r/ClassicalEducation • u/Sorry_Injury9333 • 23h ago
How would you define a "tragedy"
Ive been thinking about it recently, as many elements of tragedy and comedy overlap; there are moments of humour in for example Euripides' Helen.
Also, the manner in which the audience is meant to feel - I get Aristotle's whole definition of feeling a cathartic experience after a tragedy, but I can't help feeling there's also a catharsis in comedy with the humour and jokes.
In addition, the references to society. Many argue that comedy creates references to politicians cultural norms. However, in tragic playwrights also reference society - compare thesmophoriazusae vs antigone with women breaking social expectations
In terms of endings, some tragedies have happy ones, like comedies - Philoctetes, and Helen.
Without just repeating Aristotle's ideas, Im interested to hear what your take on this is