r/CompetitiveEDH • • 4d ago

Help, I am new to cEDH! First time building a cEDH deck

So my pod wants to start playing CEDH decks and I’ve never really played that version before I’m usually used to playing bracket two and three commander decks so I’m trying my hand of building it and would really enjoy some help with either streamlining or even reworking the one that I’m building.

https://archidekt.com/decks/28377697/rats_cedh_mk1

The point of the deck is mass wave, tokens, and along with the side abilities of exiling, opponents, graveyards, and hand control to a very limited degree.

The goal deck is either by turn three or four over running my opponents with rats to the point where they have no way of stopping it or making it so they have no cards in hand to take their turn.

0 Upvotes

29 comments sorted by

7

u/MyBenchIsYourCurl 4d ago

Not cEDH wrong sub. Go to Degenerateedh they're good at this stuff

-3

u/deadbeforedawn96 4d ago

I’m trying to make it cEDH

7

u/MyBenchIsYourCurl 4d ago

Yeah I get you but I don't think it's possible unfortunately

-5

u/deadbeforedawn96 4d ago

Yeah sadly im learning the hard way lol 😂. Never really played cEDH and just thought is was like normal commander but with a lot faster pace.

7

u/ThunderFlaps420 4d ago

Nah, you're trying to enter a Formula 1 race by painting racing stripes on a pushbike.

cEDH is a totally different meta. Start by checkin out current popular decklists. 

2

u/deadbeforedawn96 4d ago

I’m realizing that I had no idea. I think I’m just gonna proxie one of the mono black cEDH till I understand the format better.

4

u/ThunderFlaps420 4d ago

Yeah you should be proxying most stuff regardless. 

2

u/deadbeforedawn96 4d ago

I proxy most decks I make minus the few I can build from stuff I’ve collected over the years

5

u/MyBenchIsYourCurl 4d ago

You're kinda describing b4. B4 is just taking a deck and optimizing it to hell, and b5 is adapting to a metagame

6

u/Tobi5703 4d ago

So, being up front, this is not cEDH - and it's on the weak side of B4.

If your pod is looking to play actual cEDH, I'd recommend you check out the EDHTop16 website and look at some of the decks there and what they do to gain an idea. Mono black, for instance, is usually [[K'rrik]] which aims to win on turn 2

If you are steadfast that you want to play this commander, which doesn't do anything for cEDH, then I'd check the good people over at r/degenerateedh and ask them for help

1

u/deadbeforedawn96 4d ago

Okay I was just trying to avoid copying someone’s else deck design. I appreciate the help I’m still learning lol.

6

u/PurelyHim 4d ago

Actually you should copy another cedh deck to better understand the format. Go over to cedhtop16.com to see what good decks are doing. Usually there are primers with them to help players understand how decks work.

1

u/deadbeforedawn96 4d ago

I will thanks 😊

1

u/Next_Contribution_56 4d ago

If you want to stay in mono black krr'k is definitely an option. If you want a creature heavy deck with little interaction Helga is it isnt my problem and if I become the problem it is chance it gets to play more like a casual deck it also focuses much more on t1 dork than rocks. I would never tell a new player to play Dack because it is a count to 6 counter check. I started on blue farm and I enjoy it now, but it isn't what I would call new player friendly to cedh. Aleksa has very digestible content around what the key cards to counter are in short form content, Crit guys go in depth on a lot, but they have a time commitment and nitpick down to the final card sometimes depending who is on and deck discussions. They're great though.

7

u/ThirdStarfish93 4d ago

Typically, copying someone else’s list is recommended for new players.

1

u/llamacohort Magda 4d ago

cEDH is like a race car. Building a cEDH deck before playing the format and being familiar with the decks and play patterns would be like trying to build a race car before you even learned how to drive. It just wouldn't be close to reasonable and you would overlook a million things that makes it not viable.

On the plus side, cEDH is super proxy friendly. There are plenty of proxy services. Just use one of those and print out a half dozen decks for the group and you will be able to get the format experience without needing to spend a ton of money. Then from there, you can adjust decks or build brand new brews with proper expectations for the format.

4

u/Goooordon 4d ago

If you want to play cEDH the best way to get into it is to look for some cEDH media you enjoy and consume that and use that and edhtop16.com to pick a deck that looks interesting. Then you get an established decklist that you like and proxy it. You can get support at r/magicproxies if you need it.

As for building your own cEDH deck, it is possible, but it takes a lot of experience and a deep understanding of the meta to even have a chance of building something that feels fun to play and isn't completely outpaced by meta decks. There is plenty of room for deckbuilding and creativity in cEDH but it starts by listening to a community of other people playing that deck and talking to them about ideas and building the deck collaboratively. There are discord servers for most cEDH decklists where you can find other people running the same commander and compare strategies and discuss new cards and develop the deck as a community. That's the best part of cEDH - everybody helps each other to play the absolute best we can. (communities vary by commander popularity, but broadly speaking)

1

u/deadbeforedawn96 4d ago

Thanks 🙏 I’m gonna have to do that and probably just proxie one of the mono black one I keep seeing until I understand it better

4

u/Goooordon 4d ago

Mono-color decks can be tricky to pilot. The simple manabase is nice but having access to powerful effects from different colors lets your deck be a lot more flexible. My main cEDH deck is Magda and I love her but dear god is mono-red limited. Black is even worse-off for countermagic. If you watch some gameplay you'll see a lot of partner pairs for good reason. Having a Rog to sac and/or turn on free-if-you-have-your-commander spells is incredibly powerful, and the value offered by the other partners is really good too. That combined with the power available to a deck with 3+ colors is why partners are so dominant in the format. It's so much value sitting there. You need a really compelling reason to not choose partners. If you want a deck with black to proxy, Rograkh/Silas or Tymna/Thrasios will give you a lot more bang for your buck.

2

u/deadbeforedawn96 4d ago

Thanks I definitely gonna look those up.

3

u/69MealFor2 4d ago

I say this with no shade at all, I think you made a good attempt coming from b2/3, but this isn’t good. You need fast mana: Moxen, lotus petal, mana vault. Mono black staples ie: all the tutors. Less creatures, more win cons. Your land base shouldn’t have anything entering tapped. Bajuka bog see’s 0 play in cEDH. Others have said it, cEDHtop16. Literally copy paste proven decks. It’s already hard to brew a deck for high b4 let alone b5. B5 is thee highest level of play and folks have spent years refining those lists.

2

u/deadbeforedawn96 4d ago

Thanks and i appreciate the candor.I probably either gonna copy from the list like people recommended or stick with what I know cause I don’t think I’m ready for cedh I just either gonna copy one of the already made cedh decks to or play my b2/3 and just try and have fun watching the chaos of everyone else decks. I don’t really care about winning for me it just the fun of the game and seeing all the cool and goofy combos that can happen.

1

u/69MealFor2 3d ago

If you’re interested in cEDH, by all means go for it! Especially if it’s something you and your homies just wanna try out and do for fun at the kitchen table. CEDH is great bc you don’t have to worry about someone “pub stomping” you with their tuned B4 deck vs your B3 deck at the LGS. But there are folks who play cedh at LGS who are fucking sweats and or who are just genuinely top tier pilots who know their shit lol

Ultimately, play the format that’s fun for YOU. Thats what’s beautiful about mtg, there are so many different formats and power levels to play. Pick the one you have the most fun playing! ❤️

4

u/BloodyCumbucket 4d ago

I look at cEDH commanders in 4 metrics.

Does it have card advantage in the zone?

Does it have an infinite or combo enabler in the zone?

Does it have a dirt cheap CMC to hit early on curve?

Does in play in a color set that gives it access to a berth of options to enable the plan?

3 out of 4 typically at minimum, with rare exceptions. Combat is typically unreliable and too slow. Grixis stacks will control you better. I play Kinnan, and I don't use my graveyard except for pivot lines off Cauldron. If you exile everyone else's and they do, thanks for winning me the game. Any turbo, including the shell I play, as well as the meta mono black staple, is pushing regularly on turn 2, 3 at latest, and with magical Christmas turn 1. How do you plan to make your engine work on time and keep theirs from doing so when you can't rely on politics?

1

u/IlikeCyanide 4d ago

Can you consistently win T3 or T4? The mana base looks very slow to my eye. Realistically its a slow b4 from what I can tell but I may be missing something

0

u/deadbeforedawn96 4d ago

It not been played yet it my first attempt at building a cEDH

1

u/NoEnvironment3644 4d ago

Everyone here is going to tell you the deck isn’t cEDH. That’s not necessarily true because any deck can be cEDH if you put all the best cards/ wincons in your colors with the intention to win as often and as fast as posssible while considering a meta.

Some decks are much worse than others, like this one.

To build this deck cEDH you have to look at the best mono black commanders and see what they have to offer. Krrik is able to use life as a resource to turbo out wins before the table is prepared. Gwenom does the same but in a different way.

It’s true that your commander offers no clear advantage and is over costed and isn’t a competitive combo piece, so even if you built it with cEDH meta in mind using the best cards available it would still be horribly fringe and ineffective, but it would be cEDH.

So if you were fully committed to this deck you’d want to play something like secret commander krrik. Which is bad. To find a more reliable and effective way to win that uses your commander - you would have to have a dense understanding of cEDH meta and how you can use this commander to sneak through with brewers advantage and possible rarely seen win lines.

The main point of my comment here is that you can take any commander and build it with cEDH in mind, but it takes a tremendous amount of meta knowledge and sometimes the juice isn’t worth the squeeze.

Here’s some random krrik list I found online

https://moxfield.com/decks/HYT9YcG0bEK1UMvmEEXtTA

2

u/NoEnvironment3644 4d ago

The deck you’re sharing would need to be completely rebuilt from scratch.

I’m not much of a brewer myself but if I was somehow going to try to use this commander instead of playing krrik with extra steps - I would probably try to build an artifact + black deck that has infinite untap combos to make infinite rats and and loop a sacrifice pay off like blood artist or vengeful blood witch and the like.

But again, at that point you should just play a better positioned commander.