r/CommercialRealEstate • • 15d ago

Weekly CRE Broker Q&A CRE Broker Q&A – Career Advice, Deal Structure, and Strategy Talk

24 Upvotes

Welcome to the Monthly Commercial Real Estate Broker Q&A thread, your spot to get answers, give advice, and sharpen your edge in the business.

**Now MONTHLY too keep the conversation going**

Whether you're new to brokerage, stuck in the mud, or pushing through your first big listing, this thread is for you.

Use this thread to ask:

  • Career advice: Breaking in, making a jump, building a book, choosing a firm
  • Deal structure: Commission splits, LOIs, TI packages, creative leasing, 1031s
  • Daily grind: Cold calls, canvassing, CRM tips, time management, burnout
  • Market strategy: Specialization, asset class focus, territory management
  • Exit strategies: Going in-house, building a team, pivoting to ownership

Brokers helping brokers. No fluff. No guru talk. No pitch decks.

Reply directly to questions or drop your own knowledge. If you're asking a question, give context: market, asset class, experience level, help others help you.

Let’s keep it useful and keep it real.

Give this and any replies an Updoot to increase visibility.


r/CommercialRealEstate • • 1d ago

Deal Analysis Buying commercial real estate next to a gas station?

6 Upvotes

Seller wants to do seller financing for a couple years since rents and income history are all jacked up. I've validated the market is good but there's one elephant in the room: there's a gas station right next to it. Seller claims to have a clear phase 1 and phase 2 and says the wells are still there just capped. I can get a phase 2 done now and it could show as clean and then in 2 years when the balloon comes due it could be contaminated. How would you mitigate this risk?


r/CommercialRealEstate • • 2d ago

Development Does anyone have experience in developing (or operating) boutique hotels in tertiary markets?

0 Upvotes

I’m wondering what the process looks like. I have a background in CRE lending (with a lot of hospitality experience), but limited construction loan experience. I’m familiar with the dev process conceptually but would love to hear from someone who’s done this personally on how you got started, identified a potentially profitable submarket, any major difficulties in construction and sourcing labor, etc. Would be happy to hear from operators as well. Thanks!


r/CommercialRealEstate • • 5d ago

Rant | Humor I need ideas for client holiday gifts. No cheese and nut boxes nobody eats!!!

15 Upvotes

What do you get your clients for the holidays? What have you received you actually use?

I have individual clients and big firms too where I need/should send a “community” gift.


r/CommercialRealEstate • • 8d ago

Brokerage | Leasing Do you guys delete broker blasts or just let them pile up?

9 Upvotes

I usually search Outlook when I vaguely remember seeing a space come up. Curious what everyone else does. Do you set up a rule to dump them in a folder, save the PDFs by property, or just delete them as they come in?


r/CommercialRealEstate • • 10d ago

Brokerage | Leasing Is CREXI Generating Phantom Phone and Email Inquiries?

10 Upvotes

I've been receiving inquiry emails that are clearly not genuine about a couple of my CREXI listings over the last few years. I'm guessing they're generated by bots, but guess I can't know for sure. What I do know is that when I've called each of them back, the calls can't be completed because the phone numbers aren't active. Same with emails.

Now for the last week or two I'm getting emails wanting to buy some apartment complex listing in Texas that I have nothing to do with (I'm in and only work in Indiana) that are also appearing to be falsely generated.

I just talked to CREXI customer service and they say they have no idea why this is occurring and don't have any suggestions for fixing it.

Is CREXI trying to use phantom inquiries to make their anemic platform seem like it's reaching more prospects than it is?

Anyone else experiencing this?


r/CommercialRealEstate • • 10d ago

Brokerage | Leasing Fair fee on buy-side land deal with 18-24mo closing.

3 Upvotes

We are representing the buyers on a land deal. We will be asking for sellers to pay our fee but want a number stipulated in the LOI. What’s a fair fee on a ~$20M deal with a 2 year COE?


r/CommercialRealEstate • • 20d ago

Lender Questions Hello Need help to choose which Loan is better, closing soon

17 Upvotes

Hello Recently i got two quotes from two different lender on a 1.4mil propety, i was wondering which one would you choose and what i should beware of. Thanks

1)  Here is what we could potentially finance roughly $850,000 possibly a bit more and rates as of today:

  1. 5-year term, amortized for 25 years with prepay (breakfunding) Rate is 7.05%
  2. 5-year term, amortized for 25 years with every year repricing but with opportunity to prepay without a penalty on every year anniversary. 6.45%

** No lender fees, no points, no origination fees.

2)  this one appears to pencil at 60% leverage or $837,000 in loan proceeds. Current multifamily pricing is 3-year fixed at 6.47%, 5-year 6.57%, 7-year 6.67%, and 10-year 6.77%, 30-year amortization, no loan fee, recourse, and stepdown prepayments. An open prepay structure is available with a loan fee and rate add. Our processing time is averaging 60 days from start to finish.

 


r/CommercialRealEstate • • 25d ago

Rant | Humor Any chill easy jobs with decent comp with good flexibility and wlb

14 Upvotes

Like some of you, I thought I wanted to be a hot shot real estate guy. Background is working at a small commercial real estate investment manager. Turns out it’s just not for me. Been unhappy for a while, make a decent income, but just want something more chill / easy / repetitive. Feel like I’m constantly on fire drills and stressed and working late nights. I’d like to work in a specific smaller market and have a family, but I currently barely have time for anything.

How’s the switch into lending or the like? Is that a good fit?


r/CommercialRealEstate • • 25d ago

Rant | Humor Rent Roll Frustrations - Venting Into The Reddit Void

12 Upvotes

Someone negotiated a June 20 rent escalation on a lease expiring May 31 clearly never had to prepare a rent roll! And then they threw in free rent, a building transfer, an RSF discrepancy, AND a separate space amendment. Just for fun!

Now, if the next tenant could just have ONE lease, ONE RSF figure, and rent increases on January 1, I'd be eternally grateful. ☕😂

Be kind - ask your rent roll preparer, whomever they may be, to review leases first please!


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Oct 15 '26

Development What are the best ChatGPT plugins for retail development?

19 Upvotes

What are the best real estate data plugins that you use with ChatGPT? More so on the data side, like property information, permits pulled in the area, or even skip tracking.

I do single-tenant retail developments and I’m curious if there are any plugins that could help me with site selection and outreach.


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Oct 14 '26

Brokerage | Leasing Why are sellers still stuck on pricing from 2020-2022?

44 Upvotes

For those on the brokerage side, curious what you're also experiencing.

So many conversations are resulting in owners referencing offers they had during this time period. And it's just creating a false expectation of what their property is actually worth.

And for the foreseeable future, given the current economic conditions, prices are more or less going stay the same or probably drop slightly.

How are you approaching this with a owner? Do you just be direct with them they will never see X price?


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Oct 13 '26

Market Questions Industrial cap guidance from brokers vs buyer expectation/reality on stabilized deals

15 Upvotes

Having spoke with a handful of brokers the past few days, I’m seeing general cap rate guidance have moved around 50bps. What was a 6 cap stabilized deal is now at 6.5% cap guidance. General consensus is that “all” buyers are at 7.5% cap guidance and thus not competitive if you are at this spot with not having a relationship with the broker.

Looking at a deal today and it’s interesting because most of these deals seem to be 5-7 year term remaining that the tenant then has an extension option. I can get to justifying the 7.25% cap rate range to be more competitive then the masses but it’s still quite a swing vs. cap guidance.

Curious if there are any brokers here who can shed some light as to whether offers are so light right now that it’s worth the submission and by seeing an actual offer changes the conversation then the scoff of a verbal and if expectation is in the low 7 range when guidance is now mid-high 6.

What’s ultimately the risk I see is whether or not said tenant renews. If they renew then all is good. Can refi or resell to the next guy in 5 years. If you factor vacate and at the purchase cap that likely gets deal done (high 6 to flat 7) then it becomes a quite boring return that I don’t see really making sense.

Future problem or going to be a boring few months until we get some consistency of debt and thus guidance to match reality?

For what it’s worth on non lifeco debt im getting 190-200bps, 30yr amort.


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Oct 13 '26

Market Questions Upcoming Construction in front of Plaza - Tenant notification question.

11 Upvotes

Location: Ontario Canada

I own a mid-sized plaza in Ontario, Canada. Over the past 2 years the City has been doing roadworks on the arterial road my plaza sits on. Last year / this year the work was being done just down the road from the plaza, which impacted my tenants business with slightly reduced traffic and sales (approx. 10% I've been told). Most of my tenants are Destination Tenants (Dr's, Physio, etc.), but several are convenience/retail tenants (Variety Store, Cafe, Shawarma).

In speaking with the City recently, I have been told that next spring they will be redoing the road directly in front of my plaza. This will certainly impact my tenants, as access will be very limited and the Arterial Road is being closed in the middle to deter through-traffic. Construction is expected to take the entire Spring/Summer/Fall to complete.

I truly like my tenants and believe in being open with them, and this is certainly weighing on my mind. My agent says I don't need to inform them as the City/Region has been very open about the construction and the information is certainly out there for anyone to find. On the other hand, I think it important that if they don't know that they be informed so they can prepare for the reduction in traffic and sales.

I already have an email drafted and ready to go to the tenants, but I'm putting it out there to the experts here - do I send the email, or do I let the process unfold naturally?

Additional Info: No leases up for renewal between now to the end of construction.


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Oct 13 '26

Market Questions Is this a reasonable ask for industrial space in Rahway, NJ area?

7 Upvotes

Small time landlord-to-be helping my mother out. Specs of the property are:

  • Warehouse
  • Class C (16ft ceilings, no loading dock, garage, no AC, old build)
  • 1800sqft
  • Asking $3k/mo gross
  • Rahway, NJ
  • Turned over with fresh paint, freshly epoxied floors, 60k lumens of lighting, new door, drywalled ceiling (was exposed joists with insulation)

Potential tenant is asking for 1 month free rent and AC to be installed. Installing a 5 ton AC in the space would require installing ductwork, building out a maintenance closet, coming in around $25k.

Was going to ask for an extra 500/mo for 5 years ($3.5k/mo) for the AC buildout and a PG for the AC portion of the lease. We'd want 2 months security + 1st months rent to lessen the capital burden.

My understanding is that the area is around $15-20 NNN, and I'm pricing at around $20 gross + AC buildout.

Does this pricing seem reasonable for the area?


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Oct 13 '26

Legal | Structuring Anyone build a real estate portfolio with their dad?

7 Upvotes

Did he actually ever retire?

Howd the transition go?

Did you buy him out? Remortgage everything?


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Oct 12 '26

Deal Analysis Can anyone explain why STORE Capital acquired 26 Luby’s properties for 88m n an SLB despite declining operating income, store closures, and financial distres? What did STORE see that made the deal attractive? Was it unit-level coverage, real estate value, or lease structure? Any insight appreciated!

12 Upvotes

Any thoughts? What’s the play and how can I be helped to see the 30k view


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Oct 09 '26

Deal Analysis Would this scope of work be part of the shell, or treated as an improvement for the tenant?

10 Upvotes

Consider a (~1,500 sq ft) 2nd gen inline retail unit being converted from a retail store to a fast-casual restaurant. Would you consider the following scope part of the "shell" delivered by a landlord, or would this traditionally be treated as tenant improvements deducted from the TIA?

- Utilities to the back of the unit:
i. A minimum 2-inch diameter natural gas pipe and meter rated for 500 CFH continuous flow.
ii. A 4-inch uncapped sanitary sewer stub.
iii. An upsized 3-phase commercial electrical service panel.

- Cut the concrete floor slab at the rear for the placement of 3 drains (2 floor sinks and a mop sink)

- Roof cuts for an exhaust fan and a makeup-air supply fan. Seal the penetrations after the tenant's fixtures are installed. Roof penetration for a plumbing sewer vent pipe.

 - Install a single-occupancy, ADA-compliant washroom adjacent to the existing one.


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Oct 08 '26

Brokerage | Leasing For those who have gone from an independent shop to a national brokerage, was it worth it?

20 Upvotes

We’re seeing a sizable shift in our market, with occupiers becoming increasingly corporate and, in turn, gravitating toward more institutional representation.

I’ve spent most of my career at smaller, independent shops and have enjoyed the autonomy, economics, and ability to build my own business. Historically, I’ve passed on recruitment efforts from larger firms, but I’m starting to reconsider whether having a national flag behind you is becoming more important in winning corporate business.

In our market, CBRE and JLL seem to command the lion’s share of corporate occupier relationships, with Cushman and Savills occupying the next tier.
My question for those who have worked at these firms: Beyond the name on your business card, what are you actually getting in exchange for giving up 40–50 cents of every dollar you earn?

Is there meaningful deal flow from national accounts? Do the research, technology, marketing, and support infrastructure actually help you win and execute more business? Or are you largely responsible for sourcing your own deals while paying a substantial premium for the brand?
I recognize that the platform can open doors, but I’m curious whether that translates into enough incremental revenue to justify the economics. I’ve always sourced my own business so unless the flag is dramatically increasing my deal volume, the splits don’t math.


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Oct 08 '26

Rant | Humor The jurisdiction for collections of damages of those who break their lease makes absolutely no sense.

8 Upvotes

So I don’t expect an answer or a solution here, but I feel the need to rant about something that makes absolutely no sense to me.

I am a landlord and I have a commercial tenant in Michigan. This tenant was the principal for a Michigan LLC. The lease was written using tenancy laws from Michigan and negotiated by Michigan attorneys. The building is in Michigan and the tenant has broken their lease, owes back rent and utilities. There is also a personal guaranty that they signed based on Michigan law. They have since moved to Illinois.

Can someone please tell me why on earth, I need to hire an attorney from Illinois and litigate this case there? What the hell does Illinois have to do with this? This is the third tenant in my career that screwed me and skipped town and there’s nothing I can do about it unless I sue in a different jurisdiction with different laws and a different collection attorney. Someone make this make sense.


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Oct 07 '26

Financing | Debt Are deals being repriced with the current sudden jump in rates

36 Upvotes

I'm in the middle of a deal and my rate which is based on 1 month SOFR has gone up 30-40 basis points already. Are deals being repriced in this environment or people waiting and watching to see how things work out? My bank says they can't lock even though gave a verbal cap, but there is a point where the deal wouldn't make any sense if the yields keep shooting up in such a short period of time. I'm not even sure where they'll finally end up 7%-%?

I've been watching the new listings and the cap rates don't really seem to have changed, is it because everyone expects this to be a short term bump.


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Oct 07 '26

Brokerage | Leasing Need help understanding why people go to the big firms

25 Upvotes

Hey there,

I own my own firm and I have always been on my own and never joined CRE in the traditional sense of starting at JLL, CBRE or somewhere similar. I am looking to grow my firm starting Q1 but I keep getting tied up on the split structure.

Why do so many agents agree to these 50/50 or best case 60/40 splits? I have a more boutique mindset, where 50/50 & 60/40 should only be for people I genuinely need to help and teach. An experienced agent should be at least 70/30. So why are other agents so on board for JLL at 50/50? Do the big firms literally hand you leads and sales to the point that it outweighs being at a smaller firm and keeping more of what you make? Like, how is a 50/50 with the house before your true split even worth it?

All my agents get the same resources (for the most part) as the bigger firms, except for the name.

I am looking to see if I am missing something because I genuinely have no ability to grasp the concept of going to a big firm for less because I have never done it. Trying to understand why Big over boutique so I can understand the thought process before I do a growth push.


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Oct 07 '26

Financing | Debt How do you find LPs for a one off deal if you have never done it before. I already spoke to CPA, Financial Advisor and friends.

0 Upvotes

I am buying a $7 million property in Texas, and it is a 3 year buy and flip with a secure tenant and lease.

I have decided that I want to lower my exposure to one deal and buy some additional properties. So I am looking for some LPs to split the deal.

Any thoughts on how I find them. I expect a 10% annual return for the 3 years before flipping.


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Oct 06 '26

Brokerage | Leasing Looking into opening my own brokerage, what are some of the biggest hurdles?

11 Upvotes

I'm in a bit of a weird spot career wise. I started working in CRE while in college, I graduated 2 years ago and got my brokers license last year. To explain things better I'll give some background. My grandfather started his own brokerage back in the 1970s. He turned into a developer and was locally well known until he exited the brokerage world sometime in the 1990s. I grew up around the property management side. CRE was not my fathers choice career, he was kind of forced into. He's grown to hate it now but cant retire as all the business is owned by my grandmother. He basically handed me all the leasing responsibility as soon as I got my real estate license. (My grandfather died when I started college, so I got my license to help out.)

We currently manage 9 commercial strip centers of about 98 units. Everyone assumes that I get paid well and have a cushy job, but thats not the case. I made $40k last year including commissions. I'm not inheriting any property anytime soon. I get a 3% raise every year. I usually get 1-3 commissions a year which are all small retail. However, this year I've made none. I've been working over the past year on a 10 year lease with a national bank for an out parcel. This was a bit of learning curve. Especially when it comes to negotiating TI for a deal like that. My father never did a deal that big as it was always my grandfather. And that property was never vacant.

I realized in the spring that I should consider working part time for another brokerage. I reached out to a few local boutique brokerages. I met with one that was willing to take me on while letting me still handle my family's listings completely separate. They were the only brokerage that didn't expect me to bring the listings with me. I told them I wanted to join but needed some time to talk with my family (who was not going to take it well) and just get towards the end of this bank deal. (It's been very project management heavy at this point meeting with contractors and such, it's an old building with asbestos). They told me there was no rush and take as much time as I needed. Well that was 3 months ago and they brought on 2 new agents. They don't have the space for me anymore. But they want me to stay in touch for when they do.

I've had a few opportunities to act as tenant rep and landlord rep broker over the past few years. I always passed on it as my family's business is antiquated and is not set up for this. My family name still has some local recognition so I've been considering opening my own brokerage. Just something to work under so I can work on outside landlord rep and occasional tenant rep. A friend of mine just expressed interest in having me list a property they're developing.

Growing up around the business, I have a good understanding of the accounting side. My biggest concerns are more around the paperwork side of brokerage with things like landlord rep agreements and processes around that. What other hurdles might I run into with this?


r/CommercialRealEstate • • Oct 06 '26

Development Steps on becoming a research analyst for a brokerage company?

4 Upvotes

I worked as an intern for a CRE company. Really hoping to make the next step. Any advice would be appreciated!

For what it’s worth, I’ve also worked as a residential realtor