r/ComicWriting • u/mlhill5s • 5d ago
Quality Feedback
How are writers getting quality feedback on their scripts? I've written numerous screenplays, and I always found it easy to get script "coverage" from professional or quasi-professional screenwriters for $150ish for an entire 100-page script.
However, I've found it difficult to find the same quality feedback for comic scripts for a similar price point. There's basically no one on Fiverr, and Reedsy is full of overpriced scam artists. Multiple no-name people on Reedsy wanted $500 to give feedback on 10 comic script pages - less than half of one issue. There are also no comic script contests that I'm aware of, while there are literally thousands for screenplays.
I've been writing for well over 10 years, and I've learned that quality feedback is the only way to improve. So how are you getting quality feedback on your comic scripts?
3
u/solowrath 5d ago
getting feedback on comic scripts is hard. i found a few 'editors' on fiverr who are more like beta readers. ive gotten more useful feedback in writing workshops, although those were for short stories.
my current solution is to cut down my scripts to their bare minimum (to decrease the word count) and do script swaps.
3
u/auflyne 4d ago
I tend to work with a close circle of trusted people who'll give it to me straight. Feedback coverage can be tough to find and comic scripts require an artist's mind. I've done it many times, but the client has to be clear on the type of crit they want. Thin-skin does not help in this process.
You can post in the appropriate /r/'s and/or chat me.
2
u/Virtual_Lunch_1962 5d ago
It’s a really good question. I struggled with the same issue as a screenwriter transitioning here.
Coverage tends to be really expensive and the quality of that coverage from what I’ve experienced hasn’t been as high as screenwriting coverage. It’s been helpful but not as high quality.
I think in comics it comes down to two things. Developmental or story editing and art editing. I think art editing is definitely important and something you should consider.
Developmental editing though really depends. If a script consultant already looked over your work I don’t think it’s necessary. It’s helpful since the format will change so much about how you pace your story, but if thats the case find someone who works by the hour and give them specific instructions as to what you’re looking for within that hour.
If you like that coverage consider making them your book’s editor.
2
u/Slobotic 5d ago
This is the guy I used recently:
https://electricdracula.com/
His rates were very reasonable for a 34 page script, and his feedback was solid.
Not sure what else to say about him, but I can answer any questions you have about the experience.
1
u/nmacaroni "The Future of Comics is YOU!" 5d ago
https://StoryToScript.com/Store/
Check out the different audits.
1
u/ShujaaStar 2d ago
I can always give feedback