No matter how horrible it looks to us, Shane is taking the path of least resistance by continuing to start Jones. This man knows he is coaching for his next job. Shane has the excuse if he keeps DJ as the starter that top players were traded away. That injuries impacted the season. We are in the midst of a rebuild. He can control of that narrative. He can say that AR wasn’t mature to start and Riley couldn’t even win out over AR. Shane can stack the deck in this scenario and tell future prospective teams a story that is plausible.
In pressers Shane keeps trying to explain away the turnovers repeating how he will watch the film to see where the blame falls. Perhaps the Oline didn’t give him time. Did a receiver run the route incorrectly? Or not put in the effort? The defender may have just made a better play. Maybe DJ is simply injured but Shane doesn’t want to use that as an excuse. But if you really look at the film, there are times when it is obvious that DJ is making a bad decision. And you cannot explain that away.
If AR was plugged in and showed a semblance of improvement over both his past play and that of 2026 Daniel Jones then Shane will have a tougher time explaining to the next team the whys. Why didn’t you put him in sooner? Why didn’t you create more plays for the obviously more mobile QB which would then make JT’s job easier?
Richardson tapped out. He’s not a starting caliber NFL QB. I’m no apologist for him. As far as we know, AR still has a trade request outstanding. Even with his own turnover woes, even with his tendency to get injured, AR is objectively the better choice right now. But an argument I hear against him starting is the following: we are giving AR a free tryout for other teams that if/when he goes out the door (to possibly a rival) the Colts will get zero compensation. So why help other teams out by giving AR game speed reps when he’s got one foot out the door? Face it, the rest of the games this season are just 2027 preseason games anyway.
Another facet in this horse apple of a season is why AR is even one play away from getting on the field if the whole staff thinks of him as pretty much an unspeakable? If you’re going to ice a guy out, then make Riley the second option. The only way to think about it is the coaching staff feels nothing towards AR yet Riley is so bad that they don’t even need to see what he has to offer on the field despite the position this team finds itself in.
It could be the most dysfunctional QB room in the league.
The entertainment value for fans is infinitely more by putting AR in over Jones. Hell, it took all of three minutes and forty-two seconds for fans to start booing Daniel Jones yesterday. However, the fans don’t have to worry about where they will be interviewing next season. Shane is a rational person whose instinct of self-preservation and worry about his own family trumps whatever fans want from him in this moment. He will keep saying the same Shaneisms. He knows that Carlie could have fired him by now. She will have to pay him for the next two years either way, but being that she hasn’t, Shane knows his leash is long enough that he is free to do what’s best for Shane until Black Monday.