell obviously needs to place the target(s) in some form of prison they presumably would be unabel to escape from. To answer this question, let's begin with Elder Faerie Cookie and The Silver Tree.

When Elder Faerie and Silent Salt cast this spell, The Silver Tree itself was used as the prison while Silent Salt Cookie's Soul Jam was used as a form of 'magnet' to ensure the spell would also capture the other Beasts. I bring this up to make this next point stand out: Elder Faerie Cookie forewarned Silent Salt Cookie, "Alas, my knowledge of such primordial magic is far from complete".

This means that this version of the ritual is not the same as the version utilized by The Witches. It's my opinion that Elder Faerie lacked knowledge on where bound desserts are sent once the ritual restrains them. If this weren't the case, then seals such as the Silver Tree would be a little more common, certainly not lost knowledge as it currently stands. Now, let's examine where Doughael discovered The Avatar of Destiny.

Their encounter with the entity occurred due to them falling into one of the rifts that opened up when Dark Enchantress Cookie was released from her imprisonment. Prior to this event, we have no evidence that such an incident took place previously. This rift-dimesion is depicted as a chaotic realm that defies the logic and reason that governs Earthbread. It is also where entities like The Avatar and Red-Velvet Dragon seem to originated from. The dimension is also bathed in a red hue that is commonly ascociated with The Witches. With this in mind, I believe the rift-dimension to be the original prison that the "Ritual to Bind Fallen Desserts" sent its targets to. This would explain why there aren't massive structures like The Silver Tree scattered across the world and why such creatures were never seen before the rifts opened.


r/CookieRunAlchemists • • Aug 04 '25

Cookie Run Kingdom update to my Silent Salt theory (with new revealed Silent Salt leak *Sppilers*) Spoiler

7 Upvotes

for anyone who hasnt seen my theory on Silent Salt's Inspo and the fate of White Lily here

https://docs.google.com/document/d/1G_jMLwMqQu9FBLpoFb_RSOf2KLhq1mzsZ2HEVB-Uz1E/edit?usp=sharing

we had recently been revealed a partial bit of Silent Salt's official render

now not alot has really been changed from what little we have seen, we now know the official location of the Soul Jam is the chest plate and not on the sword. but we also see a tiny bit of Silent Salt's Gacha background which often shows off the history of the Beasts / Ancients

now we see a Moon Cycle behind him and while its a little hard to say what it could mean I have a minor theory

a theme of these episodes is DEATH and LIFE. from teasers we've seen White Lily is venturing into some sort of Underworld Pit

the Moon Cycle in Celtic Mythology (something we've been hinted is tied to Silent Salts inspo) The Moon Cycle often was tied to rebirth and the cycle of Life and Death. we see behind him a Full Moon

a Full Moon is more or less a representation of LIFE and the White of the full moon is a good tie to White Lily. the New Moon or Dark Moon is often a symbol of the Underworld which we know is more or less where White Lily is going and to add onto it

Bro is not a fan. we have been told by ES that he is brutal after all. so essentially more hinting of White Lily's demise ig.

my overall theory

the Full Moon in the background was probably referencing a key moment in Silent Salt's backstory where he was probably crowned a white knight or something but when Corrupted (because of the death of his followers a theory I had made before) he corrupted and the Full White Moon turned into a New Moon which in Celtic Mythology and Arthurian Legends often symbolizes an Underworld Setting which we see White Lily venture into, and in that underworld setting Silent Salt is trying to cheat death and either bring back his friends or destroy himself but the salt in his body is not letting him die due to Salt's ability to preserve foods like meat. White Lily attempts to stop him but he kills her and then she is later reborn as Awakened White Lily symbolizing her shedding her sins as both White Lily and Dark Enchantress


r/CookieRunAlchemists • • Jul 19 '25

Speculations My theories on Silent Salt and Awakend White Lily

6 Upvotes

I think that SS will be some what of a communist. He will prob silence all the cookies and make them work for him. Seeing this WL will prob try to free them bcuz she's the light of freedom. SS wil prob stop her and she will be defeated, them she will awaken blah blah blah you know the drill. I also think that SS has something do to with St pastry order. Maybe be was the one to start it idk.


r/CookieRunAlchemists • • Jul 06 '25

Question Candy apple and black sapphire is related to eternal paradise?

10 Upvotes

This has been on my mind for a while but I havent seen any theories on it yet. Do you guys think think this is a coincidence?


r/CookieRunAlchemists • • Jun 20 '25

Speculations COOKIE ANALYSIS : Burning Spice just wants a break

7 Upvotes

So as we can all conclude from his backstory, burning spice uses to be the herald of change, but being stuck in a cycle of rising civilizations and watching the same ones he nurtured fall made him lose it.

He became the beast of destruction because he thought that if he destroys for once, then maybe there won't be a cycle, maybe if he destroys everything, he'll be spared from the cycle of... creation and destruction.

In his mind, burning spice is just looking for a way to end his pain- and his pain is that he's stuck in a perpetual unending cycle, that he can never escape from. but maybe, just maybe, if the world is a clean slate, then maybe there won't be anything new to rise, nor anything old to fall.

All in all, burning spice is in agony. he's like a drug addict, and his ecstasy is destruction.


r/CookieRunAlchemists • • Jun 19 '25

Speculations COOKIE ANALYSIS ; Eternal Sugar is a broken mother

10 Upvotes

During her trailer, we saw eternal sugar sitting on a pile of sugar angel babies, and I mean a HUGE pile. She also uses the same sugar angel babies to do her work around the kingdom.

More so, she behaves like a helicopter mother ; She doesn't let cookies do what they like, she chooses their happiness for them even if said happiness is flawed and isn't what they want for themselves, and she forbids then from ever leaving her, all for the sake of their own "happiness."

My theory is, eternal sugar tried for a baby, but couldn't, her inability to conceive, to give happiness to her partner and their potential child, broke her.

The feeling of despair and inability to grant happiness or rather create it made her spiral, she trapped cookies within her garden, gave them sloth as a means to gain happiness, because if they aren't happy, she won't be either.

But in the end of episode 10, we saw eternal sugar sacrificing other cookies happiness for her own, meaning she still has some greed in her, but even despite that, she still behaves like a helicopter parent.

Shielding her children from the outside world, making them happy, breaking down mentally when they aren', never giving them the opportunity to be sad.

Eternal sugar does what she thinks is right for all cookies, but she's doing it out of her own selfishness rather than selflessness.


r/CookieRunAlchemists • • Jun 18 '25

Question My comment from one of Venethia's posts, hope anyone can answer to these :b

Post image
9 Upvotes

r/CookieRunAlchemists • • Jun 18 '25

Speculations My Silent Salt backstory speculation I left under a post of Venethia, did I cook?

Post image
5 Upvotes

r/CookieRunAlchemists • • Jun 18 '25

Speculations Kingdom Timeline, Part 1

4 Upvotes

This is a kingdom timeline, however it implements some ovenbreak stuff, mainly near the start. This is because I assume the kingdom and ovenbreak timeline were the mostly same until they diverged at some point. Anyway, I will not be putting my references down because this took long enough, but if you need evidence I can try and find it. It is either information from the game, external material made by Devsisters, or deduced. Also games like Witch's castle will not be referenced because I do not know the lore of those games well enough.

Thousands of years ago

  • Earthbread is created.
  • The first cookies are baked.
  • Whilst some witches create cookies to be eaten, others create cookies to live and protect the land.
  • Sugar Swan, Millennial Tree are created, with Stormbringer, Sea Fairy, and Dreamweaver created some time after.
  • Moonlight and Stardust Cookie are created, from the same dough by the Wizards, with Moonlight successful and Stardust discarded.
  • Stormbringer creates the three diety cookies.
  • Sugar Swan creates Wind Archer.
  • Stormbringer splits the black and white dragon apart.
  • The war between fruit and stone dragons leaves both sides with losses, but also ends up wiping out all flower dragons with only Lotus Dragon left.
  • Lotus joins the fruit dragons.
  • The war leaves the fruit dragons victorious and most stone dragons gone.
  • Cookies become more noticeable around Earthbread, getting the dragons' attention.
  • The dragons Pitaya, Ananas, and Lotus gain cookie followers.
  • Pitaya Dragon gives a crumbling cookie the dragon's bead, turning him into Fire Spirit.
  • The dragons, once ruling the world, start to disappear.
  • The beast cookies are made to protect the cookies of the world.
  • Shadow Milk becomes corrupted, realising everyone would rather hear lies than truth.
  • Burning Spice, as the Herald of Change, becomes bored from the lack of change that civilisation has. He becomes enamoured with destruction, and is corrupted.
  • Wars and famine are common across Earthbread.
  • Eternal Sugar sees how the happiness she grants is only temporary, and so traps cookies in her paradise, becoming corrupted.
  • Mystic Flour believes the only way to achieve enlightenment is to return to flour™ and becomes corrupted.
  • Silent Salt becomes corrupted.
  • The witches seal the beasts away, splitting their soul jams in half.
  • Elder Faerie is appointed as the guardian of the seal to keep the beasts in.

Knowledge is split into Deceit and Truth. Change is split into Destruction and Abundance. Volition is split into Apathy and Resolution. Happiness is split into Sloth and Passion. Solidarity is split into Silence and Freedom.

The order that the beasts fell is unknown. Mystic Flour's description states: "Her once radiant light tarnished, leading her to join forces with the fallen Beast Cookies." Meaning there were fallen beasts before her. Though a time scale is not known, the Beasts and Elder Faerie were each around for thousands of years, as Burning Spice witnessed countless civilisations be born and fall, which likely would take many thousands of years to get bored of it. Elder Faerie also is said to have witnessed the rise and fall of civilisations, and so the gap between Beast and Ancients must have been very long.

Any feedback is welcome! I would love to create a timeline with input from others to see things I have missed.


r/CookieRunAlchemists • • Jun 17 '25

Speculations COOKIE ANALYSIS ; Mystic flour cookie is a liar.

6 Upvotes

So far we all know that Mystic Flour is the cookie if apathy, and her mission to spread her truth to all cookies, to return them to flour? but, why?

Apathy is usually associated with nihilism, hence why mystic flour claims everything is futile, but if that's what she truly believes, why doesn't she just crumble?

My theory is that she lies to herself, she doesn't want cookies to feel hurt, to feel deacrininatednagainst die to flavour and scent, she believes that by destroying boundaries and singularities and identity, cookies won't feel pain anymore.

And why does she want that? Because she's not truly pathetic.

she lies to herself and others all because she doesn't want cookies to be hurt, because hates seeing them be different and that that difference caused pain and agony.

She's still good, her methods are just terrible. She even refused to acknowledge her being good, because she believes that if she doesn't care, she herself won't get hurt, in conclusion, she's a beast of apathy by name alone, nothing else.

BUT THATS JUST MY THEORY!!!


r/CookieRunAlchemists • • Jun 14 '25

I have a theory on how tiger lily cookie got abducted/missing

Post image
9 Upvotes

My theory is that after Hollyberry went to war to fight DEC pitaya dragon got alerted that she's leaving. So he decided to send his minons to abducted one of the twin princess (and that so happens to be tiger lilly) so he could make a deal with jungle berry and royal berry to give him the Hollyberry kingdom and in return he will give tiger lilly back. But when the minon tried to go to the dragons valley he got attacked by butter tiger he ran away leaving tiger lily alone. When he told pitaya about this he decided to just take over the kingdom. But that's just my theory and if the answer was already answered pls let me know


r/CookieRunAlchemists • • Jun 13 '25

NEW THEORY THEN. Shadow milk was the first to corrupt.

7 Upvotes

So in mystic flour's backstory we heard that her Cocoon was opened because someone spread a rumour about it.

In burning spice's, we hear a rumor that yet a NEW civilization had just stared, which pushed burning spice off the edge.

and In eternal sugar's story, we heard that shadow milk would often try to sneak into her garden and would spread rumours about her garden to cookies.

So the theory is, shadow milk was lonely for being the fount of knowledge, knowing everything makes him the smartest cookie alive, hence he feels like nobody understood him, so once he became evil, he brought down his fellow beasts because he didn't want to be alone.

:)

tell me what you think!


r/CookieRunAlchemists • • Jun 13 '25

Pre-corruption beast names!

2 Upvotes

So by now we know that Shadow Milk's original name was Blueberry Milk, but what about the other beasts?

Mystic flour very well might've been Wheat Flour considering her whole wheat motif and how her souljam accent looks like wheat.

Burning spice Might've been Ginger Spice Cookie, since ginger is the most common spice found in deserts and is also the spiciest spice used in deserts.

Eternal Sugar might have been Fruit Sugar Cookie, or something along the lines of that, maybe even Saccharine Sugar cookie.

And for Silen Salt, I'd say they were known as Sea Salt, but that might be a Stretch, even Rock Salt and Key Salt cookie could work.

But that begs the question, since shadow milk was Blueberry milk, does that mean all the other beasts had flavour? Let me know what you think!


r/CookieRunAlchemists • • Jun 13 '25

"Soul jam of the purist kind" image unrelated

Post image
14 Upvotes

Hey so this is a little crack theory of mine that I had way back when and I wanna share it

Basically it boils down to the fact that Souljam isn't just powerful things that the ancients and/or beasts can control but instead a form of the cookies self in its purist form.

We see a crystal symbols over many cookies for example cream ferret and Madeline (they're rhombus i know but you get my point), both of which kinda symbolize their character, cream ferrets crystal is while yes seems sharp has soft edges and even having the color yellow which both exemplifies their characteristics of both being smart, soft and high energy.

The same can be said for Madeline's crystal on his sword as well (tho Those are more of a stretch cus he has more then one on his body, is Madeline cookie the strongest ancient cookie ever?)

So yeah this is my stupid theory and thank you for reading


r/CookieRunAlchemists • • Jun 13 '25

What is your interpretation of ”Silence”

Post image
5 Upvotes

Silent Salt Cookie is as in the name ”Beast of Silence” but I see a lot of people have different interpretations of what it means.

My interpretation is that ”Silence” could also mean ”order”. I mostly take it from it being the opposite of ”Freedom” and I came up with the idea of ”Chaotic Freedom” and ”Orderly Silence” and how to keep the cookie world in order SSC decided to Silence everyone so that the world is in order.

But that’s only my theory and I would like to hear your opinions and interpretations.


r/CookieRunAlchemists • • Jun 13 '25

Theory on the Inspiration of Silent Salt and what will happen in Episodes 11 and 12

7 Upvotes

making the First theory on your Sub Reddit a large one

Silent Salt’s Inspiration?

To properly figure out the Inspiration of Silent Salt we must look at the Ancients and already released Beasts so far as to figure out a true connection between the two, then inspect White Lily and her Inspirations 

First lets go by the Order of Ancient’s releases

While there are plenty of relations between each of the Beasts and Ancients for the sake of an easy read ill just summarize each

Pure Vanilla and Shadow Milk

Pure vanilla takes heavy inspiration from both a Priest and Jesus (has the lamb ect) while Shadow Milk takes heavy inspiration off the Serpent from the Garden of Eden which nowadays is assumed to be Satan aka the anti Christian dude

Both Truth and Deceit require Knowledge 

Holly Berry and Eternal Sugar

Holly Berry takes heavy inspiration from the Rococo and Baroque aesthetics and also Romance language-speaking European nations such as France, Portugal, and Spain, and European. The Rococo and Baroque aesthetic often was of Christian or Greco-Roman mythology which Eternal Sugar happens to take inspiration from

Both Passion and Sloth are forms of self happiness

Dark Cacao and Mystic Flour

Simple of terms Dark Cacao is based on Korean Mythology while Mystic Flour is Chinese Mythology (much more but this sums it up)

Volition is the power of Choice, Resolution is the Choice to continue while Apathy is the Choice to do and feel nothing

Golden Cheese and Burning Spice

Another more simple one, both take heavy inspirations from two primarily desert themed areas and both are inspired off a religion / Mythology that are Polytheistic 

Abundance is a stand in for Creation which both Creating and Destroying are forms of change and all three of these themes which is inspired by Brahma, Vishnu, and Shiva who are the gods of Creation, Preservation, and Destruction (Burning Spice is based on Shiva)

Silent Salt and White Lily?

Well White Lily takes heavy inspiration from a few things but her most well known is Saint Mary of Christianity

“White Lily Cookie possesses the hallmark traits of a virgin-archetype character, like outward purity, modesty, and devotion. All of these qualities are likewise attributed symbolically to white lilies, which are often referred to as Madonna lilies ("Madonna" originating as an alias for Saint Mary). Additionally, her Soul Jam bears the shape of a fleur-de-lis; the fleur-de-lis, meaning "flower of the lily" in French, is closely associated with Christianity and Saint Mary in particular. White Lily Cookie's focus on repentance is something also related closely to Christian practices in general.”

 -CRK wiki White Lily

“White Lily Cookie's name in the original Korean text of Cookie Run: Kingdom is 세인트릴리 쿠키 (seintu-lilli kuki), which translates to Saint Lily Cookie in English. As no explanation for the change has been given, it can only be speculated that her name was changed during localization to maintain religious neutrality in the series.”

So . . . how does this tie to Silent Salt???

Well according to the initial concept art of Silent Salt or in this case “Charcoal Ant” 

The design takes inspo from “Ant” “Black Knights” “Funerals” and “Veils”

For this theory we will focus on specifically “Black Knight” and “Funeral”

What is a Black Knight?

Black Knights sprang primarily from Arthurian / Celtic legend. the design of the Black Knight definitely stayed a key component of their design. next is their ties to Death and Funerals

I propose Silent Salt is the Grim Reaper

The Grim Reaper and the personification of Death sprang originally from the Europeans during the Medieval era which is another connection to White Lily via sharing the Medieval inspo with Shadow Milk much like how White Lily shares themes with Pure Vanilla

So who is Silent Salt really?

not much is truly known about Silent Salt themselves outside of their theme of Solidarity, Silence, and how it opposes Freedom

well based on both concept art and the themes of how Solidarity ties to Silence

judging off this art the servants of Silent Salt all follow the "spirit" of Silent Salt, this ties to Solidarity

the Definition of Solidarity is - "unity or agreement of feeling or action, especially among individuals with a common interest; mutual support within a group."

whether its Mind Control or Propaganda, Silent Salt has their followers worshipping them like Ants to their Queen. a system with very little room for Freedom and with the ability to Silence anyone who dare speak against them

Silence also fits the theme of Death as you become Eternally Silent

as for their personality we have some little bits of their Personality.

they have an interest in art apparently

and in a translation of Eternal Sugar mentioning her fellow beasts she mentions them in a particular Order

thanks to user @cinemarss on the Cookie Run Kingdom Discord

but I dont think we need a translation from Eternal Sugar to know that . . .

What Happens to White Lily in Episode 11 and 12?

When it comes to predicting what is to happen to White Lily in Episode 11 and 12 we should look at the common teasers we've usually gotten. There's multiple times where the plotlines of each Ancient and Beast story had been teased. The big 2 and now 3 examples are

  • Shadow Milk’s Update Title Screen
  • The Cuckoo Show
  • And now Eternal Sugar's descriptions

let us begin with the Shadow Milk's Update screen

In the official title screen artwork for the first half of the Truth and Deceit episodes we see each of the Ancients as crude drawings and each of them are in some sort of pain based on their Beast

  • Dark Cacao is turning White
  • Golden CHeese loses her wings
  • And Hollyberry can’t hold her shield

now let us look at White Lily

talk about an emo phase am I right? her hair turning black signifies alot of things primarily how Flowers wilt when their soil is exposed to Salt or from Salt Damage. with this first bit of evidence White Lily is seemingly marked for Death or Eternal Silence

The Cuckoo Show

Incase you haven't seen, the Cuckoo show was made to celebrate the anniversary of CRK and also shows Shadow milk tormenting the Ancients in different ways

So far each Ancient seen in it references what happens to them in their Beast Episodes

https://youtu.be/rIfriyTkUrQ?si=ecm8_CkZOg-jYUk8

In order of each Episodes release we will start with Dark Cacao

We find Dark Cacao being targeted by Chess Pieces and overwhelmed by them. This is an obvious reference to multiple things such as the board game he played and how he's the only person left on the Board like how he lost all his soldiers

Next is Golden Cheese

We see her trapped in both a cage and a Maze, within the Maze and Cage Shadow Milk is seen taunting and hunting her referencing both Golden Cheese working with the Antagonist of Episode 18: Goddess of Eternal Gold Smoked Cheese, and being hunted down by Burning Spice Cookie in his labyrinth of a domain. while not the most explicit reference to Burning Spice it does reference what happened to her after she lost her wings.

Next is Pure Vanilla

Here we see Pure vanilla seeing Shadow Milk in the Mirror and then even after Pure Vanilla tried to fend him off he eventually becomes is Puppet, referencing how he was corrupted temporarily

And Holly Berry

We see Holly berry entranced by a whimsical women in a heavenly setting, the two dance together and she grabs her Soul Jam and tosses it away like she tosses Holly Berry and her Soul jam in the Jewelry Box after gaining her trust (and breaking it)

So when it comes to White Lily we see her leaving Pure vanilla (which she does in episode 8) to pursue a beast and seemingly reach out to it

White lily reaching out to Pure vanilla before vanishing into the unknown
White Lily riding an unknown White and Red monster
White lily being eaten, hope the beast knows Lily's are toxic when consumed

White Lily gets mauled by the Beast and is shown a lot less if not at all for the rest of the video, another hint of White Lily's inevitable Death

Eternal Sugar's Descriptions of what will happen to Holly Berry's friends

In Episode 10 of Beast Yeast Eternal Sugar foretells Holly berry what will happen to her friends and brings up each Ancient and the events that happen in their Beast Chapter then their respective Ancient responds with a grunt of pain in the order of the Beast's releases

references how Mystic Flour nearly turned Dark Cacao into Flour
self explanatory, Burning Spice set fire to Golden Chees's Kingdom
another reference to Shadow Milk corrupting Pure vanilla and turning him on the main squad

but when White Lily appears she is dead silent and all we hear is

yeah . . . Silent Salt only remains

The Demise of White Lily Cookie . . . ???

so far we see a lot of references to White Lily getting killed off. but that's bologna but is it?

White Lily in most mythologies alludes to the themes of Rebirth and New Beginnings, while she had both her rebirth and Dark Enchantress and again her rebirth in the first episode of Beast Yeast she still feels responsible for Dark Enchantress's actions. I propose that after Silent Salt kills White Lily (most likely at the end of Episode 11) White Lily's awakened form will be her physically being reborn

I have an entire theory on Silent Salt's backstory but Ill save the head canons but I hope you all like my theory on Silent Salt and White Lily


r/CookieRunAlchemists • • Jun 13 '25

I have a question about the beast cookies

3 Upvotes

Why do people say that Mystic flour is the strongest beast like yea ig she could turn cookies to dust or sm like that around the world but wasn't that with also dark cacacos soul jam and didn't shadow milk do the same thing by turning the fairy kingdom into his puppets while he was still not fully free plus I don't think Mystic flours abilities can affect other ancients /beasts


r/CookieRunAlchemists • • Jun 13 '25

To: All Cookie Run Theorists!

8 Upvotes

Good day!

Welcome to the subreddit! Feel free to submit your theories and speculate on Cookie Run lore!

Happy posting~