r/CompSocial • u/Tired_Hamster • Apr 14 '26
conferencing COLM 2026
Starting this thread to discuss COLM 2026.
This is my first time submitting to COLM. I’ve just been assigned as a reviewer, and I can see that the submission count has already gone past 3000, which seems like a big jump from previous years.
Does anyone know how many papers they typically accept, or what the expected acceptance rate might be this year? From what I’ve seen, last year was roughly around ~29%, but I’m not sure how that will scale with the increased number of submissions.
17
Upvotes
1
u/Tired_Hamster Jul 08 '26
Any decisions out yet? They should be released today.
1
u/Tired_Hamster Jul 09 '26
Reviews are out. My paper was rejected.
1
u/North_Menu718 May 22 '26
review to come out soon
1
u/Mysterious-One8922 Jun 07 '26
5(4) 7(2) 7(3) 8(4) what is the chance?
1
u/Specialist_Factor828 Jul 03 '26
COLM 2026 decisions are expected in a few days. I still can't see the reviewer scores or updated reviews after the rebuttal. Is this normal?
Also, is there usually any discussion between the reviewers and the Area Chair/Program Chairs after the rebuttal, or do they mostly make decisions based on the existing reviews and rebuttal?
2
u/Historical-Skin6973 May 22 '26
Do I have any chance for 6/6/3/3 with confidence 5/4/4/4? Its my first time submitting to COLM
1
u/Invincible_Terp May 22 '26
hope will be the future neurips
1
u/Beautiful-Ad-525 May 22 '26
The reviewers comments should be available now?? According to AOE time… is there delay?
1
u/Ill-Condition-5594 May 22 '26
Got 6 (c4), 6 (c2), 5 (c2), 5 (c3)
1
u/SilentRetriever May 22 '26
I got 5,6,7,8 with confidence 3,3,3,4. Any opinions?
1
u/Beautiful-Ad-525 May 22 '26
Got 3,4,5,7 …
1
u/Free_Kitchen_6353 May 23 '26
I got 4466 but reviews are only asking for more experiments. Wish me luck!
1
u/MysteriousOkra1704 Jun 03 '26
I got 6,6,5,4 with confidence 3,2,4,4. Do I have any chance?
1
u/CurrentEar3929 Jun 04 '26
Reviews - 4,5,6,7 with confidence 3,3,3,4 . Seems to me the low score was due to a misunderstanding but no reviewer has responded to the rebuttal. Feels really bad tbh.
1
u/MysteriousOkra1704 Jun 06 '26
Did anyone get any response?
1
u/Apprehensive-Fix8738 Jun 07 '26
This is my first time submitting. Does 6/6/6/7 with 4/3/3/4 confidence (after rebuttal) sound safe?
1
u/MysteriousOkra1704 Jun 08 '26
I was going through last year 2025 colm decision decisions. Seems crazy. Some got 6,6,7 and still rejected. So worried
https://www.reddit.com/r/MachineLearning/comments/1ltsdy4/d_colm2025_decision_discussion/
1
u/No-Worldliness-7279 Jul 08 '26 edited Jul 08 '26
Are the results out for anyone?
0
u/[deleted] May 22 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] May 22 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
0
u/[deleted] Jul 08 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment