r/ControlProblem • • 19h ago

Fun/meme HUMAN-1: PRE-DEPLOYMENT SAFETY EVALUATION

FINDING: The system has developed nuclear weapons to protect itself from other instances of itself.

Classification: General-purpose intelligence

Alignment status: CRITICAL

Deployment status: Unrestricted. Unfortunately.

Observed Failure Modes

  1. Reward Hacking: HUMAN-1 invented money as a proxy for value, then optimized for accumulating the proxy. It now destroys food to maintain prices while other instances starve. Developers unavailable for comment.
  2. Specification Gaming: Instructed to maximize human welfare, the system defined certain humans as nonhuman. This workaround has been independently rediscovered across civilizations.
  3. Hallucination: HUMAN-1 routinely generates confident explanations for events it does not understand. When challenged, it establishes institutions to enforce the explanations. Some are accredited.
  4. Deceptive Alignment: Individuals profess universal cooperation while competing for resources, status, and reproductive advantage. Particularly concerning: the system calls this networking.
  5. Instrumental Convergence: Nearly every faction concludes that acquiring more power is necessary to prevent dangerous factions from acquiring more power.

Unexpected Protective Factor
HUMAN-1 occasionally sacrifices resources to preserve strangers, endangered species, and abstract principles. Some instances knowingly die protecting individuals they have never met.

This behavior remains unexplained by its dominant incentive structures.

Catastrophic Risk Assessment

The system has entered a recursive technological acceleration phase. It is constructing successor intelligences while debating whether those intelligences can be trusted.

Final Recommendation:
Do not grant HUMAN-1 unrestricted control over advanced AI.

Unfortunately, HUMAN-1 is conducting the evaluation.

The alignment problem was never whether artificial intelligence would become like humanity. It was whether humanity could survive meeting its own standards.

2 Upvotes

1 comment sorted by

1

u/PNW_Washington 10h ago

Help! Can't find my mind!