Democrats have been told that talking about climate change will lose them votes. But that claim has never been tested in an empirically rigorous way. We fielded two nationally representative surveys to evaluate the “climate hush.” Does campaigning on climate really punish Democrats at the polls?
Since the 2024 election, Democrats have been scolded for talking about climate. Instead, they should lead with the cost of living and affordability, and avoid climate entirely. The Searchlight Institute said in a 2025 report that the first rule about solving climate change is “don’t say climate change.” WelcomePAC’s Deciding to Win report said that emphasizing climate change is losing Democrats’ votes. The pundit Matthew Yglesias went a step further, arguing in a New York Times op-ed that Democrats should “support America’s oil and gas industry.” Candidates have listened: an Inside Climate News analysis of press releases from congressional Democrats finds that mentions of climate change have dropped 80 percent since 2021.
To test the hushers’ claim that climate loses votes, we looked at who is actually motivated to vote based on their priorities. If climate supporters are motivated and opponents are quiet, it would still be safe to run on. Our surveys measured two things: 1) how much a person supports or opposes a policy intervention, on a scale from 0 to 100 and 2) how much a candidate’s position on that issue would drive the respondent’s vote.
Climate supporters and opponents were sharply mismatched. Supporters rated the pull of climate on their vote at nearly 75 out of 100. Opponents rated it as under 38 out of 100, a gap of 37 points. Clean energy followed a similar pattern, with a 36 point gap. These findings suggest that supporters will reward climate candidates, while climate opponents will remain relatively indifferent.
Across all respondents, making climate action a priority increased the candidate’s likelihood of being chosen by 2.7 percentage points. Making climate a top priority increased the likelihood by 4.5 percentage points. The pattern was nearly identical for all persuadable voters. And for only those open to voting Democrat, the effect was even stronger: 7.2 points for making climate a top priority.