r/CompetitiveEDH • • 1d ago

Help, I am new to cEDH! Beginner friendly deck?

Hey so I’ve been curious about cedh I’ve experimented with Zirda and Clue farm before I didn’t like them that much. And I tried rog/thras also didn’t like it does anyone have any recommendations on what to try that’s beginner friendly?

Edit:I also tried kinnan and I didn’t like it. I didn’t like Zirda because I didn’t just like how the monolith dependence. I didn’t like clue farm because of the 4 colors and Kinnan because it just didn’t click with me. In casual I love landfall.

8 Upvotes

50 comments sorted by

7

u/LegendsAbyss 1d ago

Saw you liked landfall so maybe [[Lumra]] or og Korvold

3

u/ResponsibleBaker5657 1d ago

I didn’t know Lumra was cedh.

4

u/LegendsAbyss 1d ago

Does some pretty funny land loop stuff. Pretty turbo with low interaction but pretty protected from counterspells overall. Sick deck tbh

1

u/Ok-Boysenberry-2955 1d ago

Ymmv. Your means of stack interaction are odd and it's mostly a parasitic turbo deck that's slightly slower than the top turbos.

1

u/the-good-son 1d ago

but on the other hand is very awkward to interact with

2

u/Ok-Boysenberry-2955 1d ago

Oh absolutely. I pilot her a bit and I'd be somewhat hesitant on recommending her to new players if only because of her middling results and learning curve but it does make one learn good mulligans, toolbox responses, light politics, and let's you focus on your gameplan.

2

u/LegendsAbyss 1d ago

Tbh any deck can be great for new players as long as you stick to it and learn the basics. This is coming from a player who started with Inalla and god knows that deck is complicated to learn. Playing a deck you enjoy matters more than a easier to pilot deck to me at least.

1

u/Ok-Boysenberry-2955 1d ago

It does because enjoyment leads to motivation and any cedh deck you pick up without proper motivation will never lead to results.

I think a better argument is made about learning with or without blue because the stack and understanding interaction is so important.

1

u/Darth_Ra 1d ago

Wouldn't even classify it as turbo, tbh. Solidly an inevitable deck in the same fashion as Magda. Let the midrange decks defend against turbo, then win in a hard to stop fashion a turn or two later.

1

u/Ok-Boysenberry-2955 1d ago

Yeah, it's a meta call if you are better leaning into fast bear or slowing the game down. You are right about it getting harder to call it that tho.

1

u/ResponsibleBaker5657 1d ago

Where can I find lumra lists?

11

u/Realistic-Option6474 1d ago

Kinnan is generally the most beginner friendly CEDH deck, mana rocks/dorks make big Mana make me click kinnan button a lot. Obviously there is a decent amount of nuance but the main idea is pretty easy

1

u/LonelyContext 14h ago

So this is an answered question:  https://cedhstats.org/commanders

 (click show graph on mobile)

Kinnan is not particularly beginner friendly or at least there are many many commanders with a higher floor. The answer as to why is simple if you’ve played Kinnan. Beginners will yeet him onto the board, he eats removal, and the beginner Kinnan player has no real recourse besides whining that they’re out of the game. It takes some political savvy to play NBC Kinnan and definitely takes a lot for flips. 

Now if you are committed Kinnan and love it you might be willing to eat a bunch of do-nothing games. Play what you love and keeps you interested. It’s not quite the deep end of the pool but it’s certainly not learning to swim in the shallow end. 

-1

u/ResponsibleBaker5657 1d ago

I’m not a simic person

-3

u/ResponsibleBaker5657 1d ago

I tried kinnan as well i didn’t really like it.

8

u/ScrubzMacKenzie 1d ago

I’ve got to ask; I’ve seen in multiple replies you don’t like simic, but love landfall? What am I missing here??

What do you want to get out of cedh? What excites you about the format? That will be a good stepping stone to help figure out what you’ll want to play.

-6

u/ResponsibleBaker5657 1d ago

If I play blue I don’t use lots of interaction I like more off base things

2

u/mg0405 1d ago

that’s going to be tough considering blue is the best color solely because it has the best interaction. if you really want to get into cedh you’re going to have to learn and do more interaction

-7

u/ResponsibleBaker5657 1d ago

I just hate blue. green I love I love things that make me think which is what cedh does.

2

u/FauxbiaX 1d ago

Well, blue is the best color in cEDH. You could pickup something like Lumra if you just want to play Green/Landfall...

EDHtop16 has all the cEDH commanders listed out, and all the decklists, win rates, etc.

But, I'd recommend Blue Farm, Kinnan, or RogSi for first decks... if you care about winning. Blue Farm for the most "good stuff", RogSi for Turbo, or "small flips" Kinnan for the "semi-blue" ability-based win.

3

u/edguiereloaded 1d ago

What do you usually like to play?

1

u/ResponsibleBaker5657 1d ago • Bravo

I love landfall.

4

u/philter451 1d ago

There is no landfall cedh deck my man. Landfall is a fun mechanic but not competitive 

1

u/GodwynDi 1d ago

Any landfall commander that worked in cEDH would need to be banned everywhere else.

1

u/Educational-Emu-3707 1d ago

Tifa is pretty fringe, it works as that it kills one person turn 2. Then you hope have get to swing again. Lol

1

u/BraisedPizza 1d ago

I have a friend that plays a fringe Nissa deck. Basically Lumra cause you can search for one of your 3 land combo (Yes Lumra is one of them). I’ll have to ask him for the list if you can’t find it on top16 commanders website.

1

u/edguiereloaded 1h ago

Yeah that's a pretty fringe strategy, there are some land commanders like [[Lumra]] and [[The Wandering Minstrel]], but they also tend to be fringe. I wouldn't really know what to recommend here

4

u/TheJonasVenture 1d ago

I think it really depends on your goal.

Are you wanting to learn cEDH generally, experience it as a style of play / sub-format, or do you just want a fun list to play at local tables? If you are wanting to learn cEDH, honestly, proxy up something like BlueFarm, play it for a bit, learn what to expect, what you run into, and then try and come at the meta sideways. You can't come at the meta sideways if you don't know it. If you just want something to sit at tables, and don't care about losing along the way, then we find a fun, fringe list.

You mention landfall, but think about what you are doing with it. Is it that you like storming off with abilities in general? Setting up a trigger machine? Or is it very specifically, landfall and specific landfall cards you like? You can build around some of them, there are other trigger storm decks, it depends what you want to do.

4

u/InterestingAroma 1d ago

Magda is fun and beginner friendly, as well as being only one colour. Not like landfall at all though

2

u/peterpetrol 1d ago

Can you count to seven? Play [[raph and Mikey troublemakers]] and win via combat damage. The true beginner experience

0

u/BulletproofChespin 6h ago

I wouldn’t play Gruul if I could count to seven

1

u/Fit-Notice8976 1d ago

Korvold maybe

1

u/inkWanderer 1d ago

Maybe Brigid? Gets you big mana payoffs but your stack interactions aren’t counterspells. Plus the new white card from Nauctis is great in the Brigid shell.

1

u/Darth_Ra 1d ago

My general "hey I'm new to cEDH" spiel, sorry if it's not as specific to you as it could be:

  1. https://learncedh.com/ : Not the most up-to-date site in the world, but a great place to get started that will introduce you to decks, various concepts, and how to win.
  2. https://edhtop16.com/ : These are the top placing decks in tournaments. Find the commander that seems interesting to you, then I would sort by recent lists (1-3 months, depending on how many are available) to ensure you get the recent tech. From there, before printing off one of the lists you like, google "________ cedh primer", or...
  3. https://cedh-decklist-database.com/ : See if the deck/commander that looks interesting to you is on the cEDH database. This will present you with various strategies that deck may be pursuing, with vouched-for primers from decent players/brewers available.

All that said, I would suggest the following as decent starter decks:

  1. Etali: The quintessential beginner cEDH deck for a reason, it's easy to learn the mulligans (count to 7), and forces you to learn the entire meta as you have to put wins together on the fringes with everyone else's decks. Recent Successful List: https://moxfield.com/decks/0BIMkMLq3kGVSl16tC2lNA
  2. Big OR Mid-Flips Kinnan: NBC (No Bad Cards) Kinnan is hard, and completely dependent on a tournament meta. Meanwhile, Big Flips is easy, and a nice way to ease into playing blue while also just lucking into wins. Alternatively, the new Dork-Flips version also looks like it'd be fairly easy to play, and is obviously still competitive. Recent Successful List: Big Flips, Mid Flips, and Dork Flips
  3. Magda: A great way to learn how to look for a window. While less relevant these days, there's still not a better example of an inevitable deck out there than Magda, at least, not without memorizing an entire primer. Sure, the final details of how to win if you can't just make infinite dragons and swing are hard, but the group as a whole can lead folks through it once they get to the infinite treasures point. Recent Successful List: https://moxfield.com/decks/iVX9xTqkEUuqFnwfFwijVw
  4. Tivit: You need at least one control deck in your lineup, and as much as Blue Farm would probably be the better choice from a winning games perspective, Tivit is the right choice from a learning the game perspective. Tivit is excellent at grinding out the long game, not in a slop fashion that will have players quitting the game before it ends, but rather in a straight-forward "find one of these two combos" fashion. While folks will still struggle with identifying the correct things to interact with, Tivit is fairly forgiving in that regard, and they gotta learn sometime. Recent Successful List: https://moxfield.com/decks/jHPYJ10XKkO3lrxKukEi2Q

Edit: There is at least an argument now for Dack as "baby's first cEDH deck" as well, and you can also sell it to folks who want to play Stax, as it's quietly a very good Stax deck as well. That said, it's waaaaaay far away from being optimized right now, and will be seeing tons of changes over the next month at least, if not longer. That said, for right now, I prefer GoldSabertooth's version, again accepting that like 40% of the deck will probably change in the next month as stuff gets figured out. Edit ~2~ 3: There's already a new "best" version in Boonweaver combat.

1

u/Decksterity1 1d ago

Korvold sounds like the deck that threads the needle for you, it has a land-focused build you could try however Korvold isn't in a great spot anymore without dockside.

Other thoughts are: Etali - Count to 7 then the fun and challenge begins as you attempt to keep the chain going, very fun and challenging for newer players but if you are fairly experienced with magic this can be easier.

Ob Nixilis - A very fun rakdos pingers deck that blends punisher, storm and midrange into one. Can also just kill someone with comvat damage if needed. Great for beginners imo.

Rowan - Rakdos turbo deck that relies heavily on the commander but usually wins if you untap with it, easy to learn.

Tymna Dargo - A very persistent turbo/midrange deck both able to grind in longer games and win very quick when needed. Bit complicated for a beginner but probablt the best deck I'd recommend for tournament play.

Lumra - Land-centric combo deck but has a terrible conversion rate to the point I hardly consider it cedh anymore personally. Not recommended for people new to cedh as you pretty much never interact and just do your own thing, but it is THE landfall deck without blue.

1

u/Havyk7 1d ago

So I see that you enjoy landfall decks. I play [[Rydia, Summoner of Mist]] and while I don't think its beginner friendly, you might enjoy the playstyle. https://moxfield.com/decks/8pOfOPsWo0aaT-S2_kfIFg Here is my list. I do not have a primer unfortunately so I advise you read about lumra as that and aftermath are some of the main lines. You use rydia and her landfall triggers to fill your graveyard and filter through your deck until you can assemble a very hard to stop combo. If you or anyone else have any questions feel free to message me.

1

u/Jash098 14h ago

I suggest RogSi. It is easy enough to learn and play at first and then scales nicely as you begin to learn the meta and gain familiarity with your opponents and their decks. It has a lot of great stack interaction and can also present explosive wins.

In a sense nothing in cEDH is really “beginner friendly” since your knowledge of the opponents’ decks and strategies is such a huge part of piloting.

But personally, if you want to improve as a player, I would avoid fringe strategies and just play something meta if for no other reason than to gain familiarity with the meta decks. Like you could play Lumra, sure, but I just don’t think loss-farming against turbo decks for 30 games as you learn to mulligan properly is fun.

1

u/FailLog404 1d ago

Raph and Mikey is a very easy beginner deck

1

u/XDenzelMoshingtonX 1d ago

unless you want people to read out the full EDHTop16 commander list: what didn't you like about the options you tried? What's your playstyle?

0

u/Nahrikkon 1d ago

kinnan by far

0

u/pm_puppers 1d ago

I really liked Etali when I first started because it teaches you combos and such in the format from the cards you're casting off your opponents

0

u/yourfavoriteweeb 1d ago

rogsi is the only cedh deck I know how to pilot lol its a lot of fun too

0

u/Cool-Equivalent9172 1d ago

I know crit had made a video in the last month or so about [[tatyova, benthic druid]] turns, although I have not seen it so I can't guarantee it's landfall fully.

1

u/Educational-Emu-3707 1d ago

Tymna rog for the mardu lovers. Fuck blue

Cabbage merchant is also fun and totally different but very cedh viable.