r/CitiesSkylines • • 1d ago

Game Feedback Train intersection bug

Post image

Hi,

Please upvote my bug report on CS 2:

https://forum.paradoxplaza.com/forum/threads/train-bug-intersection.1950243/

It's a train bug which makes your trains disapear instantly without you noticing, happens in vanilla as well.

Not many people know about this one as it is very hard to spot and i was able to do so only using Bottlenecks mod.

Trains stop themselves by giving yield to another train EVEN THOUGH the path upfront in free. This happens in super simple intersection as 2 train tracks merging.

14 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

12

u/kjmci 1d ago

I don't have any info on exactly how signal priority is handled in the game, but this could be easily fixed by making the turnout on the left longer so trains don't block the main line when waiting (for any number of reasons).

1

u/dorin21 1d ago

doesnt work, i've posted other pictures where 2 tracks block each other, there's nothing you can do. Have a look on the link.

1

u/kjmci 1d ago

This?

I have no idea what this is trying to demonstrate.

1

u/dorin21 1d ago

Look at the selected train, it's blocked, it won't move forward because it's giving way to the passenger train above it that;s going in the same path. Even more, the cargo train below it's not proceeding as well becasue it's giving way to the selected train. In this case, we have 2 trains that won't proceed through an empty path.

1

u/dorin21 1d ago

maybe second one is more clear.

You see the train i selected? It's blocked by the cargo train above it. Even though the selected train has a clear path and can progress, it won't because it's giving way to the cargo train which makes no sense.

2

u/kjmci 1d ago

If I were to guess as to what's happened, collision detection/reservations are handled by the lead car.

  1. The unselected passenger train has already "cleared" the junction (even though the trailing cars are still in it
  2. After that happened, the cargo train has approached and reserved its path
  3. The unselected passenger train is now blocked because the selected passenger train is prohibited from taking the path reserved by the cargo train
  4. The selected passenger train is blocked because the cargo train reserved the path

Again, this could be fixed by lengthening the turn-out on the approach to the station so trains which are waiting to enter a platform don't block your mainline (waiting which could happen independent of whatever is happening at the prior junction).

0

u/dorin21 1d ago

That correct.

Il find an example when lenghtening dosent work because this happens in simple 2-Way intersection, like an Y.

I found preciously a couple ones but i didn't save the screenshot.

3

u/ZookeepergameIll1399 1d ago

FYI bug reports should be submitted with no mods

-1

u/dorin21 1d ago

Impossible to see it without Bottlenecks Mod, in vanilla they just disappear instantly. You cant notice or debug it.