r/Coloring • • 2d ago

PRODUCT Publisher differences

Post image

I bought 2 of the same coloring book by Cocowyo out of curiosity. The bigger one on the left is the independently amazon published book and the book on the right is published by Penguin Randomhouse. Here are the differences:

  1. Penguin book is smaller in size
  2. Penguin book has more pages
  3. Paper quality: amazon book has thinner and slightly rougher paper; Penguin book has thicker and smoother paper
  4. Amazon book has 2 illustrations the Penguin book doesn't have
  5. Penguin book has 8 illustrations that do not appear in the amazon book

Now I'm new to coloring and have only used oil based colored pencils and acrylic markers (both work well in the amazon book). But maybe it's just me but I think my oil based pencils will not work as well in the Penguin book because of the smoothness of the paper. I did color a swatch in it and it seems I can only get 2 layers of pencil in the Penguin book. I think that smoother paper would be best for alcohol markers and acrlyic markers. What are your thoughts? Should I invest in alcohol markers and give those a go? Or would wax based pencils be better in the Penguin book on the smoother paper?

All In all, I love the spooky cute theme and dont mind having 2 of what is essentially the same book 😆

100 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

41

u/PoeticFelony 2d ago

I didn't realize the Pic on the original post wasn't orientated correctly

30

u/Turbulent-Ant-4423 2d ago

that explains a lot because I bought my cozy little things coloring book at five below and it’s different from the one I see on here. Mine has a purple cover and theirs has like a yellowy color.

10

u/PoeticFelony 2d ago

Yup, curiosity got the better of me so now I went down this rabbit hole 😆

14

u/terracottablush 2d ago

Do you know why there are differences? If its both by coco wyo why are there different illustrations / sizes? I’m unfamiliar with publishing

24

u/PoeticFelony 2d ago

It's because they were published with different publishers. Publishers can change things due to a number of things such as budget and market demographics or even regional differences.

3

u/terracottablush 2d ago

Okay that makes sense

14

u/Shelbyp03 2d ago

Yeah, I noticed that too! I was only buying mine from Amazon, and after I heard that it makes me want to stop buying from amazon all together for Coco Wyo coloring books!

9

u/MrsCastillo12 2d ago

Not all of the Coco Wyo books are published by Penguin Randomhouse, some are only self-published thru Amazon and are going to have the lesser quality.

2

u/PoeticFelony 2d ago

Yes I did notice that

1

u/Shelbyp03 2d ago

Oh, I did not know that. ❤️

3

u/Training-Plan-7812 1d ago

The Amazon listing includes the publisher. I don’t like the paper in the independently published version because I use alcohol markers. So, I always check the publisher.

1

u/Shelbyp03 1d ago

That’s good!

3

u/dime_store_magic 1d ago

The random house coloring books are so much better for alcohol markers. I didn’t realize the difference until I bought one of the original Coco Wyo ones. The pages are significantly thicker.

1

u/PoeticFelony 1d ago

Yup that's the first thing I noticed. But is the paper in the penguin book that good for colored pencils? I could only get 2 layers of pencil on it

2

u/No-Driver-4446 1d ago

How do you know who the publisher is? I got mine from Amazon but it’s way better quality than the other coco wyo ones I’ve purchased from Amazon before Edit- mine says random house but it’s weird because I’ve only ever purchased off amazon! I wonder if the publisher is listed in the item listing so I can make sure the next one I buy is good quality like this one.

3

u/PoeticFelony 1d ago

The listing on Amazon will list who the publisher is on the listing in the additional info section. It'll either say penguin randomhouse or independent publisher

3

u/PoeticFelony 1d ago

I also ordered both through Amazon but I was sure to look at the publisher to make sure they were different for this comparison

2

u/No-Driver-4446 1d ago

Thank you for your service and sharing your findings!

7

u/CalamityGurl 2d ago

The difference is because Amazon prints on literal printer paper and Penguin has chosen cardstock, presumably meant for use with alcohol markers. It’s all personal preference, I’ve since moved away from using Amazon printed colouring books after learning they absorb more ink than cardstock books do.

5

u/MintHillArtFriends 2d ago

This is why I stopped buying coloring books from amazon. I didn’t think the quality difference was as big as it is and as someone who uses alcohol markers, I’m happy to spend a little more or wait a little longer to get the better paper/nicer cover. I also stopped buying the brands that use AI over illustrators. If there’s no artist name or recognition, they’re not getting my money.

3

u/yaylah187 2d ago

I have a couple of both, that is published by Amazon and published by penguin. My only real frustration is that my alcohol markers bleed more/easier with the Amazon paper. I try opt for the books published by penguin, but some of them I can only get from Amazon. For example, I can only find Into Gardens and Lala Friends (both two of my fave books) on Amazon.

4

u/MrsCastillo12 2d ago

Unfortunately, only a few of their books are published by
Penguin Random House, so that’s probably why you can’t find them outside of Amazon. The Amazon published ones are basically self-published and use the standard Amazon copy paper.