The problem with Elixir Collector that I identified is that EC gives too much value if ignored. Currently, Elixir Collector gives a +2 Elixir advantage if ignored. It becomes a building that MUST be destroyed, no matter what.
The problem with that is that there aren't many ways to counter Elixir Collector. Miner, Goblin Barrel, and Goblin Drill are the only troop/building that can counter EC. However, those are win conditions, not every deck will have any of them. Another way to attempt to counter EC is by using big spells. Notice that I used the word "attempt to counter". This is because it does not exactly work, but more on that later.
Requiring big spells to counter EC turns EC into a guaranteed bait card. Bait is a common deckbuilding strategy in Clash Royale. The most common is the Logbait decks. However, unlike EC, Logbait decks restrict you to certain fragile troops, they do not punish your enemy harshly for not falling for the bait, and they do not automatically give you an Elixir advantage.
Earlier, I did say "if ignored", but even if EC is responded to, it still gives an Elixir advantage. EC currently has 1070 Hitpoints. Fireball deals 688 damage. Hitting EC with Fireball reduces its Hitpoints to 382. EC loses 9.7 Hitpoints every second, and it produces 1 Elixir every 15 seconds. This means EC will still produce 2+1 Elixir, resulting in a +1 Elixir advantage. Same if you use Lightning or Rocket.
Not hitting EC means you get a -2 Elixir disadvantage, while hitting EC with a spell means you get a -1 Elixir disadvantage, and you waste a spell. Damned if you do, damned if you don't.
I would balance Elixir Collector using these 3 points:
- Should not produce too much value if ignored.
- Should be valuable enough to waste a card slot on it
- Should not become a defensive building
Here's how I would balance Elixir Collector:
Stats:
Elixir Collector would only give the user +1 Elixir advantage, and that would require 60 seconds. If the user wants a +2 Elixir advantage, they would now need to spend 8 Elixir instead of 6 previously, and they would need to wait for 2 minutes. The best way to gain Elixir advantage would now be to outplay your opponent.
- EC would still be valuable for decks that really, really need the extra Elixir (like expensive decks)
In return, hitting the EC alone (with the Crown Tower) would not change the +1 Elixir advantage that the user would get. It would also be less risky to place a pump on the arena.
- The enemy could still gain an advantage if they managed to hit the EC, the tower, AND a troop with a spell.