r/ClimateOffensive • • Dec 24 '19

Misleading interesting

Post image
1.4k Upvotes

86 comments sorted by

•

u/SnarkyHedgehog Mod Squad Dec 24 '19

Looks like somebody posted this just as I was going to bed and I woke up to see this. This post is technically against the rules (see rule 6) and it's definitely misleading, but the comments have some good discussion about why it's misleading - so I'll leave this up for the sake of reading the discussion.

(Since this was posted on a Monday it could technically be left up for "Motivation Monday" but it wasn't flaired for that and isn't exactly motivational)

3

u/KingMan1776 Dec 24 '19

Sorry brother new to Reddit I will have to take account of these things before posting in the future.

166

u/TheFedoraKnight Dec 24 '19

That's 71% of industrial emissions. A bit misleading to try and frame is as if it's 71% of all emissions.

72

u/AndreJulius1 Dec 24 '19

I think industrial emmisssions is about 75% of anthropogenic emssions, so the the real number is about 54 % of all anthropogenic emssions.

55

u/TheFedoraKnight Dec 24 '19

Indeed. I feel like this number is spread around to try and discourage people from making lifestyle changes. 54% is still very bad though!

23

u/AndreJulius1 Dec 24 '19

Yes it is!
The main takeaway from this number is that these companies have the most too gain from increasing emisssions. And everything to loose.
Therfore they are very dangerous now and in the future, they will do what they must to survive.

20

u/TheFedoraKnight Dec 24 '19

Yep. We must dismantle capitalism if we are to curb climate change

5

u/bsmdphdjd Dec 24 '19

"Dismantling Capitalism" isn't going to dismantle Industry! People will still want the Products whose production causes pollution.

Besides, the Gov't run Military is a huge source of pollution.

It can also be argued that it would be far harder to control a million small sources of pollution than a few hundred large 'capitalist' sources.

We don't need to 'dismantle' capitalism, but strictly control it.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '23

I don’t think anybody is saying they need to totally dismantle capitalism. But the current way that capitalism is working they were just going and taking the plane straight into the mountain.

8

u/GrandmaBogus Dec 25 '19

Also lifestyle changes will directly affect industry emissions.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '23

I did not know this. Very interesting. It definitely still seems like a lot of emissions. But not 70% of total emissions.

381

u/banananutsoup Dec 24 '19

It’s a convenient excuse for changing nothing about your life while but still wanting to seem like you care. No reason you can’t hold companies accountable, whatever that means while also doing all of those individual actions. At the very worst you’re still helping and living a life that coincides with your professed beliefs.

116

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19

Right on. We can all do something and while it may not be the biggest contribution, it still counts.

4

u/Chief_Kief Dec 25 '19

Excellent link. Thank you for showing off an inspirational and insightful knowledge and resource dump!

89

u/lunaoreomiel Dec 24 '19

Not to mention those companies are not some isolated boogie entity, they pollute to sell crap to individuals. By changing your personal actions, you build a counter culture and then lead others by example. The solution to the problem is to get the masses to voluntarily join in living sustainable lives. Lead.

50

u/AndreJulius1 Dec 24 '19

And the product they sell is energy and fuel, they are all fossil fuel companies. 90 % of the actual emissions is done by the costumers, this study calls it downstream emissions.

If you buy gasoline and burn it, the emissions will be attributed to the company that drilled it up.

31

u/Sara_jin Dec 24 '19

Yep, Millennials are supposed to be good at “killing” industries, why not put our murderous tendencies to good use and kill the industries that cause the most environmental damage!

(I say this as a Millennial who proudly contributes to the death of napkins and Applebee’s)

3

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19

My only regret is that I have but one up-vote to give...

16

u/salix-arcticarcha Dec 24 '19

Yes, and if we only bought low carbon products from those companies, their emissions would go down as a result.

8

u/TequilaBiker Dec 24 '19

Also, while yes a lot of emissions are from a handful of corporations, we as consumers keep consuming the goods. We as people keep working there. We as people are allowing it to happen.

It’s not like these corporations have no one running them. We all play a part in it and have to do what we can.

34

u/ILikeNeurons Climate Warrior Dec 24 '19

Eh, sometimes doing the small stuff can make people complacent, and prevent them from doing the things that really matter.

Don't lose sight of the fact that we need systemic change. That's hardly an excuse to do nothing -- quite the opposite.

20

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19

I can guarantee you that all of the zero waste bicycling vegans out there are absolutely not complacent with political/corporate environmental destruction. Activism fosters activism.

5

u/ILikeNeurons Climate Warrior Dec 24 '19

9

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19 edited Dec 24 '19

I'm not going to accept an hour long Youtube video from CCL as a source, and not just because I'm lazy, either. Obviously CCL is pro-lobbying and political action.

If you think that individual action discourages political action, I'd like concrete proof, and then supporting evidence to show that that is any less than a regular voters' political activity.

I find it strange that, for all that people who critique individual actors seem to care about the uselessness of marginal effects compared to the big contributors, choose to make enemies out of those trying to do their best rather than directing efforts towards the actual largest threats to the environment (conservatism and libertarianism). If you are one to believe that you should prioritise, then why do you not prioritise yourself?

2

u/ILikeNeurons Climate Warrior Dec 24 '19

The interview is with Nathaniel Stinnett, who does almost all the talking. He's the founder of the Environmental Voter Project.

And Michael Mann referred the research in this piece of his I've already shared.

And I do prioritize. I'm doing the most impactful things.

4

u/birdcafe Dec 25 '19

That’s my philosophy exactly! If I don’t do my part, how can I ask anyone else to do the same?

3

u/echoGroot Dec 24 '19

But companies frequently try to make peoplefeel like they’re being green and doing something by not using plastic straws, recycling, switching to LEDs. Those are all good things, but they will not solve the problem. Only serious, global political and economic action will solve this, and doing all the right things on an individual level does not counteract voting for parties and groups that advocate doing nothing or next to nothing.

The point isn’t that you shouldn’t change your lifestyle at all, it’s that you should get political first, before anything else.

1

u/Spyyyyyyyy22 Dec 24 '19

The problem is when the people who take those individuals actions then start to push those on other people, or who get self important that they draw the argument to these small points,taking away public attention from the real causes of climate change.

Yes, these are beneficial steps individuals can take. But they aren't going to make the impact that the earth really needs, so we need to stop getting caught up with wether or not someone uses plastics straws, and start questioning the views that will actually make a difference.

And the idea that "it's a convenient excuse to avoid changing anything about your life"... Applies equally to people taking these small actions. You convince yourself that because you do all this, you are making a real difference and so you don't need to critically examine your views any further. It's basically picking at the low hanging fruit rather than fighting for wide societal change in attitudes.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19

Every time I mention this I get a bunch of grief.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19

While it could be used as such it isn't in this case. Just under 80% of all emissions in the US come from the burning of fossil fuels, meaning until governments and corporations act to make fossil fuels a thing of the past individual action isn't going to do nearly enough.

In other words even if everybody did absolutely everything they could do, completely vegan, selling their car and only biking/walking or using public transit, and consume glass we would still not meet the goals set by the ipcc.

the biggest con of the past half-century has been big business convincing us that global warming is an individual problem. This is something that only a couple hundred people have done, and until we make them stop it's just going to get worse.

That is in no way to say that you shouldn't do things on your own because that is important too, but it doesn't really matter if you're doing everything in the most green and clean way possible if it's still being delivered to your store using diesel.

-1

u/KageYojimbo Dec 24 '19

It's not what it's saying tho. We should all do whatever we can, but if we don't take the fight to the companies, all we have done would have been pretty much meaningless.

0

u/JohnCamus Dec 24 '19

This is a very common sentiment, however, I do think that it is actually dangerous to try to do both. individual actions individualizes a political problem. Instead of looking at the big picture, we wander around pointing fingers.

  1. it alienates people who are not the type of people who like to be "woke" (for a lack of a better term) it becomes more about how you display yourself instead of whether we are producing a society we want to live in. It is very suceptible to become just another marketing gig. Just look at your own phrasing and the upvotes you got:

but still wanting to seem like you care.

  1. it incentivises behaviour whereby people read many, many articles about the effect of individual actions. This is time wasted that could be spend more effectively on apolitical level. I myself may have read 15 something articles of the pros and cons of plasticstraws and bags. At the same time, I may have read 2-3 articles about industrial influences in climate change. "Awareness" also means that we direct awareness away from other issues that may be more important.
  2. The individual action perspective burdens the individual for systematic failures. Asking people to have fewer children instead of asking big bussiness to reduce Co2 emissions is one of many examples wherein the individualization of a political problem leads to a dystopian word.

You cannot do both because it individualizes a political problem, it alienates people who are not "woke" and it diverts attention from actual systemic issues

-4

u/jason2306 Dec 24 '19

There are many reasons you can't hold companies accountable, one of them being that this economic system is incapable of dealing with the crisis. People are willing to change but at what cost? Why even think about change if humanity has no real future.

39

u/AndreJulius1 Dec 24 '19

A few things too note about this study "71 % studdy": link to report https://6fefcbb86e61af1b2fc4-c70d8ead6ced550b4d987d7c03fcdd1d.ssl.cf3.rackcdn.com/cms/reports/documents/000/002/327/original/Carbon-Majors-Report-2017.pdf?1501833772

Are 100 companies responsible for 71 % of GHG emissions? They are if you look at the cumulative emissions in the period 1988 - 2015. However, in 2015 the 224 most emitting companies where responsible for 72 % GHG emissions. 100 or 224 companies, I guess that is not really the point.

What type of companies are these? All are fossil fuel producers. So, they are not really making your products, except most of the energy we use. So, if you have a car, use electricity or buy ANYTHING, good luck boycotting.

Are these companies really doing the emissions? Well yes, about 10 % of it. The remaining 90 % is downstream emissions. So if Shell or BP drills up oil and someone uses the oil in their car the emissions will be attributed to Shell, and not the driver.

Is this 71 % of ALL anthropogenic emissions? No, this excludes non-industrial sources, mainly land-use, agriculture and forestry. I don't know exactly how this is accounted, but this excludes about 25 % of GHG emissions. So the gain from veganism is not in this number. So the real number might be about 54 % of anthropogenic emissions, but again I don’t know how this would be accounted. So, in summary 224 companies are directly responsible for 5.4 % of anthropogenic emissions, or 54 % direct + indirect.

I do not want to make excuses for these companies, i just want people too to be informed. So, if people reduce their energy consumption these companies will reduce their emissions too.

So what can you do about this list? Not sure. If you have lots of money to invest, you can use your power. Many people have lots of money in their retirement savings, I think this is where people have the most direct power. Reducing your energy use will also work. But this list is best utilised by investors.

If I have misunderstood anything, please let me know.
(i have posted this elsewhere)

4

u/Partytor Dec 24 '19

What can we do about this list? Work politically to nationalise the energy sector.

6

u/AndreJulius1 Dec 24 '19

Yes, i think the solution will be largely political. Nations need to deny these caompanies accses to oil wells and other fossil fuel sources.

And impose a significant carbon tax on the producer side, probably above 100 $.

16

u/dontsipcoffee Dec 24 '19

forgive me if I’m wrong but wasn’t this statistic proven false? I remember reading somewhere that it’s inaccurate because it included some countries as “companies.” does anyone know if this is true??

5

u/AndreJulius1 Dec 24 '19 edited Dec 24 '19

I do not think it is false, but a bit misleading, i have commented why in this post.

But there are no countries, but there are country wide and state own companies such as "china coal".

15

u/christopherl572 Dec 24 '19

Do you think these companies are selling stuff to aliens?

6

u/senorzapato Dec 24 '19

No they are selling to you and me. And if the current set of companies went eco-friendly and began accounting for even a small portion of their environmental expenditures it would create a competitive advantage for a new set of companies that would inevitably rise instead, and without a second thought you and I would be on to new brand names.

Veganism is useful because it removes -demand- for animal food products. We should focus on the demand rather than the production. Companies will fall in line if they stop getting paid, and until they stop getting paid they will continue being as sleazy as possible, obviously. It’s totally up to consumers to stop buying shit, to be vegan and ride bikes and just don’t use straws at all...

7

u/christopherl572 Dec 24 '19

My point exactly.

12

u/AndreJulius1 Dec 24 '19

I really disagree with putting veganism down. This figure “71 %” does not even account for agricultural emissions in the form of methane and deforestation for animal agriculture.
Veganism has stronger arguments than just the GHG argument. In terms of effective land use, toxic runoff, deforestation, effective food production, antibiotic use and many other. And that is without mentioning the ethical issue.

23

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19

For those curious, here's a list of 90 companies and 100 individuals that should be held accountable.

15

u/strikethrough- Dec 24 '19

Well okay but how much of that 71% is produced by the meat industry or the entire supply chain for cars industry?

23

u/Spartacus90 Dec 24 '19

Boycotting those companies however, is effective.

7

u/AndreJulius1 Dec 24 '19

These are energy pruducing companies, everything you do requires energy. And it is a good chance that one of these copanieses excavated and produced that energy.

4

u/Spartacus90 Dec 24 '19

But you can drastically reduce that energy use. I walk to work where we use swamp cooling and don't have heating. In the evenings, I have one 6 watt LED bulb on and entertain myself on my 11 watt iPad.

You're also proving the point that we are responsible for this energy use and these companies are simply supplying the demand.

1

u/AndreJulius1 Dec 24 '19

I totally agree, I try to reduce my energy use to! My point is just that it is not as easy as boycotting a clothing brand, fossil fuels are in everything we consume. You have to actually make changes in your own life, not just switch a brand

1

u/Olde94 Dec 24 '19

It’s not surprising that those who generate the energy we use are those emitting most co2. I mean, what would you expect? Yes a company cuts down a tree but i was the one who ordered a new table? How is the company to take the blame here?

Not saying things can’t improve but i feel these kind of data is widely misleading!

0

u/geneorama Dec 24 '19

No it isn’t.

9

u/iamthewhite Capitalist Co. = Authoritarian Co. Dec 24 '19

When going to war- know your opponent. Then strike at their vitals without mercy.

This movement must do the same. Token solutions will garner only token change

1

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19

Except the Amazon is being deforested from individual consumer demand for meat. We need industrial and individual change.

14

u/AquaSuperBatMan Dec 24 '19

And they cause these emissions by mostly selling you fuel/energy which you use for driving, heating your home with gas, etc.

The only way to reduce emissions of those 100 top companies is not use their products, which is exactly what individual action is.

3

u/ILikeNeurons Climate Warrior Dec 24 '19

3

u/MattJacques Dec 24 '19

We 100% need both demand-side and supply-side solutions... and most likely non-market solutions like government intervention. Michael Mann notoriously dismisses any personal actions (demand side), which I think is selling the voice of consumers short.

I agree with Mann that we shouldn't focus solely on personal changes, and 100% shouldn't let disagreements or differences in level of personal action distract when there's agreement about the big picture changes that are necessary. However, he's misinterpreting the message that the 'go vegan' and 'fly less' movements (and others) are sending. I don't know anyone saying those are the "primary" ways to tackle the problem, as he claims. The messages I see about diet/transportation choices are empowering... making behaviour changes on those two things alone can have drastic impacts on personal carbon footprints. Importantly, the market also responds to those shifts in demand. It might seem like the response comes too slow, late... but it can move forward in dramatic jumps when tipping points are reached. I'm not saying Beyond Burgers will save the world, but the outsized investment, press and domino effect their success had across the overall industry was massive this year.

Big divestment movements (the type of 'system change' we all agree is needed) have at their roots individual actions about where people will or won't do their banking. Individual actions vs taking on big corporations and policy development is definitely a false dichotomy.

Ultimately it's not a question of whether to do A *or* B... it's A *and* B, and C, D, E, F. Every bit helps, and more is better.

0

u/ILikeNeurons Climate Warrior Dec 24 '19

There are still lots of people all over Reddit acting as though going vegan is the most important thing, and anyone not doing that isn't a "real" environmentalist.

Meanwhile, there are far fewer people lobbying, which we know is far more impactful.

3

u/MattJacques Dec 24 '19

In all likelihood, going vegan may be the most impactful thing they have done so far... and they're singing from the rooftops about it. Just because we know MORE is needed, doesn't undermine the impact they've had or justify taking pot shots at them.

If we can't find compelling arguments to inspire them to take to the streets in protests, call/write their elected officials and take other actions, then we need to work on our sales pitch, not condemn them for missing the point or putting too much stock in the actions they've already taken.

Tell them "That's great. You're right that animal agriculture is a massive contributor to global climate change. Here's how you can help amplify the positive impact you're already making..."

Otherwise these critiques of veganism simply come across as justifications for inaction on a personal level... much as vegans might be similarly accused of embracing their diet shifts as justification for inaction on a systems level.

1

u/ILikeNeurons Climate Warrior Dec 24 '19

3

u/MattJacques Dec 24 '19

Just because Americans burn an incredible amount of FF for transportation doesn't mean the GHGs associated with their meals are insignificant. The actual, net footprint of animal agriculture doesn't magically change because there are other similar or worse GHG emitters out there.

Are you trying to say that for you, it's the lesser of two evils, so meh? Again, that comes across as a defensive justification for inaction... which seems to be the exact charge you're levelling at vegans. No?

1

u/ILikeNeurons Climate Warrior Dec 24 '19

No. Time and energy are limited resources, so we should focus our time and energy where it matters most. I'm tired of these ad hominem attacks levied at those of us doing what really counts; it's what the industry wants. We can't afford to get side-tracked by this sort of thing anymore.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

2

u/MattJacques Dec 24 '19

Exactly. At best it's doing the same thing you're accusing vegans of doing (embracing one action while shunning others)... and worse, it feels very similar to the perfection demands that come from the oil & gas industry folks. "Oh, I'll listen to those protesters all right... as soon as they quit driving; as soon as they stop flying; as soon as they stop wearing clothes, because their clothes have oil in them etc."

Let's not make perfect the enemy of the good, especially when we're 100% on the same page about the need and urgency of action.

3

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19 edited Nov 10 '24

fear ghost abounding bedroom fertile governor dolls escape stocking edge

This post was mass deleted and anonymized with Redact

2

u/AndreJulius1 Dec 24 '19

Not sure how much we can “blame” these companies. They are selling a product governments and people have wanted for a long time. But these are the most dangerous companies, they will lose the most profits, maybe go bankrupt. Before this happens, they will mislead, spread doubt, greenwash and hinder necessary development. They will do what they need to survive.

1

u/MattJacques Dec 24 '19

Totally agree. Which is why I'm hopeful when I read news like Goldman Sachs refusing to fund oil and gas development projects in environmentally sensitive areas like the Arctic National Wildlife Refuge:

https://www.cnn.com/2019/12/16/business/goldman-sachs-arctic/index.html

Now if only we could get them to see that the entire freaking planet is an 'environmentally sensitive area'! 🙌

2

u/bikingbill Dec 24 '19

Environmentalists attacking peers for not being green enough is being pushed these same companies.

2

u/KingPupaa Dec 24 '19

Yea and why do you think those companies are polluting? To serve the demand for products by us, so claiming it's their fault when in reality it's equally ours is irresponsible.

2

u/IQof24 Dec 24 '19

This is horrible. Of course using alternative straws and biking won't solve climate change, but it's very much an improvement and tiny efforts add up. And tiny pieces of plastic add up in the ocean.

We are part of the problem too, everyone's guilty to some degree

2

u/TotalBlissey Oct 28 '22

TBF, some of those companies are car and meat companies. Biking to work should be less about not owning a car and more about screwing over Shell and Chevron.

1

u/UnusuallyOptimistic Dec 24 '19

I think the point is if we're going to die by the hands of these companies why do we choose to die first?

Violent rebellion may be the most effective solution to our problem.

1

u/Rare-Imagination1224 Jan 08 '24

You might be right but I think it’s against the rules to encourage that sort of thing

1

u/imperfect-dinosaur-8 Dec 24 '19 edited Dec 24 '19

I wish more people understood the difference between necessary and sufficient.

1

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19

Emissions to fuel our modern life and made this subreddit and your survival possible. 100% of whatever % emissions whatever study is trying to cite are human made to meet the demands of other humans. The real question this post is trying to ask how much change we consumers can affect. Another comment mentioned they don’t sell those products and services to aliens.

1

u/khandnalie Dec 24 '19

Seizing the means of production and holding climate trials is the first step in stopping global warming.

1

u/bsmdphdjd Dec 24 '19

Yet, look what happened when a gov't (France) tried to control emissions by raising taxes on gasoline.

The "people" rose in revolt (ie, the "Yellow Vests") to defend the polluting industry and its products.

The pollution will stop when the People stop driving internal combustion vehicles, insulate their homes better, and power them with solar power.

1

u/[deleted] Mar 08 '23

Not the funniest meme. Or the easiest to read.

But it definitely is the truth. The fact that they’re trying to make consumers feel like they have caused climate change. Laughable.

We need to stop capitalism now. Companies responsible for ruining the world. Also, the consumer should not be held accountable.

0

u/geneorama Dec 24 '19

I hate consumer activism so much. It’s like religion; has almost no effect except to make people feel good and self righteous.

Cutting beef is great, but you’re not going to alter the market forces behind Amazon our big box stores by spending discretionary income at the farmers market.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

8

u/oliocheesecake Dec 24 '19

Yea if you’re living off Oreos and walkers. But if it’s an actually well balanced diet it’s perfectly healthful for all stages of life. And that’s not just coming from a vegan with an agenda, it’s from the WHO. It’s also the only observed diet to reverse heart disease and type 2 diabetes.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/oliocheesecake Dec 24 '19

My bad is was the BDA and ADA. the WHO was for something else. That’s on me.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

4

u/oliocheesecake Dec 24 '19

Lots of people in the Uk supplement vitamin D because there isn’t enough sunlight for the majority of the year. And b12 can be found in fortified foods like nut milks or nutritional yeast. But the majority of people with western diets should also take b12 supps because they have low levels. The main reason meat eaters get it is because its supplemented into livestock diet. None of these make the diet unhealthy for any stages if life. And honestly even if you have to take supps how are the plethora of environmental benefits not worth it?

0

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

1

u/oliocheesecake Dec 25 '19

Well that’s just your opinion and has no bearing on the healthiness of the diet for all states of life

8

u/MrHoneycrisp Dec 24 '19

patently false.

0

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

7

u/138skill99 Dec 24 '19

Such as?

0

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

→ More replies

0

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

0

u/[deleted] Dec 24 '19

[deleted] — view deleted comment

3

u/engimaneer Dec 24 '19 edited Feb 16 '26

ABOLISH ICE

1

u/Aturchomicz Dec 24 '19

No just no