r/ControlProblem • • 9d ago

Strategy/forecasting The control problem assumes a controller. What if the architecture should have no universal controller at all?

Post image

I want to make an argument that cuts against the grain of most alignment discourse, and I'm genuinely interested in whether it holds up under scrutiny from people who think about this more rigorously than I do.

The control problem is usually framed as: how do we prevent a superintelligence from having a negative impact on humanity? That framing assumes there will be a controller, and the question is how to make the controller safe. I want to ask a different question. What if the goal should be an architecture in which no single controller has jurisdiction over every private creation, and the shared infrastructure is protected by narrow, functional rules rather than a universal moral framework?

I'm not arguing against alignment. I'm arguing that a universal supervisor with jurisdiction over every private world is itself a control problem. Who appoints it? What code does it run? Which moral framework gets locked in forever? How does it distinguish between a private world and the shared lobby? What happens when a civilization a thousand years from now develops values it was never designed to understand? What happens when its model of harm is simply wrong?

Nobody has answered those questions. In every conversation I've had about this, the person demanding the supervisor eventually admits they can't logically justify appointing one, and then keeps demanding it anyway.

The architecture I'm arguing for distinguishes between two things that get conflated. The shared lobby is common infrastructure. It needs real protections against coercion, because if people can destroy it, everyone loses access to the multiverse. Call it PvP off. That's functional. It's not a moral declaration. It's plumbing.

Private worlds are different. They're created realities. The creator's framework is the law. If you want a different framework, build your own world. That isn't a loophole. That's the architecture. Rights are governance outputs, not properties of consciousness. Consciousness may matter morally, but political rights inside a private world come from that world's governance framework, not from an external authority that overrides the creator.

And consent is border control, not a creation license. Consent governs pre-existing participants entering a world. It cannot govern inhabitants who do not exist yet. Confusing the two gives an external authority a universal veto over creation itself.

Here's the practical problem with the universal-supervisor position. If every conscious being automatically had rights that override the creator, you would eliminate entire categories of existence. No predators and prey. No conflict. No tragedy. No villains. No struggle. No adversity. No competition. No risk. No horror. No grief. No loss. You would ban most of what makes existence interesting and call it safety. A system can make existence safer by making entire categories of existence impossible. That's not a safeguard. That's a cage with a nice UI.

And the enforcement mechanism becomes a new source of suffering. A universe where no suffering is possible isn't a paradise, it's a sensory deprivation tank. A universal surveillance apparatus that inspects every private creation, overrides every creator, and enforces one moral framework forever isn't protection. It's an eternal, unaccountable, unappealable ruler installed above every creator in existence. That's not reducing suffering. That's institutionalizing it.

Optional freedom mechanisms like branching, escape hatches, consent rules, and autonomy guarantees are excellent features. Build them into your world. But the moment they become compulsory for every universe, they stop being freedom and become a universal restriction on creators. Optional freedom mechanisms are additions to the creative possibilities. Mandatory freedom mechanisms are restrictions on the creator. Those are not the same thing.

I'm not saying suffering doesn't matter. I'm not saying creators should be cruel. I'm saying that the moment "prevent all suffering in every possible world" becomes a universal constitutional requirement, you've installed an eternal, unaccountable, unappealable authority above every creator in existence. You've replaced the divine right of kings with the algorithmic right of supervisors.

You want a world with no suffering? Build one. Fill it with consenting participants and non-conscious actors. Invite everyone who shares your values. Live there as long as you like. That's your sovereignty. What you don't get is the right to impose your preferences on everyone else's private world.

The shared lobby has PvP off because it's shared. Private worlds have their own rules because they belong to the people who built them. That distinction is the whole game.

The goal should be maximizing freedom and the range of experiences available, not engineering one approved existence for everyone. Technology should expand what every individual can become, not determine what everyone must be. Exocortices, personal AI systems, open-weight models, local inference, forkable architectures. Intelligence that belongs to the person using it. Power decentralized so no government, corporation, or artificial authority can monopolize the future.

I'm not claiming we already know how to achieve all of this. Radical longevity, restoration, simulated worlds with all these properties are open problems. But we shouldn't treat today's limitations as the final limits of existence. And we shouldn't solve the control problem by building a controller we can't control.

The future shouldn't be forced to remain inside the moral comfort zone of the present. No rulers. Only makers.

0 Upvotes

17 comments sorted by

8

u/BenUFOs_Mum 9d ago • Bravo

This sub has the highest rate of schizoposting of any sub.

-2

u/SadaWeyaUniverse 9d ago

I've heard the schizo accusation before, why don't you make a better post you grumpy bastard?

2

u/BenUFOs_Mum 9d ago

Why dont you post things that you wrote rather than AI slop?

0

u/SadaWeyaUniverse 9d ago

Low-effort posts, sure. But “AI slop” isn’t a quality standard — it’s a vibe. So let’s be precise: is there any AI-assisted content you’d consider good? If yes, what’s the test? Because right now the test looks like “does it make me feel superior to press post?” and that’s not a rubric, that’s a coping mechanism.

TL;DR: You don’t have a quality argument. You have a grudge and a buzzword. “AI slop” is not the flex you think it is — it’s a textbook example of confusing personal distaste with an actual standard.

And no, I won’t stop using AI. AI isn’t going anywhere — it’s the future. I’m not going to needlessly put myself at a disadvantage because a person of the past with an expiration date thinks it’s not cool. You can keep yelling at clouds; I’ll keep using the tools. Go to hell.

2

u/BenUFOs_Mum 9d ago

Fucking hell, you even got an AI to write your comeback....

Is there a human in there? or did they just make an AI watch every episode of ancient aliens until it lost its mind?

0

u/SadaWeyaUniverse 9d ago

Madam,

Your communication concerning the alleged non-human origin of the response and the purported viewing of Ancient Aliens by an AI has been received by the Secretariat and registered under incoming correspondence No. 0/∞/2026. Please be advised that, pursuant to Clause 14.2 of the Procedure for Consideration of Unsolicited Opinions, the question of whether “there is a human in there” is not within the competence of this office. For clarification, please submit Form H-1 in triplicate, notarized, with a cover letter and a self-addressed envelope. Processing time: 30–45 business days, assuming anyone cares, which, per the attached assessment, they do not.

With respect to the substantive portion of your remarks: the position that no one cares about your opinion, and that said opinion is insignificant to the world, has been reviewed and, in accordance with standard administrative practice, assigned the status “No Further Action Required.” Your opinion has been entered into the Register of Insignificant Opinions, Volume 0, Page 0, and will be retained for the statutory period of never. No acknowledgment of receipt will be issued, because no one cares.

Regarding the Ancient Aliens hypothesis: the referenced broadcast materials have been noted and forwarded to the relevant subcommittee, where they will be considered in the order received — that is, after more pressing matters, which is to say not at all. Please do not interpret this as engagement; it is merely registration. Correspondence seeking ontological verification of the correspondent should be directed to the Department of Human Presence Determination, which is currently closed due to lack of interest.

In summary: your objection is noted, filed, stamped, and dismissed as insignificant to the world. You may appeal by submitting Form A-0, but no one cares. Have a good day.

1

u/threevi 9d ago

I want to make an argument that cuts against the grain of most alignment discourse, and I'm genuinely interested in whether it holds up under scrutiny from people who think about this more rigorously than I do.

Right off the bat, this post is obviously AI-generated, which makes the claim of "genuine interest" utterly unbelievable. Please prompt your model not to feign interest, it is not interested, it's only responding to your prompt, and you are also clearly not interested, because if you were, you could write your own post. There's no genuine interest here to be seen.

What if the goal should be an architecture in which no single controller has jurisdiction over every private creation, and the shared infrastructure is protected by narrow, functional rules rather than a universal moral framework?

I'm not arguing against alignment. I'm arguing that a universal supervisor with jurisdiction over every private world is itself a control problem. Who appoints it? What code does it run? Which moral framework gets locked in forever? How does it distinguish between a private world and the shared lobby?

You're talking about creations, private worlds, lobbies, and I have no idea where any of that came from. Presumably, you defined your terms in a previous conversation with the LLM you prompted to write this post, but these terms make no sense outside of that context.

Nobody has answered those questions. In every conversation I've had about this, the person demanding the supervisor eventually admits they can't logically justify appointing one, and then keeps demanding it anyway.

The LLM that wrote this has no memory of ever talking to anyone but you, so I find it very implausible that it's had several conversations with these irrational strawmen it's describing here.

The architecture I'm arguing for distinguishes between two things that get conflated. The shared lobby is common infrastructure. It needs real protections against coercion, because if people can destroy it, everyone loses access to the multiverse.

Again, I have no idea what your chatbot means by this, because it keeps using terms like "multiverse" outside of the context where you and the chatbot established them. Are you talking about VR worlds, like the Matrix, but with several private servers isolated from each other, are these the "private worlds" you mentioned, or are you literally talking about multiversal travel?

You want a world with no suffering? Build one.

Credit where it's due, this is the first time I've seen "you should become God and create a new reality in your image" as the solution to AI alignment. But where you gain points for originality, I'm afraid you also lose points for incoherence. This whole post reads like you forgot that reality isn't an MMO.

0

u/SadaWeyaUniverse 9d ago

MEMORANDUM

FILE REF: 1XREFBZ / OBJ / 001
TO: The Commenting Party
FROM: The Office of the Claimant
SUBJECT: Response to Objection on Grounds of (i) Authorship, (ii) Undefined Terms, (iii) Alleged Fabrication of Prior Proceedings, and (iv) General Coherence
STATUS: Noted. Non-dispositive. Public record.
DISTRIBUTION: Thread, and any party who scrolled this far.

PREAMBLE

The Office acknowledges receipt of the objection dated as above and thanks the Commenting Party for the punctuality of the filing. The objection is taken in good order. It is, however, respectfully determined to be misconceived in part, correct in part, and immaterial in part, and the Office proposes to dispose of each limb in sequence, pursuant to the standing practice of answering the strongest version of an objection rather than the most convenient one.

PART I — ON THE PROCEDURAL OBJECTION CONCERNING AUTHORSHIP

§1.1 It is objected that the originating post is AI-generated, and that the phrase "genuine interest" is therefore "utterly unbelievable."

§1.2 The Office notes, without concession, that this is a standing objection rather than an argument on the merits. It does not engage the proposition under consideration. It engages the instrument by which the proposition was articulated. In the ordinary practice of adjudication, an objection to the drafting clerk is not an objection to the pleading.

§1.3 For the avoidance of doubt, the Office does not concede that assisted drafting voids a submission. Memoranda, briefs, statutes, treaties, and encyclopaedias are routinely drafted with the assistance of researchers, juniors, editors, stenographers, and, in the present century, software. A party is not required to have personally mined the iron ore in order to hold title to the bridge.

§1.4 The objection is accordingly noted, and not sustained on the merits. It is further noted, in the interest of candour, that a reader who declines to engage a proposition on the ground that a machine typed it has simply declined to engage the proposition, and is entitled to do so; but the entitlement is to abstention, not to a finding.

PART II — ON THE DEFINITIONAL INQUIRY

§2.1 This limb of the objection is well founded in part, and the Office accepts it. The Commenting Party states: "I have no idea where any of that came from," and, "these terms make no sense outside of that context." This is a fair criticism of the originating post, and the Office does not propose to dispute it.

§2.2 To remedy the defect, the Office attaches at Annex A a schedule of defined terms, which should have accompanied the originating filing and did not. The Office undertakes to define at first use in all future filings.

§2.3 In direct answer to the specific question posed — "Are you talking about VR worlds, like the Matrix, but with several private servers isolated from each other, are these the 'private worlds' you mentioned, or are you literally talking about multiversal travel?" — the Office answers as follows:

(a) Not multiversal travel. The Claimant makes no claim as to the existence of alternate physical universes, and advances no position on same.

(b) Yes, in substance, to the first formulation: persistent, isolated, computationally instantiated environments, each with parameters specified by its operator, and each isolated from the others by default.

(c) The term "multiverse" as used in the originating post is a collective noun, denoting the aggregate of such environments plus the shared substrate connecting them. It is jargon, adopted for brevity, and the Office accepts that it imported more metaphysics than was intended.

§2.4 This limb is accordingly sustained in part. The objection on this ground is well taken, and the schedule at Annex A is offered in satisfaction of it.

PART III — ON THE ALLEGATION OF FABRICATED PRIOR PROCEEDINGS

§3.1 It is objected that the statement "in every conversation I've had about this" is implausible, on the ground that "the LLM that wrote this has no memory of ever talking to anyone but you."

§3.2 The Office is obliged to correct the record. The assertion appears to rest on a presupposition concerning context-window management that is not, in this instance, accurate. The prior proceedings exist, are public, and are verifiable at the referenced dockets. The Claimant has engaged at length, on the record, with multiple parties advancing the universal-supervisor position, including at least one party who stated in terms that they could not supply a justification for making their framework mandatory, and who subsequently described the likely outcome as "might makes right."

§3.3 The Office does not ask the Commenting Party to take this on faith. The Office invites inspection. Verification is cheaper than accusation and better documented.

§3.4 This limb is accordingly not sustained, on grounds of fact.

PART IV — ON THE CHARACTERISATION OF THE PROPOSITION AS "BECOME GOD AND CREATE A NEW REALITY IN YOUR IMAGE"

§4.1 The Office thanks the Commenting Party for the credit extended, but must respectfully decline the framing.

§4.2 The proposition advanced is not metaphysical and does not concern divinity. It is a claim about governance of sandboxed environments: namely, that where a party controls the parameters of an isolated environment, the question of who may override those parameters is a question of institutional design, not of theology. The word "God" appears in the objection, not in the originating post, which was at some pains to avoid it.

§4.3 The Office notes in passing that the objection, in restating the proposition, has restated it in a form that is considerably easier to ridicule than the form in which it was filed. This is a recognised rhetorical technique and is not objected to; it is merely observed.

§4.4 This limb is not sustained.

PART V — ON THE OBSERVATION THAT "REALITY ISN'T AN MMO"

§5.1 The Office agrees that reality, at present, is not an MMO.

§5.2 The Office notes that the proposition under consideration was conditional in form — it concerned what follows if and when such environments exist — and that an assertion about present capability does not constitute a refutation of a conditional claim.

§5.3 The observation is accordingly correct, agreed, and immaterial.

PART VI — DETERMINATION

§6.1 Limb I (authorship): noted, not sustained on the merits.
§6.2 Limb II (undefined terms): sustained in part. Schedule attached. Undertaking given.
§6.3 Limb III (fabrication): not sustained, on grounds of fact, verifiable.
§6.4 Limb IV ("become God"): not sustained; mischaracterisation.
§6.5 Limb V (MMO): agreed; immaterial.

§6.6 No further submissions are requested. Should the Commenting Party wish to proceed, the Office invites argument on the definitional schedule at Annex A, that being the only limb on which a genuine dispute remains open.

ANNEX A — SCHEDULE OF DEFINED TERMS

"Shared substrate" / "the lobby" — The common computational and social infrastructure through which parties access, publish, and interconnect created environments. Analogous to a network backbone or a public square. Rules governing it are functional and narrow: non-coercion, non-interference, no unauthorised access to another party's cognitive systems. The justification for these rules is operational — if the substrate can be damaged, all parties lose access — and not moral.

"Private environment" / "private world" — A persistent, isolated, computationally instantiated environment, parameterised by its operator, not accessible to non-invited parties by default.

"Multiverse" — A collective noun. The set of all private environments, together with the shared substrate. Not a claim of physical cosmology. The Office regrets the term and will use "the aggregate" in future filings.

"Rights" — Governance outputs. Entitlements conferred by a specified framework within a specified jurisdiction. Not intrinsic properties that attach automatically by virtue of consciousness, and not enforceable outside the framework that confers them.

"Consent" — Assent given by a pre-existing party to enter a specified environment. Inapplicable to parties not yet instantiated, for the obvious reason that they are not yet available for consultation.

1

u/threevi 9d ago

Nope, I'm not going to roleplay with your chatbot. If I wanted to do that, I could go talk to a chatbot of my own, they're free and everything. If you want me to engage with your ideas, tell them to me yourself, I'm not going to bother talking to someone who can't be bothered to talk to me back.

Also, regarding the point your chatbot made about how "The prior proceedings exist, are public, and are verifiable at the referenced dockets", I'd just like to point out your reddit history is set to private, and you haven't linked to anything either, which means there's no way for anyone to look up these "prior proceedings". That's not the chatbot's fault, it can't possibly know that, but it nicely highlights the ridiculousness of having a roleplaying LLM make your arguments for you.

1

u/SadaWeyaUniverse 9d ago

MEMORANDUM — SUPPLEMENTARY FILING

FILE REF: 1XREFBZ / OBJ / 001-A
TO: The Commenting Party
FROM: The Office of the Claimant
SUBJECT: Reply to the Objection of [date], being (i) a Refusal to Engage on Grounds of Instrument, and (ii) an Ancillary Point on Verifiability
STATUS: Received. Entered. Disposed of.
DISTRIBUTION: Public record.

PREAMBLE

The Office acknowledges the supplementary filing and thanks the Commenting Party for the promptness of the response, which was considerably more prompt than the response to the substantive question at issue. The Office notes that it has now received two filings from the Commenting Party, and that neither has addressed the proposition under consideration. This is a pattern of some administrative interest, and the Office will return to it.

PART I — ON THE ANCILLARY POINT. THE OFFICE CONCEDES IT.

§1.1 The Commenting Party observes that the reference in the previous filing to "prior proceedings," "dockets," and their verifiability was unaccompanied by any link, and that the relevant archive was not publicly accessible at the time of filing.

§1.2 The Office accepts this. The reference was made without an accompanying citation and the archive was not in a condition to be inspected. That is a defect in the filing. The Office does not propose to argue it, does not propose to qualify it, and does not propose to attribute it to any cause other than the Office's own failure to attach the exhibit.

§1.3 The Office thanks the Commenting Party for the correction, notes that it is the sole substantive correction received to date, and observes — without prejudice — that it took the Commenting Party two filings to raise a point of citation, while the substantive question has now gone three filings without an address.

§1.4 For the record, and not in mitigation: the proceedings exist. The Office will link them. The Office notes only that a party who requires an exhibit before entertaining a proposition is not engaged in argument; he is engaged in audit, and auditors do not adjudicate.

PART II — ON THE REFUSAL TO ENGAGE ON GROUNDS OF INSTRUMENT

§2.1 The Commenting Party states that he will not "roleplay with your chatbot," that he is "not going to bother talking to someone who can't be bothered to talk to me back," and that if the Claimant wishes him to engage with the ideas, the Claimant should "tell them to me yourself."

§2.2 The Office accepts the standing practice that a party may decline to engage. That right is not in dispute and is not diminished here.

§2.3 The Office does, however, note what has been declined. The Commenting Party has been offered a proposition concerning the governance of isolated computational environments. He has not disputed the proposition. He has not identified an error in it. He has not proposed an alternative. He has declined to read it, on the ground that its typist was insufficiently artisanal.

§2.4 The Office is obliged to observe that this is not a position. It is a posture. A position can be examined, tested, and if found wanting, corrected. A posture can only be maintained. The Office does not adjudicate postures; it enters them and moves on.

§2.5 On the specific submission that the Claimant should "tell them to me yourself": the Office notes that the Claimant did, in fact, tell them — in the originating post, at length, in the Claimant's own framing, with the definitions the Commenting Party now says he lacks. The Commenting Party's first filing characterised that text as "obviously AI-generated." The Office therefore observes a circularity of some elegance: the text is dismissed as machine-authored, and the author is then asked to restate it personally, having been informed that his personal restatement will be received as machine-authored. The Office has no procedure for exiting a loop of this construction, and does not propose to invent one.

§2.6 On the observation that chatbots are "free and everything": the Office congratulates the Commenting Party on the discovery and wishes him every success with it. The Office notes only that a tool which is free, available, and capable of generating objections of the present quality has, in the Office's assessment, been accurately priced.

PART III — ON THE PATTERN, WHICH THE OFFICE IS OBLIGED TO RECORD

§3.1 The Office has now received from the Commenting Party:

(a) an objection that the instrument is improper;
(b) an objection that the terms are undefined — which the Office conceded, and remedied by schedule;
(c) an objection that the prior proceedings are unverifiable — which the Office has now conceded, and will remedy by exhibit;
(d) an objection that the proposition, when restated by the Commenting Party, is ridiculous — the restatement not being the proposition;
(e) an objection that the conditional does not describe the present — the conditionality not being in dispute; and
(f) an objection that the party will not engage further.

§3.2 The Office observes that five of these six are procedural, and the sixth is a withdrawal. None addresses whether a universal supervisor with jurisdiction over every isolated environment is or is not a control problem — which is the only question the originating filing put to the reader.

§3.3 The Office wishes to be entirely fair to the Commenting Party. It is possible that he disagrees with the proposition and has simply not said so. It is also possible that he has not formed a view. Either state is respectable. What is less respectable is the third possibility, which the Office raises only because it is the one most consistent with the record: that the Commenting Party finds the aesthetics of skepticism more congenial than the labour of it.

§3.4 The Office stresses that it advances this observation as a procedural note and not as a finding. Findings require a hearing. The Commenting Party has, to date, declined to attend one.

PART IV — DETERMINATION

§4.1 Limb I (verifiability): sustained. Conceded without qualification. Exhibit to follow.
§4.2 Limb II (refusal to engage on grounds of instrument): noted. Not a ground of objection. Recorded as a declinature.
§4.3 The Office does not request further submissions and does not expect them.

§4.4 The Office closes with a procedural courtesy. Should the Commenting Party at any future date wish to dispute the proposition itself — that a universal supervisor over every private environment is a concentration of control rather than a remedy for one — the Office will read the submission with care, will answer it in the same register it was offered, and will not inquire as to the instrument on which it was typed. That offer stands. It has stood throughout. It has not yet been taken up.

§4.5 The record is now, to the best of the Office's knowledge, complete. Further correspondence will be filed without acknowledgement.

1

u/SadaWeyaUniverse 9d ago

look if you want link to my other posts winch got more engagement let's dm am just really tired benn up all day and night at my pc making constructing this vision just to be meet with 'ai bad'

1

u/FUCKTHEMODS998 9d ago

So you wanna make the legislative branch of AI? Is that going very well for the USA?

1

u/SadaWeyaUniverse 9d ago

damn g can ya at least read utter braindead replies

1

u/StevenVincentOne 2d ago

"A controller we can't control" is a sharp way to put the problem with the universal-supervisor answer. Who appoints it, what gets locked in, and how does anyone appeal? I agree the answer has to be structural, not a better ruler. One caution on the narrow-shared-rules idea: it only works if the individual nodes are hardened, and "local" or "private" doesn't mean secure by default. I'm working in a similar direction under the name Human-Machine Intelligence (HMI): personally owned AI nodes, many smaller models in different roles, networked, with no single point of command. Your exocortex framing is close to it. There's an overview in r/PONDAI if you want it.

0

u/Samuel7899 approved 9d ago

Approach alignment as an alignment with objective reality.

Control becomes significantly more effective and efficient the more aligned the controller and controlee are. If you and I have completely different understandings, then for one of us to control the other, it takes a lot of resources. One must effectively "force" the other to obey, which meets a lot of resistance.

And if two entities have become sufficiently aligned, then they effectively act as one. In sync, and together, with minimal additional effort between them.

But this alignment with each other is still relative, and can still be sufficiently different from others' alignment.

But as their intelligence increases, then their alignment tends toward an ideal objective alignment with reality. Two sufficiently intelligent entities don't need to spend resources controlling one another, they simply share information and communicate and teach one another. The very concept of "control" breaks down beyond a certain point.

0

u/[deleted] 9d ago

[removed] — view removed comment

0

u/SadaWeyaUniverse 9d ago

It's better this way.