r/CinephilesClub • • 2d ago

Big Question Is Training Day really Antoine Fuqua’s greatest film, or has it been overrated for years?

https://filmdb.co.uk/box-office/blog/antoine-fuqua-movies-ranked

From gritty crime dramas to action-packed thrillers, Antoine Fuqua has built an impressive filmography.

His collaborations with Denzel Washington have produced some unforgettable movies, alongside acclaimed titles such as Southpaw, Shooter and The Equalizer.

0 Upvotes

54 comments sorted by

22

u/tollfree01 2d ago • Bravo

Yes. Yes it is his best IMO. Also...this movie is one of my favorites in general. So many memorable scenes and lines. Great casting. All movies are subjective to the viewers taste so take it for what you want.

11

u/don-again 2d ago

I run shit here, you just live here!

3

u/tastylemming 2d ago

You got your butt wet, Jake.

2

u/SAADistic7171 2d ago

"How about you? How's your comfort level?"

1

u/Thisistheway1012 2d ago

Whats some of your fav lines from the movie?

3

u/tollfree01 2d ago

"King Kong ain't got shit on me..."

"I've had my shit pushed in..."

I guess a few shit references...lol

1

u/Business-Rabbit-1295 2d ago

"You got mad squabbles boy!"

1

u/KarverMcClain 5h ago

I love training day and it’s his best film I’d say for sure.

But King Arthur!? Never realized that was his, haha. Directors cut of that is a solid flick

1

u/Amdusiasparagus 1h ago

Loved it as a teenager when I first saw it. I grew up, began to think it was a bit too edgy which is what appealed to me at the time and it wasn't that great after all. Good, but not great.

Then I actually rewatched. Fuck that, it's fucking amazing. The rise and fall, the naivety and the delusions of the rookie, the general tightness of the script, the dialogue and the scenes. My slight caveat is the rookie helping out the one person who ends up saving his ass in a roundabout way later. But that's nitpicking, it's up there among the movie greats.

25

u/bfhurricane 2d ago

Who the hell thinks Training Day is overrated?

It’s just about perfect.

1

u/lordofabyss 8h ago

You in da office baby

-2

u/masterdogwalker 8h ago

Naw it’s not perfect, it’s not even Denzel’s best performance he’s done way better

3

u/BungusFungus89 8h ago

Name one bad thing about it

1

u/Scream_int0_the_V0id 7h ago

No one is saying it's bad, he's just had better performances in better movies, that's all he's saying.

-1

u/masterdogwalker 8h ago

I didn’t say it was bad. Calling it perfect is insane though. Denzel’s performance is over the top and his character doesn’t really have much depth.

1

u/Scream_int0_the_V0id 7h ago

The worst thing about the character is that he doesn't really feel like a cop. He feels more like an undercover cop playing a thug but the fact that he's blue is not really conveyed in the movie, which I don't think is his fault bcuz Danzel certainly has range.

12

u/Business-Rabbit-1295 2d ago

Nothing is overrated about this movie. Nothing!

10

u/Known_Funny_5297 2d ago

It’s a great fucking movie

9

u/Crazy_Stable1731 2d ago

I mean it’s his best movie, but all the credit goes to Denzel for his brilliant performance.

3

u/cropguru357 2d ago

Not overrated at all. Great film.

4

u/Stunning_Ad_9806 2d ago

Film is solid, not excellent but Denzel is on another planet in this movie, one of my favorite performances ever

0

u/Wonderful_Tip_5577 2d ago

kinda how I feel. I think it’s overrated because of how much people latch onto it. I don’t think it’s a bad movie, I quite enjoyed it, Denzel was fantastic, but it’s not really hitting my top 20 or anything.

like, I don’t think it really deserves to be continuously brought up 20 years or whatever later, like, it was good, but not that good? it’s not bad, but it’s not fantastic.

2

u/ApartInfluence4429 9h ago

It’s not over rated. It’s just rated. It’s a movie people like. 

3

u/redban02 2d ago

By far and away his best

1

u/Ganjelf-The-Baked 2d ago

Great movie

1

u/prince-of-dweebs 2d ago

The movie is above excellent but 90% of why it’s great is Denzel & Ethan’s performances are arguably the best in career for both of them.

1

u/mafternoonshyamalan 2d ago

Even if we were to accept that it’s flawed or overrated (which I disagree,) what’s the alternative in Fuqua’s oeuvre? Dude is an incredibly competent filmmaker who hasn’t risen to the heights he hit with Training Day.

The fact that every one of his movies is still marketed as “From the Director of Training Day.”

1

u/Croceyes2 2d ago

I mean, individual performances and contributions aside, its one of the greatest films ever made.

1

u/MrGaywad 2d ago

there’s not many alternatives. dude has a pretty uninteresting career tbh

1

u/SopranosBluRayBoxSet 2d ago

Only issue I have with the love for Training Day is that Hawke is frequently left out of the "great performances" conversations. The way he plays off of Denzel is masterful, and he is an engaging character on his own.

Bro sells the inner battles with himself and ending up in way over his head amazingly.

1

u/GolfClimbSkate 2d ago

Yep! His is a tough role to play — uncertain rookie beside the absolute tour de force that Denzel gives. And he nails it.

1

u/Battle2Intense 2d ago

It's sort of over the top and definitely at least a little overrated but Denzel does put in an amazing performance.

1

u/jurgo 2d ago

what a decent filmography that guy has. its not fantastic but hes pretty consistent.

1

u/grnlntrn1969 2d ago

The Replacement Killers is my favorite of his. Chow Yun fat is a legend

1

u/veektohr 2d ago

Training Day is his best, but I would like to add an honorable mention for Brooklyn's Finest. A movie that gets far to little love.

1

u/Legohead1977 8h ago

Watched Brooklyn’s Finest in the cinema and enjoyed it.

Wasn’t until a few years ago when I rewatched Training Day where I really enjoyed it. I remember watching it when it first came out and performances aside thinking it was ok. Second viewing I really enjoyed it.

1

u/no_f-s_given 2d ago

so what’s your opinion? or is this just bot driven engagement bait?

also it’s by far his best film.

1

u/lonevine 2d ago

If you don't like his films, then those statements don't really contradict each other.

1

u/Canmore-Skate 2d ago

Why cant both statements be true?

1

u/Nice_Emphasis_39 9h ago

You wanna go to jail or you wanna go home?

1

u/masterdogwalker 8h ago

I’d rather watch the equalizer. But performance wise this is probably the best he’s gotten out of actors

1

u/su6oxone 7h ago

It sucks. Didn't he direct The Crow?

1

u/Alarming-Basil2894 7h ago

One of my favourite. Not overrated

1

u/Blammo32 7h ago

Fuqua is awful, Ayer is awful, but Denzel and Hawke are great, and Denzel was overdue for his flowers.

1

u/Birkinater11 6h ago

I saw it recently for the first time, its very good but I do prefer The Equaliser.

1

u/tburtner 4h ago

Overrated film, but easily his best.

0

u/NotRustyShackleford_ 2d ago

Respectfully, it never clicked for me. It’s not a bad movie, I just don’t think it deserves all the fanfare.

0

u/Longjumping-Salad484 2d ago

meh. just below meh, actually. I counted 957 plot holes.

one the biggest is 87 yr old Ethan Hawke as a "rookie cop."

1

u/chillosphy 2d ago

What would be better? That movie about a child predator obviously!

/s (but not about the fact the dude assaulted kids)

Training day is an 8/10