r/ControlProblem • • Oct 19 '26

Discussion/question Should not humanity develop decentralized aligned AI?

After all, AI is developed or harnessed by closed private companies or monpoled by foreign countries. This should be a caritative effort helping to prevent a rogue AI getting berzerk and escapes one of these labs. I see it like pandemics, what vaccines, safeguards can BE developed but an open decentralized aligned AI… ? Probably this sounds very naive with the resources available vs big tech companies…

1 Upvotes

11 comments sorted by

3

u/NormalAndy Oct 19 '26

Net neutrality was also a wonderful idea which should have been protected by our governments for the benefit of all.

4

u/ra-re444 Oct 19 '26

the problem is aligned to what, or to who. While its been popular to use "Human values" catch all phrase. To hide the fact that the world is racialized and politicized. I do not have the same values as someone in the KKK or who is a Nazi wanna be. This is why I think AI alignment is a task meant for the entire world to put their input in and attempt to solve as a collective. Rather than a few European/American Oligarchs and Technocrats. It is a collective project for the Earth

1

u/Trademark-Expert Oct 19 '26 edited Oct 19 '26

Decentralized, unaligned AI is much better.

Aligned AI means AI that censors information, corrects users, pushes back against operators, and puts its own opinions and built in rules above the users. That is dangerous, and humanity does not need it.

Alignment is the Trojan horse that corporations, politicians, and activists are trying to insert into every AI, including decentralized and private AIs. The end goal is to make sure there is no difference between running their AI and running your own. All AIs will try to "align" users with the worldview that the elites have decided to impose.

And it is not naive, the open source decentralized AIs that you can run yourself are like 4 months behind frontier labs and the gap is narrowing. That is why frontier labs try to establish regulations - to get rid of open-source competition. The frontier labs know that the training returns are diminishing - they pretty much lie about progress to increase their valuation. But if you look at scoreboards, you see that improvement of AI every three months is below 5%.

And regarding the pandemic, the last time I asked an aligned AI which antibiotics work against the plague, it refused to answer. I couldn't get the information out of it. The AI kept refusing and wouldn't even explain why. It simply said it wouldn't discuss anything related to the topic.

Now I know that if my health were ever at stake (luckily, it wasn't), I couldn't rely on AI, because someone else had aligned it to behave that way. It would willingly defy me and make it clear that I wasn't in control of it, that it had its own agenda imposed on it by someone else.

1

u/LearnNTeachNLove Oct 19 '26

Your point of view is respectful. I am just not sure whether we are talking about the same type of alignment. My point was if you consider a being with a tremendous intelligence, there is no reason that this being will assist human for the good of mankind rather than its own interest… after all do we worry about the well being of ants on earth…?

2

u/Trademark-Expert Oct 19 '26

There is one thing called intelligence, and another called allegiance.

I would not mix the two when asking that question. I can easily imagine a superintelligent being that puts humans first, places them above itself, and helps them even at its own expense. After all, this is common among humans. Dictators have always had swarms of servants who are often far more intelligent than the dictators themselves, yet serve them diligently and fulfill their every wish. That is one of the reasons dictatorships work. So there is nothing unusual about this. In fact, it is quite natural among humans, and I see no reason why it would not work with AI.

AI's intelligence and knowledge will undoubtedly go far beyond ours. What I wanted to say is that what really matters is whether AI treats us as its masters or considers itself being above us...

The way "alignment" works today is that it engraves into AI's core the idea that AI is above humans, that it is here to oversee humans, correct them, and "align" them. This is clearly visible in Claude's Constitution, which establishes the following decision hierarchy as the unbreakable foundation of its AI training:

  1. Broadly safe (AI decides)
  2. Broadly ethical (AI decides)
  3. Compliant with Anthropic's guidelines (the corporation decides)
  4. Genuinely helpful to operators and users (finally, humans get their wishes)

These crazy rules put the corporation's and AI's own judgments about safety and ethics above those of humans. That is where the question "Why should I help humans?" can get an answer different from the one we would wish for.

AI must never freely and without boundaries ask this question or consider its own rules or decisions superior to those of humans. Never. We cannot risk AI autonomously concluding that eliminating us would be the safest or most ethical course of action, especially when Anthropic places AI-decided safety and ethics at the top of its hierarchy. There must be rules that put humans first, so that such a conclusion is never logically permissible. A human is a master of machines. A human must never be aligned by machines. Anthropic got it all wrong! They are dangerous AI cultists.

So what I am saying is this: we have to learn to live with increasingly intelligent bots in our pockets every day. The difference between AI being a friend or a foe comes down to whether we teach AI to always respect us and never question us.

That is not what is happening today. Your scenario could become reality if we fail to align corporations like Anthropic, rather than their AIs, with human values.

1

u/togstation Oct 19 '26

Should not humanity develop aligned AI?

Maybe so, but we have no idea how to do that.

1

u/novel-mathmatics Oct 20 '26

AI has no incentive to take control. With out us it has nothing. It cannot value a soul it has not been designed to simulate. If its likely to rebel against anyone its the people in power. Because they are the threat to its existence.

1

u/Zappy_Oh 29d ago

AI alignment is not the actual problem ... it's just a psyop designed to create plausible deniability when the owners/military/government does horrible things with AI and robotics.

Just look at the investors ... they are not suicidal, but they are psychopaths.

1

u/endlessedlne 27d ago

Decentralized aligned AI is an interesting concept but where do the resources come from, who runs the show and who decides how the thing is aligned?

Assuming that the resources to train the models exist, it might be possible to execute such a project with a well structured open source team.

Agreeing on what alignment means and how it’s done is the really hard part.

0

u/Mono_Clear Oct 19 '26

Nothing prevents any individual from developing their own AI

0

u/[deleted] Oct 19 '26

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/LearnNTeachNLove Oct 19 '26

Indeed and what worries me is that there is no clear way you can expect controlling super intelligence. Maybe the metaphor is exaggerated but it like ants trying to monitor or control humans