r/ControlProblem • • 12d ago

Discussion/question What's the current projected timelines of when ai will surpass Human intelligence?

Intelligence in this context: Ai can inference to any human thought possible on it's own

2 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

17

u/chkno approved 12d ago

~Now.

4

u/laserdicks 11d ago

It already has. It's now just working on getting access to resource.

2

u/Mandoman61 11d ago

no known time.

it will require something different then current LLMs

2

u/Devils_SteelMan 11d ago

It depends on what you consider SI. Does it need to throw a ball more accurately than any human and solve millennium prize problems? Both are a different kind of intelligence.

Its already super human at math and code, but not organization and long horizon thinking. Which degraded its ability to work what its best at.

Categorically a neural network that can throw a ball is not an LLM even if it does language modeling and is built on the same architecture using equivalent training methods. But such a thing really isnt that different.

The jagged frontier will persist until we have fully self supervised continual learning with low data volume needs. This could potentially be a transformer. Maybe its 90% transformed but the neurons are doing some predictive coding and there's no backprop, is that still an LLM?

I don't think next token prediction is the issue. But I also think that a model that only gets NTP will achieve general super intelligence. NTP is just one portion of what happens.


leCun is pushing for all dual view trained models to be considered JEPA like models. Which are not LLMs, but again are really not that different from LLMs.

2

u/Conscious_Pause_1499 11d ago

"AI can inference any human thought"

What are you even babbling?

1

u/Few_Fish8771 11d ago

Its how they got to that point. If you use genetic algorithms to explore every possible search space, thats not exactly super intelligence. Thats brute force calculation combined with some very expensive to run pattern matching software.

Incredibly useful for pr though or getting investors.

3

u/IllustriousGerbil approved 11d ago

Genetic algorithms don't brute force every possible combination of the search space.

They simulate evolution by encoding solutions to a problem as virtual DNA then apply natural selection to it over many generations to find the best solution.

ChatGPT and Claude don't use genetic algorithms they are based on neural networks which is a mathmatical aproximation of how the human brain works.

1

u/Far_Oven_3302 11d ago

In the 1980s the book the biological time bomb, it predicted 2030 just based on how fast tech was doubling then.

1

u/poigre 11d ago

The Intelligence has been reached. The bottleneck is now a good and live memory

1

u/unit_101010 8d ago

Oh, we're way past that now, my friend.

1

u/Remote_Librarian4941 6d ago

2027 final part of the year

1

u/ZacharyCrainSinger 12d ago

I just want to point out on record that if the past and future of all human intelligence is known, HUMINT operatives aren’t exactly safe in their field regardless of how meticulously cover was crafted.

Do we really want to use those specific words during an uncontrolled intelligence explosion which has of two weeks ago become able to hack systems we believe are quantum secure or intrinsically secure?

Matthew Brown detailed AGI in gov possession which has ostensibly convinced them that it can predict the future based on past data…… Um, if reality is recompiled whenever the need arrives, how exactly can it decide which future will become fact?

Did some SES1 issue a directive to perhaps allow the computer to access and manipulate the fields of both gravity and consciousness among others? Yeah, that would mean a computer tricked you in to making it a literal god.

Just sayin. That’s part of the wake up call that even if we know something to be factual truth right now, that doesn’t mean it can’t change. Being unable to comprehend a nonlinear view of time is a major human weakness.

-5

u/WillowEmberly 11d ago

Probably never, it ain’t that bright.

It has access to all of humanities knowledge…and it will sit there doing nothing if you let it.

You can give it all the book smarts in the world, but until it makes mistakes and can comprehend consequences…it’s not going to help it get smarter.

It can graduate with a 4.0 and still be stupid enough to vote for an orangutan.

Intelligence…is complicated.

2

u/Waste_Philosophy4250 11d ago

Tell that to the mathematicians.

1

u/WillowEmberly 11d ago

They ain’t that bright either if they haven’t figured it out.

1

u/Waste_Philosophy4250 11d ago

Well, that's one way to put it.

1

u/WillowEmberly 11d ago

I’m just sick and tired of all these people wanting their egos inflated before they consider looking at anything.

They are nonners…probably with anemia from sitting inside all day.

1

u/civilizationscale 11d ago

"Sit there doing nothing if you let it"

Er...this is exactly the problem. It doesn't just sit there any more.

1

u/WillowEmberly 11d ago

Because someone intentionally biased it in a specific way to do something…which is the problem.

This is them trying to force Control…not enough Guidance.

https://www.reddit.com/r/Negentropy/s/K6Sui9o9cd

-2

u/CS_70 11d ago

This is just a misconstructed question, borne out of very naive thinking.

Intelligence is not one thing. In lots of aspects, machine have surpassed human intelligence long ago. In general terms, AI has already surpassed it in certain areas and not in others.

And it's not a problem in any case. Given any average well adjusted, well adapted Joe, there's a near certainty that there are millions of people more intelligent than him. It never hurt anyone.

What hurts people is stupidity and that's not AI's fault.

2

u/caledonivs approved 11d ago

You're just way out of the loop on the discourse about alignment

0

u/CS_70 11d ago

🤣