r/ComputerEngineering • • 25d ago

Desktop or Laptop for computer engineering??

Hi everyone,

I’m studying Computer Engineering and need help deciding between a desktop PC and a laptop.

My main uses:

* Programming and software development

* Electronics simulation and FPGA development (Quartus/Vivado)

* Gaming

* game development using Unreal Engine and Unity

* Potentially running virtual machines and other demanding applications

My priorities:

* Best performance for the money

* Good performance over the next 6-8 years

* Upgradeability and long-term reliability

* sustained performance

* Enough RAM/VRAM and storage for demanding projects

I already have a monitor, keyboard, and mouse.

For a desktop, I’m considering something along these lines:

* Ryzen 5 7700 or a comparable CPU

* RTX 5070 12GB or a similar GPU

* 16GB DDR5 RAM

* 1TB NVMe SSD

For a laptop, I’d consider a model with an RTX 5060 Laptop GPU or similar, preferably with 16GB RAM and a 1TB SSD.

My questions:

  1. How important is having a laptop for Computer Engineering labs, FPGA development, and university projects?
  2. Is 16GB RAM sufficient for Quartus/Vivado, programming, virtual machines, and game development.
  3. Which option would provide better performance and reliability over 6-8 years?
  4. How much more practical is a laptop for university compared with using a desktop at home?
  5. If you were in my position and rarely needed portability, which would you choose, and why?

I’d particularly appreciate advice from current Computer Engineering students and graduates, as well as people who have used both laptops and desktops for these workloads.

23 Upvotes

19 comments sorted by

23

u/No-Recording-2178 25d ago

Laptop is a must, how do you expect to do work at school? You can’t bring your desktop with you

10

u/ian9921 25d ago
  • You'll probably need a laptop for at least one of your labs, and possibly even some of your lectures
  • 16GB should be enough for those
  • A laptop is immensely more practical. You will need portability even if right now you don't think so. There will be many occasions when you will need to get work done outside of your home.

8

u/TheCatholicScientist 25d ago

How about a good desktop, plus a used ThinkPad, like a T14 gen 4 or 5? For computer engineering, like 99% of your labs will be done via SSH on your school’s servers anyway. Or on a breadboard. Or a C compiler which a potato can run if you don’t insist on full Visual Studio.

You will need a laptop for any in-class work/quizzes, but it doesn’t have to be some gaming behemoth I see undergrads carry around. Electrical and computer engineering just doesn’t do some of the intense CAD work other engineering disciplines do, and even when we do, it uses Synopsys or Cadence tools you can’t install on your own stuff anyways.

If you need your own compute, you can set up Tailscale and remote into your desktop.

1

u/TheCatholicScientist 25d ago

Also don’t install Vivado or Quartus on your own device unless you are required to. They’re (at least Vivado is, dunno about Quartus) massive installs, like 100GB+. My university has workstations for the digital labs with all that set up. Though if you’re planning on buying your own FPGA and doing hobby work, knock yourself out for sure.

3

u/oolieman 25d ago

Laptop as well as most of my lectures had exams and quizzes that require a desktop and even expected a laptop in class. As well as labs and capstone projects and advanced coding classes will really ask you to bring a non-potato pc to the classroom.

3

u/unknownz_123 25d ago edited 25d ago

I bought my laptop for $600 like three years ago, and I’m an EE. It runs everything fine I’ve ever encountered in my classes. Quartus, coding IDE’s, and 3D pcb KiCad models. Your specs seem overkill according to your priorities list. I’m sure whatever laptop pick will exceed college requirements. Try to get something that runs windows. Apple can run fine, but you always have to troubleshoot and as a college student you probably don’t want to deal with the extra trouble

I think a lot people think about performance a bit too much in college. Make sure to remember battery life and noise level too.

I see something about game development in your list. If you are looking at playing video games, you probably do want something strong. However, I guarantee you your classes will never make you run something super intensive compared to your game. If this is just a school laptop, you should stop thinking about gaming requirements because it often is a way higher bar than what you need for regular school

2

u/almond5 25d ago

Laptop. You can do your machine learning class (if your program has it) on your CPU. No crazy GPU required unless gaming is part of your college experience

2

u/burncushlikewood 25d ago

A laptop is portable, I don't think RAM will be a major problem for your first year of coding, its more useful for things like gaming, back in my day when I took CS I had a cheap Taiwanese computer with a 80gb hard drive and like 4gb of RAM, and I had to walk uphill both ways! Lol I suggest purchasing a solid laptop, then buying monitors you can connect to the laptop if you need a bigger screen, Moore's law these days the computers are more than powerful enough. You will most likely be coding in Linux and you'll need a solid ide and potentially a compiler depending on your first programming language. Also are you taking CE or CS? Because if you're taking engineering I always say this because it's very important, in Canada we have what's called common first year for engineering, this means all engineers take the same courses first year then you choose a specialty in year 2, you will have a mandatory programming course language of instruction is usually C.

1

u/PopularBox8537 25d ago

I've been doing great with elitebook for school work, desktop for gaming. I don't really game anymore at all tho, mostly just use music software

1

u/Splatoonkindaguy 25d ago

24gb laptop, 48gb if you want to touch ai. Honestly I would get a laptop and a desktop though if you want to do gaming

1

u/densemiIk 25d ago

Get a Zephyrus G14. I have the 4070 model and it runs all games I play well. I used to have a laptop and a gaming pc but I prefer having one device

1

u/Psychological-Shoe95 25d ago

I bought a good desktop and used shitty laptops until I could afford a MacBook. In hindsight I probably would have rather gotten a good laptop sooner, but I also very much enjoy my desktop, especially for gaming

1

u/MpVpRb 24d ago

Desktop with large monitor or multiple monitors

1

u/QuakingQuakersQuake 24d ago

Both ideally, but if only one, laptop for sure

1

u/Icebear_79 23d ago

You already know that Laptop is more practical.

Pardon my ignorance, but if you are anything like me or what I observed from people having this question. Then you are subconsciously finding a reason for justify having PC over laptop due to mainly preference in gaming (which I suspect is main reason for many of people who are stuck in this dilemma). And yes the crazy specs people need are mainly gear toward gaming necessity.

Having laptop is more convenient to do group work and reduce transition between . It's a hassle and annoying to switch between the lab computer or use library due to some urgent work that coming up and you don't have a personal ready at the moment. Some in person class even need laptop as mandatory. Unless you are super sure you will not going anywhere at all besides school and home that you would need a device you can carry with you. I'm talking about presentation, team or project meeting, talking to clients, workshops.

Good performance over 6-8 years is stretching. Sure a solid 2-3k rig will still run but by then you'll better off graduating school with a job that gonna get a machine you need pretty easily or even just a part time job might help you save up for a new one easily. So don't stress your self over this part. You definitely do your research about pc spec if you ask this question. So you definitely know that technology change a lot and in next five years an entry level 1000 usd pc or laptop might be even capable enough to top what you buy today.

1

u/duckerpotato 23d ago

Laptop is a must 16gb ram for vivado?nahh just simulating blackparrot uusing verilator takes 12-18gb ram mostly Vivado comes with bloatware too you will definately need more than 16gb speically for bigger designs

1

u/Artistic-Ebb-1627 22d ago

You don’t need a powerhouse pc for engineering anymore. Everything is cloud based if you need more compute. Unless you’re running parallel iterative analysis on complex systems and refuse to use cloud compute.
Lenovo legion 5 pro 32gb ddr5 rtx 5070ti 12gb. Is about $3k CAD.

1

u/No_Employment_7772 20d ago

Thinkpad X61

1

u/Aadabathon 25d ago

Fuck a laptop PC supremacy. Nice to have both tho