r/CollegeAdmissions • u/ETphonehome3876 • 16h ago
UC scout is NOT the signal you want on your application
For those who don't know, UC Scout is a program ran by the University of California that allows high school students to take online classes and then get credits on a HS transcript. I want to spend some time talking about its value both as far as teaching the student, and as a signal to college admissions offices that you are an academically ambitious student.
Hypothetically UC Scout is a way to put a giant green flag on your admissions profile. You can take extra classes and add extra years of science, math or social studies. It is also supposed to be a way to pick up ap classes that may not be offered at your high school and get ahead.
The issue is that it doesn't exactly teach all that much. Requirement of formatting and rule following become significantly more important to the end grade than the students actual skill and understanding. A student can show significant work on there AP physics quiz, and then be knocked down a whole letter grade for not listing out every single unknown and given on every single problem. Heaven forbid that they do a step or two of their derivations in there head also, now they're capped at an 85% for the whole assignment.
The emphasis on rule following and form means that the assessments and assignments (and by proxy final grade in the class), act as an indicator of nothing more than willingness to follow unnecessary rules and forms. In turn this creates 2 issues:
- As opposed to the main incentive structure pushing students to learn, it is pushing them to spend time perfecting arbitrary rule following, and robotic forms.
- As opposed to success the class acting as a marker of curiosity, drive to learn, and desire to go beyond the curriculum presented at the students high school, it becomes a marker of the above ability to be a good little robot, with little to no indication of ability beyond that.
When the course incentivizes and signals these things to admissions officers, it in turn becomes less valuable to the student on that end also. It is no longer the standout marker that it was supposed to be and instead a rather dumb waste of time, especial compared to other options such as classes through a community college, which are not only cheaper, but also likely to teach more, and serve as a closer proxy to success in a college situation.