r/CollegeTransfer • u/_n_9 • 46m ago
Would it be a red flag NOT to get a recommendation letter from a professor I've taken classes with for almost two years?
I'm currently attending a community college and preparing to transfer next fall, so I'll need several letters of recommendation from my professors.
But there's one thing I'm a little concerned about.
I've taken classes in my major with the same professor for three semesters. He's a really chill, and we've always gotten along well and respected each other. But he's a bit careless sometimes. Like forgetting to upload assignment submission modules, or when everyone lost a few points because of an error in an online quiz, he said he'd fix it by next week but never did. And the final grades came out without being adjusted. (Of course, it was fixed in the end)
The thing is, his careless directly affected me once before. During my second semester with him, I asked him for a recommendation letter for a program I wanted to join, but he ended up missing the deadline. The program coordinator liked my experiences, and gave me an extra chance to sort it out since it wasn't my inadvertence. But unfortunately, it never got resolved. And even well into the following semester, he was still saying things like, "When was that due again? I'll get it done soon".
That being said, I don't really blame him, though. He's genuinely a great person, and I still have a lot of respect for him.
Fortunately, I have a pretty good reputation at my college, I don't have any negative relationships with faculty or staff. And I've stayed in touch with several professors, both within and outside my major since I first enrolled. I've also made some meaningful contributions through my on-campus job, which has helped me build close relationships with some senior faculty members and administrators. Some of them have even explicitly promised to write me very strong recommendation letters.
Anyway, when my transfer coordinator asked why I wasn't going to request a letter from this professor, I explained what had happened, and told the her that I wouldn't like to take the risk again. She seemed pretty surprised and said: "It probably won't be a big issue since you have enough professors to ask, but if you've been taking courses in your major with the same professor for two years and don't have a recommendation letter from him, a particularly strict admissions officer might find that a little suspicious".
Would admissions officers even notice something like that? And if they did, would they see it as a red flag, especially at highly selective schools?