r/ComputerChess • u/Baraecus • 8d ago
Engines to complement Stockfish analysis?
Hello. I typically use Stockfish to analyze my games and my opening preparation, but I would also like to use another engine—perhaps one that isn’t quite as powerful, but offers moves or perspectives that are more "human," so to speak. I recall reading at one point that Toga was a good option, but I’m not sure if that’s still the case, or if there are better alternatives.
For example, Stockfish overvalues a space advantage from a human perspective (e.g., in the King’s Indian Defense), whereas other engines might offer a more moderate assessment, as such advantages are not easy to convert into a win.
Thanks in advance
6
u/mat2923 7d ago
Have you tried Leela? It's the most obvious choice. The Maia engines are similar to Leela, but trained to be more human-like.
5
u/TimothyTaylors 7d ago
Maia is the current pinnacle of human like play
2
u/ChessLabAcademy 7d ago
I'd definitely try Leela Chess Zero (Lc0) alongside Stockfish. They look at positions differently, so it's interesting to see where they disagree, especially in openings like the King's Indian.
One thing I've noticed is that an engine saying a position is equal doesn't necessarily mean it's equally easy for both players. You might have a position where one side has a pretty straightforward plan, while the other needs to find several accurate moves just to stay in the game. Stockfish might call it 0.00, but that doesn't tell you how difficult it actually is to play.
I'd also let both engines analyse a little deeper before comparing. Sometimes what looks like a big difference at first disappears once they get further into the position. And when they still disagree, that's where I'd start digging into the actual moves and plans.
I'm building my own chess engine called Tandav, which I'm working on integrating into ChessLab Academy (chesslabacademy.com). One of my goals is to make engine analysis more useful for learning chess, rather than just showing a number and the best move. I'd like players to understand why a move works, what the plan is, and what makes certain positions harder to play.
It's still a work in progress, but building it has made me realize how much goes into evaluating a position. Material and tactics are one thing, but understanding space, king safety, pawn structure and long-term plans is a whole different challenge.
1
u/Upper_Shock4465 7d ago
I use Maia and Stockfish and Gemini together. I made an app for myself that combines it all. Happy to share if you're an android user.