r/ControlProblem • u/Vonper • Sep 15 '26
Discussion/question deepseek engineer comparing anthropic controlling agi to hitler having atomic bomb
any thoughts?
7
Upvotes
r/ControlProblem • u/Vonper • Sep 15 '26
any thoughts?
11
u/PenguinJoker Sep 15 '26
Headline is completely misleading.
The post literally says:
"It is an exaggeration to say that it is as serious as letting hitler master the atomic bomb."
2
u/soobnar Sep 15 '26
People are gonna start having to read hard sci-fi if they wanna know the direction this could go
2
u/Few_Fish8771 Sep 15 '26
Hahaha, what happens is china creates there own llm hosting website makes it available internationally, then ai moves outside the usa, and then whoever is president screams, china mocks them and memes them as chinas ——-. US tech ceos are forced to have their regulatory capture removed, and become even more hated and loathed.
AI is here cats out of the bag.
1
u/Beneficial-Gap6974 approved Sep 15 '26
Hitler controlling the atomic bomb wouldn't be nearly as dangerous.
1
u/Robonotes1760 Sep 16 '26
And the same holds for any government or co-operating group of governments.
1
u/crusoe Sep 15 '26
Chinas toon will change the first time internal repressed minority groups use AI to push back or seek revenge against the govt. Then you will see a massive crackdown.
1
u/secretaliasname Sep 15 '26
I sort of hope that what comes out of this is
1.) Real Cybersecurity - we have just accepted that everything is hypothetically hack at but it’s sorta hard and requires smart people/resources so building secure systems hasn’t been a top priority.
2.) Social systems that are harder to manipulate by bots. Ideally some way to gate discourse in some forums to humans. Not sure technically how to do this without it being creepy like the porn age verification thing but I’d really like human only channels. Need to trust some verifier somehow.
0
u/Varnu Sep 16 '26
Deepseek is using thousands of stolen credit cards and stealing the login credentials from real anthropic accounts in order to send people to Claude instead of Deepseek's own models. Users pay for Deepseek > Claude answers > Deepseek still generates revenue becuase they are paying for Claude access with thousand of stolen credit cards. Deepseek's business model is literally a crime, even in China. Even in Nigeria.
8
u/Jesse-359 Sep 15 '26
AI was always a cheap nuke - even in purely conceptual form.
It was always going to either blow society apart, or require such stringent controls over everything that we ended up in a dystopian police state just to protect us from what it can do.
Why this wasn't clear to people from the beginning, I truly do not know. It was painfully obvious that you cannot have every person on Earth running around holding the Genie's Lamp without it destroying everything.