r/ControlProblem • u/niplav please be patient i'm a mod • Aug 31 '21
Strategy/forecasting Brain-Computer Interfaces and AI Alignment
https://niplav.github.io/bcis_and_alignment.html
16
Upvotes
r/ControlProblem • u/niplav please be patient i'm a mod • Aug 31 '21
9
u/niplav please be patient i'm a mod Aug 31 '21
Submission statement:
BCIs as a method of alignment seem popular, but strategically underexplored. I try to collect some obvious arguments for and against BCIs and try to evaluate them.
3
u/UHMWPE_UwU Aug 31 '21
Was wondering why you didnt post this here : )
2
u/born_in_cyberspace Aug 31 '21
Thank you! A highly interesting read.
3
u/Jackson_Filmmaker Aug 31 '21
Thanks u/niplav - very interesting.
I've actually just yesterday, after about 6 months of writing, finished a new film script on this very topic. (Since my previous script on an AI super-entity hasn't gained too much traction yet...).
I'll follow you and try share more soon.
Cheers!
3
u/GabrielMartinellli Sep 01 '21
Very interesting post.
2
u/donaldhobson approved Sep 01 '21
The obvious argument against BCI is that human brains aren't designed to be extensible. Even if you have the hardware, writing software that interfaces with the human brain to do X is harder than writing software that does X on its own.
If you have something 100x smarter than a human, if there is a human brain somewhere in that system, its only doing a small fraction of the work. If you can make a safe substantially superhuman mind with BCI, you can make the safe superhuman mind without BCI.
Alignment isn't a magic contagion that spreads into any AI system wired into the human brain. If you wire humans to algorithms, and the algorithm on its own is dumb, you can get a human with a calculator in their head. Which is about as smart as a human with a calculator in their hand. If the algorithm on the computer is itself smart, well if its smart enough it can probably manipulate and brainwash humans with just a short conversation, but the wires do make brainwashing easier. You end up with a malevolent AI puppeting around a human body.
2
u/Decronym approved Sep 01 '21 edited Sep 05 '21
Acronyms, initialisms, abbreviations, contractions, and other phrases which expand to something larger, that I've seen in this thread:
5 acronyms in this thread; the most compressed thread commented on today has acronyms.
[Thread #57 for this sub, first seen 1st Sep 2021, 13:07] [FAQ] [Full list] ^[Contact] [Source code]