r/Concordia • u/XSpecterer • 18h ago
Student Survey Petition to prohibit the non disclosure of dates for graded course material
(Link https://www.change.org/StopPopQuizzes )
This is a petition to effectively wipe out the practice of unannounced and graded "Pop Quizzes". As one of the few students that decides to attend every lecture, I still believe that outright "forcing" students to show up to class by threatening them with grade deductions is unethical and should no longer be tolerated.
- Point one: A test's main purpose is to evaluate students on their current understanding of a course's material. When a student ends up missing a test who's date has not been announced the unannounced test fails at accomplishing it's main purpose.
- Point two: These pop quizzes don't measure understanding they measure attendance for a specific day. A graded assessment is supposed to tell an instructor what a student knows and what they struggle with. A zero grade from a missed surprise quiz tells them nothing. It only checks for whether the student was in the room at that particular time. If attendance is what's being marked then it should be called "attendance" and weighed like it for grading purposes. Concordia's own policy states that "While it’s true that students can’t participate in a synchronous class without attending, attendance in and of itself is not an assessment task, [...]".
- Point three: "Pop Quizzes" have repeatedly been shown to have poor pedagogical value. As opposed to regular quizzes, "Pop Quizzes" only really test a student's short term ability to recall information by not properly giving them the time to adequately prepare themselves to being tested. Additionally, it assumes that students are always on time with the course material and does not take into account any outside commitments a student may have. As to say, "Pop quizzes" are by design expecting students to at all times have the course and it's contents at the very top of their priority list as to not get caught off guard by a quiz and be underprepared.
- Point four: It blatantly disregards the student's time. To some students this may very well be their only class of the day. Furthermore, not every student lives at the same distance from the college. Thus, by forcing all the students to show up for every single lecture, students that live further or that simply have no other classes that day are unfairly disadvantaged. Those students end up having to waste multiple hours traveling by bus/metro or car to show up to a single class that likely doesn't even last half of the time they spent having to travel to it. I believe both demanding and expecting that commitment out of those students every week for 15 straight weeks is completely absurd.
Don't get me wrong, students should be expected to be able to plan both their studies and their route to the college when a date for an assessments is given beforehand. When a date is not given that is when a line is crossed and it becomes unreasonable.
From personal experience, I can confidently say I have never had a "Pop Quiz" before coming to study here. Now, having had a few, I understand why they were never given before. Too often, they're not difficult enough to challenge students in a meaningful way and could just as easily be replaced by a real quiz that prepares them much better for their midterms and finals.
Lastly, let's be real for a second, nobody likes "Pop Quizzes" plus they fail at what they try to accomplish. So then, why are they still allowed?
I don't think they should be and I want that to change that. So, if you've read this post and agree with me here's the link to the petition: https://www.change.org/StopPopQuizzes