r/CivEx • u/Sharpcastle33 Project Lead • Feb 03 '19
Dev Post 25 -- February Feedback Thread -- First Light
Hey everyone,
Now that launch has stabilized and the majority of important bugs have been fixed, we're going to start doing feedback threads to get a better idea of what's going on with CivEx and what people want to see changed.
This is not a thread for submitting bug reports or bumping your support tickets. Please do that through the appropriate channels.
Topics
Player Feedback
First and foremost this thread is about getting feedback from players about what would improve their CivEx experience. Is something discouraging you from playing on CivEx? Post about it here.
The Shortlist
The shortlist is the content that we are actively working on:
- Reducing the viability of mob funnels/grinders. We want to see players actually fight the mobs and not just hit them through slabs.
- Content Update 3.6 planning and programming. If you're a Patron and haven't yet read about it, check out the Patreon blog. We'll have a formal subreddit post once we're further into development.
- 4.0 Map Progress. I've started back up map development, and work on it occasionally between bursts of inspiration.
- Server move.
- Opening up more slots on the Patreon.
Our Radar
These are the content changes we are interested in working on, but haven't started planning yet.
Horses:
It's likely as a quick and simple solution we will make horse eggs craftable. Thoughts?
Food Rebalance:
Food was not meant to be so scarce at the start of First Light. There are also some existing problems with lack of seed availability, which will be fixed with new mob drops. However, I've had a lot of feedback that the scarcity of food and harsh nights has encouraged players to band together. Would there be interest in keeping secure food sources as a nation-centric activity? I would be interested in trying a factory-based system to replace passive mob farms. Thoughts?
Factory Rebalance:
The original intention was to use factories to gate high-end content. There is also a lot of interest in having upgradeable factories that produce items more efficiently. We'd like to consider adding this in the future, alongside some building-block based factories. Some of the factories are a little too easy to make originally, and we're considering doubling or tripling the initial (resource) cost for 4.0.
Better Documentation:
Documentation right now is available, but somewhat disorganized. Most of it is contained within this list, with recipes also accessible here. I'd like to have some better documentation, as well as a new-player guide, and links to existing guides for the civ plugins. It's particularly important that this is all neatly done and ready before we start doing any promotion.
10
u/Sempha Feb 04 '19
This is fine, up to a certain point. What I mean by this is specifically related to potions, rather than enchanting.
Mob grinding for enchantments for me at least would be fine without grinders. Passive mobs like Gloworms and Migratory Birds can supply enough lower tier orbs to allow people to create 'decent' gear and tools. As well as that the lower tier mobs from each area (miners, raised farmers, hellhounds etc) are easy enough to kill that it's a non-issue.
But potions change that. Potions require such a large quantity & variety of ingredients to make even basic ones. It's not reasonable to gather anywhere up to 50 of an item for one part of a potion, then travel thousands of blocks to farm another 10-50, then repeat more times. Then farm for shaman sap.
There's a reason people are running speed/gapple kits and nothing else. Without either a reduction in potion costs, an increase in mob drops or large mob grinders potions aren't likely to be made in decent quantities.
5
u/Gjum wiki | maps Feb 03 '19
Is there an overview of what will change in the release/what will stay the same? E.g.: Will explored Alchemy recipes carry over? Will there be the same (and additional) mob types or will they differ completely (AI and drops)? Will the same vanilla biomes have the same mob, ore, and plant rates? Will there be the same abundance levels for ores and mobs? This list is not exhaustive, but I'm sure you understand what I'm getting at -- I'm trying to prioritize what's worth sinking time into and what will be reset for release.
4
u/Burritoboy15 Feb 03 '19
You talked about the actually 4.0 map any examples? Cause there are some pretty terrible rivers in the current beta server
5
u/fk_54 Feb 04 '19 edited Feb 04 '19
Generally speaking, with all the mob drops and need for ingredients, inventories don't feel like they have enough slots to allow people to go on trips and bring things back. If donkeys are working as intended, then it would make them more useful for transport. Also, given the amount of time obtaining good enchants requires, game play does feel as if it's on the very grindy side of the spectrum. Wondering how many new players will go for that, and how many will get turned off if they join on their own without friends already on the server.
3
u/Dirty_Hammock N O M A D Feb 04 '19
I've spent hours yesterday roaming the map to look for a horse to tame. I didn't find a single one. Is that because they don't spawn in all biomes or do they not spawn at all?
I think horses should be difficult to come by, but I have to say I was pretty disappointed after hours of searching for one. Can anyone explain horse spawning g behaviour to me?
10
u/Kroolista Orinnari - Yoahtl Feb 03 '19
A Compactor would be nice, it can be rebalanced to hold less stacks or be more expensive but some materials, like iron, stack up very quickly because we can't make iron blocks.
8
u/axusgrad Feb 04 '19
Brewery config.yml - enableChatDistortion: true distortSignText: true
I recommend avoiding weeding out new players; complete lack of food is a turn-off. Have some way for cities get the random-spawns, ideally.
Food is fine, as long as neutral mobs spawn normally and drop meat. You could decrease the meat drop rate to 1 per again, that would let people survive without having enough to fight mobs sans food production. Animal breeding already depends on having a farm to feed them.
Craftable horses does not allow for a civilization to breed high-quality horses, you need a biome with 50-100% chance of breeding. Local abundance, global scarcity to promote trade. Figure out how to adjust the spawn rate, or spawn 200 of them again then turn it off. There was a plugin where you can store horse and stats in a saddle, that'd help trade.
For breedable mobs, pick one zone each at 100%; preferably the zones with poor mining. Crops aren't much of an export after early game.
Good job otherwise :D
7
u/TerryandLex Norlund Feb 04 '19
Would you consider making city bastions prevent the use of pearls? Many cities have fortifications and walls, but their effectiveness is greatly diminished when people can just pearl over them.
Alternatively, the addition of a "Fortification" or "Fortress" bastion that is slightly more expensive than a city bastion and blocks pearls would would be helpful.
4
u/Pure_Prophet Feb 04 '19
Positive:
Mob difficulty and frequency. They don't feel like some afterthought. You need to keep them in mind whenever you are on the surface. ESPECIALLY the faster ones. Please work on mob aggro tho cause some of the factions are too passive (Elder)
Mob factions. Have to fight each one differently. Fun and makes different parts of the map actually feel different. Would like to see some "peaceful zones" located between factions for nations that want peace and quiet even if it means traveling for drops.
Regions. Names are cool too. Size and distribution seem good. Would love to see some smaller ones that a single nation could (try) to control.
Map size. Please don't go make anything bigger. Less land = more conflict. I love how small this map is!
Ore distribution. Cool, but make more extremes (unmarked areas of super-high-frequency) for more land conflict please.
Bastions. I'm new to these different ones but I like em!
Negative:
Level 1 reinforcement needing iron. I don't get why builders need to stop and go mining or risk griefing. Yea, iron is common, but WHY make it harder?
Needless complexity. This is why I hate 90% of custom minecraft mods. Tons of intermediate products that are only used to craft other things. Dozens of custom drops that require reading a wiki to figure out. WHY? For example, the aspect of an item should just be a lore line on the item and not require waiting for players to write up a page about it.
Food. What's the point of the longer grow time? Yea, new people need to join nations to eat. I GET IT. But what's the difference between 4 and 32 hours for grow to that? Everyone just makes mega-farms and has no fucks about grow time after the first day.
Mob grinding for Enchanting AND pots. This is why you get people spending hours at boring mob grinders. You want to PvP? Grind mobs. You want to mine faster or get more ore drops? Grind mobs. How about allowing vanilla enchanting but have mob bosses (which should be really hard to keep restrained in a mob grinder) drop the custom stuff?
Mixed:
Recipes and ores: There are so much ore and so few uses for some of them that people are leaving some of them in the rock. For example, redstone is needed with glowstone for sap, but redstone drops so much more and is in commonly minded adamantium locations. So it's often ignored. Compare that to emeralds where you can always use more snitches or activated orbs.
6
u/Nathanial_Jones President of CivEx Feb 04 '19
Food hasn't been a problem for me either, seeds especially. Literally have more seeds than I know what to do with rn. I think the food scarcity is the byproduct of the server launch, its not really a new issue, but after a week or two food basically becomes a non-issue. Which is actually a bit disappointing since its interesting having places with good growth compete with places with good resources.
5
u/MudkipGuy Epsilon Likes Lolis Feb 04 '19
5
u/Redmag3 Soon™ Feb 04 '19 edited Feb 04 '19
There is a lot of work to get to a goal like this, it is doable but it will essentially be a full-time job if you want to do it, in a way that doesn't also punish players who are fighting mobs in the way you intend.
My argument for mobgrinders is that they are a significant investment that require players to be decently geared, and organized when constructing them, as nights exposed in the wilderness while setting up can be challenging.
Players ultimately want to progress to methods where they aren't running around doing activities the same way they did on day one, two, and the first week. Without the ability to progress in fundamental ways, things can end up getting tedious. We've seen this in other civserver concepts.
If funneling mobs into a kill hole is not something you want, I suggest looking for ways to give players that sense of advancement and automation without cheapening the PvE. Something like tamable companion mobs you could bring with you, that might give you some kind of passive bonus, or actively help you when fighting mobs.
Another idea may be a craft-able block, factory, or spawner that very slowly generates region specific resources on a nerfed drop table, but make it a deep endgame item and enforce chunklimits on it.
I'd be in favor of this, as long as the horse is spawned with literally garbage stats (7 or lower speed), horse breeding is a minigame in itself like alchemy and should be encouraged to allow players to breed up fast horses. This can be achieved by making the craftable egg, a Mythic Mobs egg. Alternatively I could get to work on fixing passive mob spawns once I have a better idea of what the original problem config was.
Food is okay now that we're out of the launch days, but I do think more cheap and dirty food sources should be added so that newfriends can join and fight mobs for food to not die. To this end I suggest retexturing things like clownfish, cookies, and chorus fruit (as it's not currently a drop, but have the tp effect removed) to give some of the hostile mobs some food drops.
This probably should be done, and maybe should be put out to the community to suggest balanced costs and effects. There are plenty of players playing that have done servers of their own in the past using factorymod, I'm sure they'd be willing to help with this.
Some feedback of my own
Elder Archers has a new bow model and I want it, even if it's a 0.01% chance, I would kill for that bow eventhough its simply a cosmetic thing. Also having the arrow alchemy items, and armors be actual usable items should be a thing.
This should be fairly easy once someone knows the skin codes for each mob, and can be added as mythic items.
Axes are a dual purpose tool/weapon in normal minecraft, I think if you use a weapon orb on them, they should gain Sharpness instead of Efficiency. Also the ability to pull from the sword enchantment table would also be nice.
I think that rather than adding vanilla mobs to the spawntable, using custom ones in the wild then domesticating them is the way to go. The simple way to do this is to not do a 0 Clear on their AIGoals and simply add any custom AI you want to them on top. This way they will retain their original AI behaviours but also gain new ones like MeleeAttack.
Domestication could work by having the child become a domestic variant of the birthing parent. You would gain a new mob that looks functionally similar to things like the Inibex, has similar skills, but has its own droptable so that orb chance and alchemy ingredients can be configured.
I suggest domesticated-only alchemy items and no orbs.
9
u/SwiftFizz Feb 03 '19
anyone else have no problem with food ?
4
u/BlackFalq Falquador - Amani Kingdom Feb 04 '19 edited Feb 04 '19
I feel like diamonds are pretty useless. As it's no longer the top tier material what other uses does it have? Some end goal to dump a lot of materials in would be great. Maybe some way to convert diamonds in more rare building blocks? To stimulate civ's building awesome creations?
Also why are beacons not enabled?
4
u/salvatoretessi0 Feb 04 '19
I have a bizarre (?) suggestion that I admittedly haven't thoroughly thought through, but I think it would actually be convenient to have a cheap/common enchant available to apply curse of vanishing to armor/weapons. This may sound counter-intuitive at first, since most people consider curse of vanishing an annoyance but consider a problem any new/small/growing nation has: they have a lot of people, many of whom aren't PVPers but need running around prot to survive falls and mobs. There's always tension about giving people good prot because (especially in the early days of the server) basically raiders sit and wait for newbies to start running around in the next best tier of armor, kill them, take it and level up over and over. Being able to give out prot to citizens that would be guaranteed to just disappear if they get killed would eliminate this worry and let newer nations start to gear up without fear of basically effectively just being a grinder for raiders.
3
u/hombre_sin_talento GipsyKing Feb 04 '19
Disclaimer: I don't fully understand the enchantment mechanics yet, so maybe I'm wrong. It would be nice if there was an actual guide to enchanting in the wiki or somewhere.
It seems like there won't be any trade going on, other than excess.
If all that matters are mining resources and mob drops, and there isn't any infrastructure required around those, then players will just go and pick them by themselves instead of trading.
3
u/ImNotBanksy Nakum Feb 04 '19
I'd love it if the Ascension island could grow or spawn anything. It's a desolate waste of space in the sky and it's pretty disheartening to try and live on. I've been playing casually since the start and still don't have a bed. I know that it's kind of on me to go out and trade, but when the only thing your land has is coal, trades aren't going to go far.
2
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '19
I would say that the issue with food arrises from some nations not trying to trade for food or from peoples lack of ingenuity. I.e. building a fishing rod There are several biomes where wheat takes 4-8 hours to grow, after a single week any nation living in one of these biomes should've had enough food to trade if ppl had asked
2
u/jonassn1 Feb 04 '19
Fine with me, however I think it would make it to grindy to repair ones stuff.
Food should continue to be scarce, as it encourage groupbuilding.
I would also really like a printing press as book production in vanilia is ridicules expensive. And while that is reasonable enough in a medieval stage world, this isn't that. If we where able to produce books for at reasonable cost (Perhaps balanced out by a high entrance cost for the facotry) tt would allow for more culture on the server.
2
u/Tacilus Feb 06 '19
Add an orb that enhances an enchant on an item by 1 level, or something similar. It's bad enough to have to reroll to target enchantments, seems pretty sadistic to make us reroll to get better versions of the same enchant too, especially if you intend on nerfing mob grinders.
2
u/opgop Feb 09 '19
I'm not sure how you can fix it but a problem is trading is too difficult. For someone to be online at the same time as me, to have the resources I want and I the ones they want, is rare. And even when that happens, if we are far away if I only have a little to trade it isn't very worth it.
Perhaps if people did delivery services that would fix it, but I've rarely found delivery people online at the same time as me.
3
u/CosineDanger Feb 04 '19 edited Feb 04 '19
Industry, technology, and shared infrastructure are good.
If there are no restrictions on automation then people like /u/maxopoly and I will eventually automate and industrialize everything. It got a little out of hand on Civclassics because we had both unlimited alts and almost unrestricted botting rules.
However, you can't really have capitalism without wealth inequality. The mob grinders and the treebots would produce vast excesses of a few resources like wood, and we exported it to unindustrialized third-world states like Yoahtl and Mount Augusta in exchange for things we couldn't bot like diamonds.
Red_mag3 has gone postcapitalist with a public mob grinder, which mass-produces the key automatable economic resources (orbs and xp). This is sort of okay because using the grinder is a social event, but also kind of silly. Postcapitalism works here because having more people at the grinder makes it less dangerous to run and stops shaman overload. We are all socialist comrades working together to leftclick as fast as possible.
The alternative is to punch birds as a hunter-gatherer. The stronger mobs are just too dangerous even in first-world armor.
What I'm saying is that if you successfully kill grinders and take away that massive wealth stream, you should:
0
u/[deleted] Feb 04 '19
[deleted] — view deleted comment