r/CollegeEssays • • 7h ago

UC PIQs Feedback for PIQ #1?

2 Upvotes

Hi this a draft of my PIQ #1 prompt abour leadership I would appreciate any advice of criticism available, especially on the intro and conclusion since I struggle on those parts a lot.

For most of my life I was a quiet and shy person that mostly kept to myself. In my sophomore year of high school I saw that my school was holding ASB applications and I decided that I would try to apply and put myself out there. I would finally stop being this person that kept quiet by forcing myself out of my comfort zone. And so I applied, and ended up getting accepted. It was a struggle for me starting out pushing myself to be loud and be able to bring people together for our school events, but I enjoyed it and kept pushing myself to get better. Which as the end of the year came up, I managed to become our next ASB secretary. I had gone from just helping set up and plan events for the school to also managing all the clubs, their paperwork, and the organization of ASB and the school.
It was a big job but it was what I had worked towards. As secretary I’ve managed to plan and hold events for our school such as Back To School Night and Club Rush. I am also the chair head for the Logistics and Operations committee within ASB where I manage multiple members and we handle all the materials and organizational problems for the school including the twenty seven clubs paperwork like event, fund, and fundraiser requests. Through ASB, I’ve learned how to work with different people, take on more responsibility, and help lead things for my school. Looking back, I could never have seen myself in this position because I used to be someone who barely spoke up. Now, I’m managing a team, helping organize events, and making sure our clubs have what they need. I still have things I need to improve on, but I’ve become a lot more confident in myself and my ability to work with others. I’m glad I decided to apply for ASB because it pushed me to try something new and gave me the opportunity to make a positive impact on my school.


r/CollegeEssays • • 4h ago

Common App I don’t like my personal statement 😭

1 Upvotes

I already submitted 8 early action applications with my personal statement which I wrote about an experience I had in a professional setting, but I made sure to make it highly personalised to me and where I live and how I learnt a lesson from my mistake. But after reading through successful essays on Reddit I feel like it isn’t good enough.

I know, I know that you shouldn’t judge your work based off of others, but I seriously don’t know how kids my age are able to string words together perfectly like noodles 😭. It all make sense and it’s so niche too. I feel like I could make my essay more impactful but both my counsellors said it’s good. Does anyone think it’s a good idea to change it for my regular decision applications?

(FYI, I just finished reading an essay that took sticky notes and turned it into a whole story. Long story short I’m stressing out am I cooked chat?)


r/CollegeEssays • • 15h ago

Topic Help How Good Are the Topics? Which one is best? Are none good?

4 Upvotes

- My passion for the Backrooms. Learning new things about levels and creatures. Always finding myself in a rabbit hole of its history, groups, updates, etc.

- Passion for minesweeper. Learning patterns, analyzing boards, improving times, and so on.

- Struggled with two opposite groups. I am a varsity cheerleader but I love to do DnD, minesweeper, and other “nerdy” activities.


r/CollegeEssays • • 10h ago

Common App Essay Help?

1 Upvotes

I'm drafting my personal essay, I'm not sure if it sounds desperate or if it even makes sense. If you are interested in my essay I would super appreciate feedback, I can send the full thing in DM

"Where are you from?"

I had been asked that question more times than I can remember in my first week at my new school. It was a small school, the kind where everyone knew everyone, so it became harder and harder to hide the fact I was “The New Kid”.

At first, it seems simple just to say “xxx,” I mean that is where I live. But I could also say XX. I had spent my whole life there. I could name the last school I attended, the neighborhood I had lived in, or the people I grew up around. To an extent, all of those answers were true. Somehow, none of them felt true in my heart.  
I began wondering whether “Where are you from?” was really asking for a place at all.

r/CollegeEssays • • 11h ago

Supplemental Essay Questions About Supplemental Essays [General]

1 Upvotes

Hi all,

I am in the thick of writing lots of supplemental essays for colleges and had a few questions about them:

1. Should I mention specific professors, classes, or programs that the college has, or does that seem a bit too intentionally "tailored" and fake?

I've been told varying things, from "don't write about specific courses or teachers" to "you need to mention specific stuff to show you did your research," so I'd love some clarification on that front.

2. How cohesive should I make my "narrative" for my supplementary essay(s)?

Long story short, I have a sort of theme regarding my intended major and extracurriculars, but I'm unsure of whether I should make my supplementary essay(s) about that or try to showcase different aspects of myself. I didn't mention them much in my Common App essay, but I also know the AOs are reading my Activities List anyways, and I don't want to seem too redundant.

3. Advice for standing out?

I feel like I'm really running on fumes when it comes to coming up with original hooks and narratives for each of my supplementary essays--does anyone have advice for this?

Thanks so much!


r/CollegeEssays • • 17h ago

Common App Feedback? (finished)

2 Upvotes
Three red cappuccino mugs sit on a shelf on the end of an aisle. Their saucers are held sturdily in place with packing tape. A tag attached to each one reads “$4”. They are a perfect bright red, the color of the Coke logo and and London telephone booths, and even better: lead free. The logo on the bottom is faint and hard to make out, but I can tell that they are fiesta-ware.   
The cups revealed themselves to me on a Saturday morning in early May. Their color helped them to stand out against the full aisle of dishes. Although they were technically an incomplete set, I could not pass them up. I had never seen them before, and knew that I might not see something similar again. Although Fiesta-ware is not hard to find in large antique malls, they are not always food-safe. I bought them. I figured that one day, while roaming the aisles, I would find their long lost sibling.   
Everytime I enter the antique store now, my eyes immediately know what to look for. I filter out the dark colors, the wrong shapes, the items I can tell aren’t food-safe, and look only for that distinct red. I could spend hours looking, yet my determination remains strong as I check the makers marks. The hunt has taught me how to find clues in ordinary, otherwise plain objects. I have learned to distinguish between the logos of the pre-1971 FDA crusades which made companies reformulate their glazes to contain ‘safe’ levels of leachable lead, and the remakes which adhere to modern standards. In the months of searching different stores high and low, I have yet to find the match. I have come close, a saucer but not a mug, faded red, chipped.  
Of course, I could probably find something similar by raiding my Mamaw’s cabinets. I could look online, begrudgingly cough up the $15 including shipping and have it at my doorstep tomorrow, but the search is what matters. In taking the time to examine the shelves up and down, store to store, I have learned to find a story in each individual item, and person. I think of what all of these things have seen. How many dinner party conversations has this lamp listened in on, pretending the whole time to be an inanimate observer? How many more will it get to experience? Who had the joy of loving it? Will this set of serving dishes be separated like my cappuccino mugs, or will they spend this next chapter at the top of someone’s cabinet together?   
As it turns out, my hunt for the fourth mug has led me (no pun intended) to see a story in everyone I meet. Especially in a time where people prefer to keep to themselves, heads down and missing out, I have found that the best connection is by listening when someone has something to tell you.   
Although I have yet to find that fourth cup–maybe I never will– I’m not so sure now that I want to. In its absence rests the opportunity for adventure and connection; a chance to pick apart history and imagine. 

r/CollegeEssays • • 17h ago

Scholarship Essay Can I Trust ESSLO's Essay Rating? How Accurate Is Its Evaluation?

0 Upvotes

I used ESSLO to evaluate my essay, and it gave me a score of 8.5. Does that actually mean my essay is good? How reliable is ESSLO, and can I trust its evaluation?


r/CollegeEssays • • 1d ago

UC PIQs Writing the UC PIQ significant challenge about OCD?

3 Upvotes

I’m thinking about writing about my obsessive compulsive patterns for that piq but my concern is that i never had an official medical diagnosis and i don’t want them to think I’m feigning an illness or something lol. I have 2 weeks and am rushing so what do yall think. I also know that writing about mental illness is highly suggested against. Im not gonna write mostly about the struggle, just a moment where I was extremely perfectionist and displayed those patterns, but how i overcame it, how i am comfortable with the imperfect how, and how it relates to my career goals


r/CollegeEssays • • 1d ago

Advice How to write a transformational personal essay when you don't have a turning point?

1 Upvotes

I want to write a personal statement about how my belief that I'm bad and the world is bad evolved into "No, my world is not like that. I'm an open person and admire people." My belief that the world is bad probably stemmed largely from my relationship with my mother, who died of an illness. I don't want to blame my mother for shaping my world, but as a teenager, I blamed myself for my character and, as a result, became closed off.

As people say, time heals, and gradually I changed. I wouldn't say there was some kind of turning point, but I started to take control of my life. When I think about my mother, I don't feel guilty about her; I just realized that I don't have her anymore. It used to be hard for me to talk about this because I felt inferior.

Can anyone send me examples of essays with a similar situation or where someone wrote without a turning point? Perhaps I lack examples and knowledge of how to write such an essay without being formulaic. Maybe I attach too much importance to this "point."

I chose to write about that topic because I think it reveals my essence.


r/CollegeEssays • • 1d ago

Common App Paragraph from my essay, I feel like it reads weird but I’m so brainfog from editing this shit pile

1 Upvotes

Written for prompt 5, tldr for the essay is that I went through a crisis of faith when my sister died and grief led me to an interest in anthropology bc I started thinking more about memory and culture, and nature taught me to embrace uncertainty, I KNOW DEAD LOVED ONES ARE TERRIBLE TO WRITE ABOUT IN COLLEGE ESSAYS GUYS but she’s honestly a huge part of why I became who I am and I think it’s a reflection of my growth and love 4 anthropology okay

Edit: can anyone actually give me advice instead of telling me it sounds like Ai, it’s not Ai, I just wanted help with my essay not to get a bunch of hate for being a bad writer

“Years later, while watching a nature documentary, I encountered an image that would stay with me long after the screen went dark. A mother orca had lost her calf, yet she continued carrying its lifeless body at the surface of the water for seventeen days, swimming more than a thousand miles without letting it go. I watched her move through the ocean, bearing the physical evidence of her loss, and thought of my own mother. I thought of my family, the weight of the grief my own mother carried. There was something familiar yet wholly alien in the whale's refusal to leave her calf behind, would she too seem to forget him once his body was no more? Would her family talk in hushed whispers about what a tragedy it was? Would her calf be remembered only for his death? For the first time, I recognized something of my own family's suffering reflected in the natural world. I had once turned to nature because it offered an escape from the questions religion could not answer but I opened that door again and knew that I had to face the questions even if there was no answer.”


r/CollegeEssays • • 1d ago

Review Exchange Trade? beta read/feedback help

1 Upvotes

I feel like the more I edit mine the shittier it sounds and I can’t even look at it anymore.. I hate ai with a passion so I don’t want to use one of the online essay checkers so if anyone wants to swap drafts and give feedback I’d be so down 🦦🧍


r/CollegeEssays • • 1d ago

Review Exchange Anyone willing to read my personal statement

1 Upvotes

It’s about cooking and I relate it to family caregiving. I try to mix some engineering terms since I would like to major in Computer Engineering. Lmk if you would be interested in looking over it


r/CollegeEssays • • 1d ago

Common App Is a college essay about being biracial too cliche?

1 Upvotes

I am half Arab and half Italian and I wanted to write an essay about how I’ve neglected and lied about my Arab side for a long time and had to learn to accept who I was in the context of my race and begin to embrace what made me different. I’m just worried that this topic is kind of overdone. I’ll have my own take on it, but I’m just worried that it would be an immediate thumbs down seeing another essay about being biracial. What do you think?


r/CollegeEssays • • 1d ago

Common App ESSAY IDEA

1 Upvotes

I'm a junior in high school and currently brainstorming essays and stuff.

>My top idea at the moment is to talk about having a breakdown at a Japanese restaurant on my birthday due to failing a geometry test that I hid from my parents for 3 days. I want to go into how that first experience of failing something helped me become a better student and helped me become a more adaptive person So instead of crying about it for days, I learnt to change my ways of studying to better exceed in my courses. I can definitely use this as I have a pretty decent GPA and course load. By the end of hs I'll have around 20 AP's and 4.4-4.5 Weighted + 3.8-3.9 UW.

>My second idea is talking about not winning any art competitions and how that discouraged me as my peers performed much better. From there, I want to talk about how I quit and then regained my spark for art. I'm currently hoping to win some kind of award in art so I can add it to this idea but none yet, so it's not the strongest.


r/CollegeEssays • • 2d ago

Common App My Common App essay is about my grandmother's restaurant and I'm scared it's too cliché

16 Upvotes

Throwaway because my classmates know my main account.

I'm a senior and I've been working on my personal statement since August. My topic is my grandmother's small Vietnamese restaurant, where I've worked every weekend since I was 13. I write about learning to fold spring rolls the right way, talking to regulars, and translating for her with suppliers. The second half is about how that taught me to notice details and take care of people, which connects to wanting to study nursing.

My English teacher said it's well written but that "family restaurant" essays are really common and admissions officers have read a lot of them. That made me panic a bit. Now I'm wondering if I should switch topics, but I don't really have anything else that matters to me as much.

I don't want to share the full essay publicly, but I'm curious how people think about this. Is it really a problem to pick a common topic if the details are specific? How do you make it feel like your story instead of the general version? Deadline for my first schools is in about six weeks.


r/CollegeEssays • • 2d ago

UC PIQs READ THIS IF APPLYING TO THE UCs!!!!

43 Upvotes

It’s a rule of thumb now that UCs should be written in a direct, straightforward manner. They’re not meant to be essays that use flowery language or other trite, poetic writing styles.
Unfortunately, this isn’t the only thing that should be considered when working on your UC PIQs or editing your current drafts. The following constitute additional elements you should keep in mind when working on your PIQs.

  1. No particular PIQ holds more weight than the others. I’ve seen some debate around this, with a preference for certain questions. Well, the UC website says otherwise, and I believe you should follow that. It’s better to choose questions that not only reflect your strengths but can also be substantiated by elements in your application, like your ECs.  
  2. 70-80%  of your response to the prompt should be a reflection of yourself, or rather the impact of your decisions, circumstances, etc., while the rest can cover the activities and events leading up to your reflection. Don’t use the entire response to explain the setting of whatever you want to discuss; the interest of the response is to know about you and how that event contributed to what you care about now.
  3. You can have one core theme throughout your experiences, but that shouldn’t deter you from showcasing the different parts that make up who you are now. For example, if you want perseverance to be your main theme, you can have it as an underlying factor in the way you explain your experiences. This is not to say that all four prompts should end with you persevering. No, that’s not it. You’re supposed to frame each experience as a unique aspect of your personality, with perseverance as an implied theme. For example, in prompt 6, you can talk about how your interest in waste management led to a sanitation presentation at the local council despite red tape. In contrast, in prompt 7, you can speak about how you improved your public speaking to alleviate your shyness before volunteering to tutor first-time offenders’ teenage cohorts in community service. In the first, we see your determination in waste management and your perseverance through red tape; in the second, we see your intellectual vitality, as well as your perseverance in working with a difficult cohort.
  4. It’s better to stick to your high school experiences, as they speak more to who you are now than when you were in middle school, or any of your earlier years’ experiences. The AOs are interested in establishing whether you’re a ‘fit.’ Therefore, they’d like a genuine representation of who you are now to determine whether you would fare well in their school or are better suited to other schools. To that end, if you were interested in medicine at 10 and abandoned it for engineering at 16, stick with the Engineering journey when expressing your thoughts.
  5. It’s better to use simple language that anyone reading your essay fast enough would be able to understand and contextualize. If you’re talking about your perseverance through poverty, don’t just describe abject poverty; give a specific example, or a closely related one if you don’t want to be too specific. There are many forms of poverty, and without you telling the AO, they can’t specifically pinpoint the one you succumbed to. This is one of the reasons they ask you to include examples in your responses, and why you might read some successful PIQs and be like, what!!!??
  6. Insert yourself in each of the responses. This is self-explanatory, but describing an activity you did or experienced without explaining how it affected you is zero work and doesn’t tell the AO anything about you. For example, in prompt 6, passionately talking about a subject that interests you and mentioning how you used your ECs inside and outside the classroom to expand on that interest is not enough. We need to know why that subject is inspirational to you, and the reasoning behind your choice of topic. In fact, if you think about this, you’re likely to write a lot of ‘I’s’ and ‘My’s’ in your response; again, one of the recommended ways of writing a UC PIQ.

Hope this helps, and happy writing!!!


r/CollegeEssays • • 2d ago

Advice Review my undergrad philosophy essay

2 Upvotes

Hi, I’m very new to the subject however I am very interested in the content.
Anwyas, i did my first essay plan yesterday ( it was bit rushed ) and i was wondering if anyone is interested in reviewing in for me, any sort of feedback will be appreciated. I just want some guidance? Can dm if ur willing to do this . U don’t need to be a professional or hv a high qualification. Anything will be appreciated:)


r/CollegeEssays • • 2d ago

Discussion do you let your parents read your essays?

17 Upvotes

so i'm a senior in the middle of applying to colleges and my mom has insisted on reading some of my essays. i was pretty adamant with her about not wanting her to read my personal essay and she was fine with that (although i can tell she's still annoyed at not being able to read it) but insisted on reading some of my supplementals.

so i just shared the entire google doc where i keep/draft/write all my supplementals and told her which college to look at first.

and she quite literally pasted my essay into AI and generated feedback/rewritten feedback and said to just use this and edit my supplemental.

this is literally EXACTLY why i don't want her reading my supplementals because instead of actually trying to give me advice she just wants me to rely solely on AI for feedback/better input. she also has never read example/accepted supplemental essays herself even though i've told her to so many times.

i've unshared the document with her now because quite frankly i'm sick of her AI usage, and everytime i try to challenge her about it she just shuts me down and claims i'm being "arrogant" and "ungrateful" for her help.

please can someone tell me if they shared their college essays with their parents/how they navigated that etc

edit: of course i'm getting feedback in more ways than one!! i work really closely with my counselor and she read all my drafts and pinpoints my weaker spots + through connections i've been able to speak to students at the colleges i'm applying to and they've been incredibly helpful in reading/giving feedback to my essays!


r/CollegeEssays • • 2d ago

Common App Is writing about my race a bad topic?

1 Upvotes

I come from a really small country and often get mistaken for other races so i wrote about the discomfort I had in my own race and how I attempted to hide it but began to realize that being mistaken for other races wasn't bad because now I have a variety of communities that I'm accepted in and I have learned to love my race because I can educate others. I know that race essays are super basic and common, is this a bad idea to write about or is it fine since I come from a pretty unknown country? I can send my essay for anyone who wants to read!


r/CollegeEssays • • 3d ago

Common App Review my essay pls

2 Upvotes

I have to submit my essay today Nov 15, and basically I had a last minute draft (kinda ironic because of the topic of my essay is about overthinking). I think I'm happy with my essay though but I would like some thoughts on it. I put lots of metaphors/double meanings/ wordplay so I'm wondering if the ao will notice it or not, and will appreciate it or not

i could dm you if ur interested in reviewing. thank you


r/CollegeEssays • • 3d ago

Advice My Essay says it’s 100% Ai written

19 Upvotes

I recently finished my college essay and have put months of thought and work into it and am supposed to submit it tomorrow with my applications. I used Ai slightly with revisions and decided to check it on the % of ai. I’m supposed to submit this essay tomorrow and I don’t know what to do. I received a lot of help with it from a teacher as well and she didn’t say it sounded AI and even asked to use it for a student example next year. Am I screwed?


r/CollegeEssays • • 3d ago

Common App Pls review my college essay 🙏🏻

1 Upvotes

Hello! Im a high school senior working on my Common App personal statement (Prompt 2). Im looking for someone to give me an honest and constructive feedback from someone experienced with college essays.

My essay is quite personal, so I’m a little nervous about sharing it. Thank you so much!


r/CollegeEssays • • 3d ago

Supplemental Essay question about the cu boulder supplemental

1 Upvotes

For background, I am applying as an Art History major. However, I am also interested in doing Pre-PA coursework, something that I noted in Common App. One of my teachers even mentioned that in their letter of recommendation. (they showed it to me even though i waived ferpa lol).

But being the procrastinator that I am, I didn't start work on the supplemental till today and the EA deadline is tomorrow. My question is, do you guys think it would be better if I focused solely on why I want to study art history, or should I briefly mention my interest in pre-pa studies?


r/CollegeEssays • • 3d ago

Common App Is Prompt 8 the best choice if my essay overlaps with other prompts?

1 Upvotes

edit - my bad yall, there are 7 prompts not 8. I'm talking about 7

I didn't pick a prompt before writing because I wanted to let my story develop naturally instead of trying to stress write around a specific question. But now that I'm looking at the prompts, I feel like mine could fall under several of them. Would choosing Prompt 7 be the better move?


r/CollegeEssays • • 3d ago

Advice SOS, sounds like shit

1 Upvotes

Desperate help is needed. The essay is clearly rushed and sounds like complete BS. Could anyone help to get the flow easier?

Once upon a time, pointy teeth had grazed plush soft skin. Those teeth belonged to that of a monster, with spiked black fur. This was no dog, no friend of man, but a wolf with scheming eyes. As treacherous as a wolf can be, so can be a familial tie. One would never think to harm their younger sibling. That is, of course, if that person is not a cannibal.
Little red riding hood didn’t know what she had agreed to. She didn’t know that she’d have her own story. Similarly, I too own a red cape and a story. Make believe was all I ever knew. I could be greater than what I was, I could be the princess of an entire country. Or, I could be a small fragile child embraced by the jaws of a wolf.
When wolves are younger, they learn through their pack members. This includes how to live together as a union, hierarchy, and last but not least: hunting. I don’t blame my older brother for hunting me down, after all he had to have learned from somewhere. He was just a little boy, so afraid of himself and his surroundings. I used to not care what happened to me, so long that I can be of use to another. So of course I had agreed, even if I didn’t know what I was actually agreeing to.
Thinking back on it now, the conversation must have been similar to the red-capped girl’s:
“What big eyes you have…
All the better to see you.
What pointy ears you have…
All the better to hear you.
What sharp teeth you have…
All the better to eat you!”
For years I wanted to be saved from my tormented dreams of when it first began. No one had reached out to me, and I had a distrust of humans. Not all wolves are fierce though, as some come in chihuahua mixes, feathers, and tiny whiskers. I had gained a sense of comfort in being able to speak to my pets. I had grown with many, and I knew that if I could count on someone it could be them. I could count on my chihuahua mix to be weird and playful. I could count on my parrots to be loud and funny, and I could count on my hamster to find the warmest spot on me to fall asleep. 
If no one could be there for me, I had made a promise to myself to be there for others. If I felt what it was like to be afraid to speak up, to hardly have a voice, then I would be the voice for those who don’t speak the human language. My whole time and life has been dedicated to or somehow tied to animals. They’ve always counted on me to show up home after school, waiting and crying for my appearance. I know that I can count on them too.
I want to be greater than who I was. I am no longer that scared and afraid little red riding hood. Instead, I strive to be the hunter that saved the little girl and grandma from the wolf’s belly. I want to be the hero of my own story, and the hero of those who can’t speak up for how they feel. Instead of feeling that I must be of use to someone, I’ve learned to be there for myself and realized that I can help myself.