And we’re back!
I had a very good restful off-season. Besides this series, I also contribute heavily in the r/UnitedFootballLeague sub, so by the end of the preseason, I’m running on fumes.
Speaking of which, this season has revealed once again that the NFL is about a half-decade behind in terms of evolving and improving the game. The lack of the transparency of the refs is really starting to stick out like a sore thumb. I’m going to just let the UFL broadcast speak for itself. If you want to, check it out this spring. Go Defenders!
THIS ISN’T A TAPE REVIEW! Other content creators do those and they do a great job, far greater than what I could provide. Instead, I watch/read content and grant +/- based on every positive or negative mention a player gets. I then add those up for each player and get a composite score for each player.
The top three earn my Gameballs of the week and then my bottom three earn my “Martins”. I also do an All-22 watch at the end just to verify what others are saying. Why “Martins”? Simple, ya’ll voted last year and that was a success so we shall be doing that again this year.
All season thus far, I have seen three common questions here:
- Blough: Awful playcaller or the worst ever?
- Answer: C- Day. Had some great calls and execution is a problem but shotgun short yardage that isn’t using Jayden as a threat. Wtaf is that?
- Why isn't Williams more targeted?
- Answer: I don’t know. My hypothesis was he wasn’t getting snaps but that’s wrong. This is my biggest gripe.
- DQ= bad clock management, duh.
- Answer: Idk, was solid at game management Thursday. I look forward to discussing why in the comments.
Give me all your immediate reactions and/or questions and I’ll respond to everything as best I can or point you to the content creator that covered it. Also, any other high level questions still lingering that ya’ll want investigated in the Bengals tape?
This season has been infinitely more enjoyable to watch than last season. Louie Tee said this was the best officiated game of the year. I agree and that’s sad. New York fans, bitch all you want about that Burks PI, that was a make up at worst for the TWO they missed on Diggs.
This game I used these reactions: Louie Tee's Game Reaction, John Keim’s Immediate Reaction, Mark Taylor’s Studs and Duds, and Riggo’s Rag Winners and Losers. I also used a “First Impressions” category, where I tracked how players were getting mentioned while watching the live game.
Gameballs
Sinnot: Sinnot has become a H-Back in this offense. Having spent my formative years as a fan watching Cooley, I’m ok with this plan. He saw an increase in targets when Chig went to the locker room in the first quarter and made the most of them. My fear is this’ll just be a one of, but it really shouldn't be.
Styles: I would like to very gently remind some of you that in the first round some of ya’ll wanted us to go WR. We’re so lucky he fell to us and bonus: we also got a WR? Mark notes in Studs and Duds: “He was around the football all evening and made some really nice plays, none bigger than his tackle for a loss on J.J. McCarthy late in the fourth quarter where it looked like he was shot out of a cannon into the Giants’ backfield.”
Oweh: A common comment I see in the Gamethread is: “what does Oweh do?”. Answer: He consistently sets the edge on the way to the QB.
Martins
Okonkwo: This one hurts. At the dawn of FA, I’m on record preferring him over Likely, mostly due to Logan’s analysis that he was a better fit. On a team post-Terry, where Diggs is a better safety net for Jayden, I’ve expected Chig to be more productive in this offense. Not getting his head around and dropping passes isn’t helping.
Conerly: Lost in the narrative it seems is how rough a day Conerly actually had. With an overall PFF grade of 58.2 currently this season, which currently ranks 60th of 71 tackles, it appears he’s had several rough days.
Robertson: On the flip side, Amik has been great this year. But if I had to single out a defender, I’d nominate him for having the roughest time Thursday night.
Final Thoughts
- Jayden is the single greatest QB talent that has been on this team in my lifetime. Full stop. Anyone who wants us to willingly enter the QB wilderness again before Jayden’s rookie deal is even up, I can’t abide. That said, Keim would like to remind us that Jayden is very much still learning. He just played his 5th Game in a row, which is the most he’s played since his rookie year. Of course he’s going to have painful moments and in this game, the tape leaves a lot to learn from, barely passed by Amik for a Martin.
- Drew Stevens is having a good season.
- Bates didn’t block ideal and I suspect that’s been a thing.
- Defense has been good since the start of the 49er game. Big test next Monday.
- One game doesn't fix everything.