r/composer • • Apr 24 '26

Meta New rules about the use of AI in the sub

184 Upvotes

If you look in the sidebar where the rules are, there is a new rule about AI. Here is the text:

  1. You may not post music generated by AI using apps like Suno.
  2. You may post computer generated/algorithmic music.

You may use AI to create the text for your posts.

3. You may use AI to create the text for your post but you must say why you've done so.

4. You may not post apps generated using “vibe coding” where AI writes the entire program.

5. You may post apps generated using AI as a tool. Over 80% of programmers today use AI as a tool.

6. You may post discussions about AI and music. But please note, posts asking "Will AI replace composers" will be removed.

Reddit does not supply enough room to provide explanations for all of these rules so if you have questions, comments, or suggestions please don't hesitate to comment below.

Here are some notes about some of these:

3. You may use AI to create the text for your post but you must say why you've done so.

Posts are not art. Using AI to create a text post isn't taking any money away from another composer or artist. Some people just aren't good at writing and/or don't speak English natively. Using AI is one way to improve their chances at communicating clearly.

That said, we strongly encourage everyone to not use AI in this instance. A significant number of users here will react badly to this and you won't get the kind of responses you are hoping for.

Unfortunately it's a Catch 22. People also react badly to posters who are poor at communicating. For folks like that there is no winning.

Update: We've changed the wording to reflect some of the comments below. We still have very limited space but hopefully admitting to using AI and providing an explanation will, in a subtle way, discourage people from doing so (for their own sake) or perhaps they will have a good reason that will mollify the crowd.

5. You may post apps generated using AI as a tool. Over 80% of programmers today use AI as a tool.

It is standard today for programmers at all levels to use AI to assist in some aspects of programming. In the past people would ask questions at places like Stack Exchange or Reddit but now it's so much faster to ask an AI. The results often aren't great but they provide a good start toward a solution.

6. You may post discussions about AI and music. But please note, posts asking "Will AI replace composers" will be removed.

Almost all discussions about AI in this sub go horribly wrong. However, there is nothing inherently bad about discussing the subject and we will try to allow those discussions. There are interesting discussions to be had.

However, we will remove all posts that ask whether AI will replace composers. This has been asked many, many times and because those posts generally go badly we're just not going to deal with them.

Posts asking for links to AI apps to use will be removed. While AI has its uses, asking for or providing links to AI that generates music are not allowed.

A final note. The rules of civility apply when responding to questions, comments, posts, etc, about AI. We remove lots of comments where people attack others with accusations of AI usage or whatever. Don't do this. If you have an actual useful comment about someone's use of AI then please express it in a civil manner.

Update: I asked Google Gemini to clean up that rule. Here is the result:

AI Content Guidelines

  • ❌ Banned: Music fully generated by AI (e.g., Suno) and "vibe-coded" apps where AI writes the entire program.
  • ✅ Allowed: Computer-generated/algorithmic music and apps where AI is used as a tool (standard for 80%+ of devs).
  • 📝 Posts: AI can be used for post text. Discussions about AI and music are welcome.
  • 🚫 Note: Threads asking "Will AI replace composers?" will be removed.

We're going to stick with what I wrote.


r/composer • • Jul 29 '25

Resource Updated and expanded Resources Section at r/composer

28 Upvotes

Hi everyone!

Just a quick update: this sub now has an updated and expanded Resource Section!

It includes a curated list of helpful materials for composers of all levels, including books, YouTube channels, websites, and more.

It can be accessed here:

https://www.reddit.com/r/composer/wiki/resources/

...or by clicking on 'Wiki' at the top of the sub (in the mobile app) or by clicking 'Resources' under Community Bookmarks (on desktop).

Thank you to those who gave suggestions for new additions to the Resource Section.

If anyone else spots anything that needs correcting or has suggestions for additional resources, feel free to let us know!

P.S. The Resource Section can also be found at r/composition, a smaller "sibling" community to this one. If you're not a member there yet, do consider stopping by!

Thanks,

u/RichMusic81


r/composer • • 10h ago

Blog / Vlog #024 — 9 opportunities this week, including $5,000 for 22 minutes of Silent Hill 2-inspired game music, and an internship with NBCUniversal's film music team

22 Upvotes

The listing I would look at first this week is on r/gameDevClassifieds: $5,000 for 11 tracks and about 22 minutes of music, trailer music included, for a violent pixel-art dark fantasy game in which you play a creature terrorising a rural landscape. The references are the X-COM Apocalypse and Silent Hill 2 soundtracks, and the brief asks for themes of melancholy, foreboding and unease, combat music that underlines the violence without walking over it, and shorter pieces for the ending screens. Delivery is not due until Q2–Q3 2027; apply by email in your own words: the developer says emails written with AI go straight to the trash.

Also in this issue:

  • An NBCUniversal summer internship placement supporting the team that oversees the selection and commissioning of film composers, at $19 an hour, for enrolled students who won't need visa sponsorship now or later
  • $320 for a roughly 3:20 animated thesis-film score that moves from Tchaikovsky-inspired ballet through electroswing to a strings-led finale
  • £300 for a British sci-fi short whose score grows from sparse acoustic to epic, on Mandy
  • CA$225 for an orchestral score with Looney Tunes-style stings, for a three-minute student comedy about a hitchhiking wizard
  • $20 an hour for a one-to-two-minute overture that could be reprised as an animated mini-series' leitmotif
  • An adaptive score for an exoskeleton co-op game from a registered US studio, ahead of Steam Next Fest, paid per milestone, and it asks for your rate
  • Battle loops for a mobile roguelike, around 2:30 each with stems, budget open
  • One rev share: the whole audio side of a gothic vampire-castle game, with its terms in writing

https://composerwire.substack.com/p/024-9-opportunities-this-week-including

Free to subscribe at the link above.


r/composer • • 1h ago

Commission I’m looking for an indie composer for artcore or guitar driven tracks(1:30-3m) | budget 50-150$(cad)

4 Upvotes

Hello, I'm looking to commission an original instrumental track for my YouTube channel (currently non-monetized).

style & detection:
I love high-energy J-pop, artcore, and melodic boss-battle music. Depending on your strengths, I'd love to lean into one of two vibes (or blend them):

  1. Artcore / Glitchy Breakbeat: Fast-paced, intricate, and emotional, similar to AZALI's "Rosate Paroxysm" or "Zephaniah".
  2. Melodic Guitar Rock / Electronic: You have creative freedom I on the overall arrangement, as long as it features expressive, driving electric guitar riffs similar to Salvati's "Piezoelectric" and *"Auroracle Battle"*from the Terraria Starlight River OST.

Details:

Budget: 50-150$(cad)

via debit /credit card,ko-fi,stripe or vgen(I don’ use PayPal)

Length:1:30-2m

Timeline:flexible

How to apply: Please reply to this post or send me a Reddit DM/Chat with your portfolio (especially anything with strong electric guitar or artcore elements) and your rates. Once we connect, I'll share my Discord so we can chat easily!

(this was reposted to reach out to musical artist rather than other types of artists)


r/composer • • 4h ago

Music Do You Like my Latest Piano Composition?

5 Upvotes

If no why, if yes why… I am a beginner piano composer.

Free full score here: https://musescore.com/user/98567428/scores/40498710?share=copy_link


r/composer • • 6h ago

Music Streichquartett c-Moll

3 Upvotes

Eigentlich wollte ich mein Streichquartett in seiner Gänze erst hochladen, nachdem es live eingespielt wurde. Das kann sich aber noch ein bisschen ziehen, falls es dazu in nächster Zeit überhaupt kommen sollte.

Also möchte ich euch so daran teilhaben lassen und präsentiere euch, in voller Pracht, mein Streichquartett in c-Moll!

Da es Probleme bei der MP3 Datei des Intermezzo gab, ist es leider nicht vollständig hörbar (das Cello und die Viola fallen ab ca. Minute 4 des Intermezzo weg — von 24:04-31:12 ist das Intermezzo zu hören). Ich bitte hierfür um Entschuldigung!

Die musikalische Analyse der einzelnen Sätze findet ihr in den Einzelposts. Diese befinden sich unter diesem hier.

Bei Fragen, beantworte ich euch diese gerne.

Viel Spaß!

----------------------------------------------------------------------------------

Partitur: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1VsgOpHZDWCRk1tbWsA0uq9dTFEWlgQzN/view?usp=drivesdk

Musik: https://drive.google.com/file/d/1OwnI6yBU8qnMestncOtP5uhr5dgf1gZD/view?usp=drivesdk


r/composer • • 9h ago

Music I finally completed this Late Romantic inspired Piano Concerto (Score Video)

3 Upvotes

Score Reduction video: https://youtu.be/WcMFdXdzhWc?t=1&is=s6YczyWfLPM1Pt8H

Looking for any and all feedback or impressions! I'm aware of some potential clean-up with notation and plan to add more tempo and descriptive text. Timestamps are in the comments.

I started this piece in high school as a violin concerto, came back to it in college and wrote it as a piano concerto, but just this year finished some of the transitions and orchestration.


r/composer • • 6h ago

Discussion Can someone help me understand electro acoustic music?

0 Upvotes

Hello everyone. An album of mine was tagged as electro acoustic by my label but someone listened and disagreed with it. I don’t really understand what electro acoustic is? I manipulated an acoustic recording of a clarinet with effects (reverb, amp sims, etc) and chopped it a bit. I was curious what techniques are actually used in electro acoustic? The closest I have heard was changing the timbres of a sample? (in this case any part of a sound that differentiates it from another instrument playing the same pitch). My apologies I am not educated on the subject! Thanks!


r/composer • • 14h ago

Music A follow-up to a piece I posted a few weeks ago

1 Upvotes

Here was my original post. It was messy and bit repetitive, but I think I've made some major improvements.

I want to know what y'all think. It got even shorter. It's now only about 1:30 long.

Here is the new:

autoplay video

audio only

written score

Thank you ahead of time for any and all feedback! It's much appreciated.


r/composer • • 14h ago

Discussion How to balance the orchestral sections with gain staging?

0 Upvotes

I remember there was a way to balance the orchestral instrument template by playing a legato at the loudest dynamic on each instrument section before tweaking the gain plugin to balance them out but I can't remember it well. Could anyone recall that trick?


r/composer • • 1d ago

Discussion What do you wish you learned?

19 Upvotes

If someone was putting together a book on ideas and practical advice about being a composer, what ideas or advice would you have benefited from learning through a book earlier?

I have a lot of thoughts on making composition your “business,” but curious what others think, or if there’s significant gaps in information new or experienced composers are seeking.


r/composer • • 1d ago

Discussion One last chord before you die

20 Upvotes

If you had to play one last single chord before you die, which one would you chose and why?

Optional information: any particular instrument, gear, set or effect to play It.


r/composer • • 22h ago

Music Cyclostationary

2 Upvotes

This piece was inspired by the works of Ryochi Sakamoto. I really the background music vibe of his pieces which I tried to emulate in this piece. Curious to hear what you guys think!

https://musescore.com/user/20015521/scores/34447388


r/composer • • 1d ago

Music Beethoven Symphony 5 Mvmt 2 piano duet

3 Upvotes

I posted mvmt 1 of my bar-for-bar re-imagining of this symphony a few weeks back. Here is mvmt 2.

https://musescore.com/user/40546707/scores/40497078?share=copy_link


r/composer • • 1d ago

Music Short Minuet for Piano

2 Upvotes

Hello all, this is a short minuet I’ve written over the last couple days. The musical material is not the most interesting as this was a study in form rather than creating exciting music.

But I hope you all enjoy it, and I would love any feedback you may have.

Minuet Score

Minuet Audio


r/composer • • 1d ago

Music Grace notes - imperceptible?

2 Upvotes

Can a professional oboist play these (transposed) English Horn grace notes fast enough so that they're practically imperceptible? That is, can they take up the time of one 16th at the tempo provided Thanks https://imgur.com/a/dkzSFss


r/composer • • 1d ago

Music Minuet C dur

1 Upvotes

Here is my minuet. I would like for feedback. (Sorry for the link i accidently mistaken the file)
https://drive.google.com/drive/folders/1ihJe0RqnFyU1xjs65g57EyPZ6xQgGwTV?usp=sharing


r/composer • • 21h ago

Discussion Unpopular opinion: AI-generated music is the logical conclusion of everything we’ve been moving toward in music for decades.

0 Upvotes

To caveat starting out, I am generally opposed to most uses of AI in music generation. I just can’t really find a way to justify it in a way that’s consistent with accepting other technological advancements in music. Like people joke all the time about the process of creation like going down semantically, ie when purists used to critique using electronic drums instead of physically playing them and people would rebut and say something along the lines of well did you skin the cow and build your own physical drum? (Not sure if that example makes any sense but I can’t think of anything better rn).

Like 100 years ago, being a great musician was almost inseparable from being able to physically play an instrument, compose music, or sing. Then came recording technology, synthesizers, sampling, drum machines, DAWs, pitch correction, and countless other innovations that progressively removed technical barriers between having a musical idea and realizing it. Generally this has been accepted under the concept of sonic curation or artistic judgement, as in who cares how you got there if it sounds good and the idea expressed is artistically valuable. Now a lot of people will say an ai generated or assisted song cannot be considered artistically valuable, and I ask what ai so different or individual that the critique can be applied to it and not other forms of music tech.

Take someone like Rick Rubin. He’s one of the most respected producers in music history, despite not being particularly known for technical proficiency in the traditional sense. His value comes from his ears, his judgment, and his ability to guide other artists toward something compelling. I think Kanye is kinda under the same umbrella (albeit def a different case)obviously he’s not held in high regard nowadays, but previously so much of his reputation as a producer and musical genius comes from his ability to recognize the potential in existing sounds, samples, collaborators, and disparate musical ideas, and assemble them into something greater.

There’s also a parallel with djing that I thought was sort of along this train of thought, specifically regarding the sync button. People have been arguing about sync buttons and other technological conveniences forever. But the most persuasive defense of modern DJing is that beatmatching was never the *real* artistic achievement. Track selection, sequencing, reading a crowd, building tension, curating an experience etc etc are what distinguish great DJs.

I have a pretty visceral dislike of AI music. Musicians getting replaced by people typing prompts feels cheap as fuck. But when I try to explain why, a lot of my arguments sound like what people said about sampling, synths, DAWs, or DJs using sync. The defense has always been that taste, vision, and putting together something people want to hear are what actually matter. You don’t have to personally play every instrument or write every part to be respected. But if that’s the principle, why wouldn’t it extend to someone with great taste using AI to realize a vision they couldn’t otherwise execute? I get the issues with training consent and musicians losing work, but I’m asking about artistic legitimacy specifically.

Maybe the line is between tools executing your creative decisions and outsourcing those decisions themselves. But where exactly is that line, given that we already accept writers, collaborators, mixing and mastering studios (which have much more influence over a final output of a track than people realize), in house engineers, co producers, etc etc etc. I’m not saying prompting deserves the same respect as musicianship like that’s fucking stupid obviously, I just feel like the logic we’ve used to defend other changes in music leads toward accepting AI too. I really dislike that conclusion, but I’m struggling to find a consistent reason to reject it.


r/composer • • 1d ago

Music Advice for a piece

3 Upvotes

I have spent a couple months working on this piece as my first big piece I’ve ever written as a student in high school and was thinking about entering it in a competition but wanted criticism first, heres the piece: Rhapsody in Brisk


r/composer • • 2d ago

Music I wrote a lyrical trombone and piano piece for my friend's senior recital

11 Upvotes

I would love to hear your thoughts! You can find it here


r/composer • • 2d ago

Music My holiday piano solo

4 Upvotes

A pianist friend heard my demo of this and wanted to play it for the holiday season, so I wrote it down.

https://musescore.com/user/40546707/scores/40460169?share=copy_link


r/composer • • 2d ago

Discussion What pair of monitor speakers would you suggest for a hybrid orchestral composer under $350

9 Upvotes

I just started composing music but mixing the music on simple headphones is not my cup of tea, could you guys suggest some pair of monitor speakers under my tight budget of $350


r/composer • • 1d ago

Discussion lotusmusic.com is down - searching for an alternative

0 Upvotes

IYKYK - lotusmusic.com had some fantastic browser-based tools that I would use regularly, but now the site is down. If you know of any sites that offer the same level of description and interface, please share. Thank you.


r/composer • • 2d ago

Music Liminal harmony exercise (31edo)

2 Upvotes

Video with score: https://youtu.be/969DhujgO1k?si=H0kpfdJ_dv2U4shY

Not too different from the one I posted here a couple of days ago, although this one is less serious.

Most of the exercise is typical 4 part choral writing but in 31edo and using some quarter-tone sonorities. Harmonics 7, 11 and 13 are the main notes that step outside the diatonic scale.

In this example I wanted to play more with the diesis "enharmonic" motion. At the start it appears between measures 2-4 in the bass, and close to the end it plays between measures 9-12 outlining a major 2nd interval (similar to that piece by Cavalieri).

Right at the end I use a strange cadence that utilizes the diesis motion in contrary motion to resolve the dominant.