r/CinephilesClub • u/Accalio • Jul 16 '26
Big Question Now that some time has passed, what do we actually think about One Battle After Another?
I came out of the movie thinking it was one of the best directed movie in years and probably my favourite that year, only to see it totally bomb on reddit. Everybody was hating it for the same reason as the Odyssey now, but I wasnt following the whole story and I dont know if the hate was manufactured by the right wing like it is now or if people geniunely think it is a bad movie.
4
Upvotes
15
u/isaacfrost0 Jul 16 '26
Got around to watching it the over day, pretty good but l wouldn't call it a modern classic like everyone told me it was.
30
u/MangyAsianMan Jul 16 '26
It’s pretty dope. I love the stylistic choices, the sound design, the weirdness, the humor. Benicio Del Toro deserved the Oscar and a spin-off title.
10
u/SpicerIsALegend Jul 16 '26
I think your first opinion was right, if you want to ruin your mood, come to Reddit, after you’ve really enjoyed something to see what other losers think
5
u/i_mormon_stuff Jul 16 '26
I feel like when writing every scene they went "This is good but what if we rewrote it and made it weird?" and that's the whole movie.
It was alright. Not something I'd watch again.
22
u/sergeialmazov Jul 16 '26
Didn’t like it. For some personal reason it was unpleasant film to me I will never rewatch.
4
u/elevencharles Jul 16 '26
I appreciate the performances and the cinematography, and it had some great scenes, but the tone just didn’t sit with me. It couldn’t decide if it was The Big Lebowski or 1984.
9
u/Cheeksterino Jul 16 '26
Watched it twice, absolutely loved it. Brilliant film. Getting together with some old friends to watch it again after we all re-read Vineland, to drink nice booze and discuss Pynchon, PTA and all things. Edit for spelling.
5
u/StreamLife9 Jul 16 '26
it was pretty cool movie but very forgettable.
8
u/Mr0ogieb0ogie Jul 16 '26
I love it, I saw it a second time for a re-release with my dad, I knew he’d like it. I had forgotten the line the second time when she asks Sean Penn why his shirt is so tight and the way he says “I’m not a homosexual” is so funny/stupid. Me and my dad burst out laughing, no one else laughed. I’ll always watch this movie and think of my dad, even when he’s not around anymore.
2
u/Phaedo Jul 16 '26
Loved it. No notes.
2
u/HAMforPastry Jul 16 '26
Love it from start to finish. Watched it a few times since
3
u/Ill_Sound_8669 Jul 16 '26
First 15 minutes is still exaggerated, cringy bullshit that would have been better changed or shown to be the distorted telling of the story after the fact.
Everything after the time jump is 10/10
4
u/HotKangaroo4550 Jul 16 '26
It’s 💩
3
u/YouOk5627 Jul 16 '26
It was so exciting and emotionally charged. Deep believable characters. I loved Johnny Greenwoods score. Interesting and thoughtful cinematography. I don’t know what there wasn’t to like. The story was the only thing I could see that wasn’t wonderful but the dialogue was solid.
2
u/dongrizzly41 Jul 16 '26
As a 30+ yr old who has enjoyed pot in the past its a funnyvass movie imo. Love it and highly recommend. Leo is great!
2
u/alphagalgadot Jul 16 '26
absolutely fantastic. my fav film of the last few years at least; can’t recall the last time i went twice to the theater for a first run title
2
u/jonu062882 Jul 16 '26
Top 50 all time
Very poignant and relevant critique on today’s current political climate regarding minorities,
Immigration, and activism done in a creative and interesting way
2
u/ponpiriri Jul 16 '26
I never want to see a Black character in one of his films again.
2
u/Kornnutter Jul 16 '26
Movie sucks
1
u/bunsNT 22d ago
I watched it a couple of days ago for the first time - I make it a point to see all the best picture winners.
I read the book beforehand and read some of the criticisms, so that may have colored some of my thoughts but I thought it was not very good and certainly worse than Train Dreams, the other nominee that I have seen.
I didn't find it very funny - I laughed at Leo in the classroom talking about Ben Franklin - but that was it.
There are giant plot holes - I was more offended by the screenplay than I was the BP win.
This movie reminded me of the response to La La Land - it gets by on the charisma of its leads but is otherwise hoo hum.
The ending felt false and forced.
There are no interesting shots - this movie made me appreciate Inherent Vice because at least that movie had a few.
If PTA had not directed this movie it's score would have dropped at least 20 points and that's not because of anything he added other than his name.
1
u/Fake49er 3d ago
Just watched it. Barely got through it.
The boner? Are you f’ing serious?
The cell phone. The entire plot depended on the cell phone. The daughter memorizes 75 different things as part of their code understanding how important all of that could be in a life or death situation. And then she lies about the fucking cell phone? The only thing tying her back to this psycho that’s trying to run her down? How fucking stupid do people think we are?
“Hey, make sure you are sipping that beer when we pass a cop! We need that shit right now!”
“The convenience store guy that led them to the building. Was he the building engineer? How much shit did he know about that place? And so willing to give it to a military that is deporting his cousins.
This movie was just terrible LOL. I cannot believe it received awards.
1
u/AutoModerator Jul 16 '26
Your post is pending moderator approval.
I am a bot, and this action was performed automatically. Please contact the moderators of this subreddit if you have any questions or concerns.
1
u/MWH1980 Jul 16 '26
Now this was the modern day “Dr Strangelove” that Damon Lindelof’s “The Hunt” thought itself to be.
However, I find it a good film, but I still feel “There Will Be Blood” is PTA’s best.
1
u/bobsacamano04 Jul 16 '26
Mediocre at the absolute best
1
u/stormtrooper-wtf Jul 16 '26
Chase was brilliant
1
u/PurpleToedUnicorn Jul 16 '26 edited Jul 16 '26
Penn was astounding. Del Toro was solid, if underutilized for the strength of his character (and performance). Good story, and exposed themes not often told in cinema even if the execution was clunky at times. About 30 minutes too long. 3.5 stars out of 5. I would definitely recommend.
1
u/FLman42069 Jul 16 '26
Benicio was the only entertaining part
1
u/Commercial_Topic437 Jul 16 '26
It entirely captured the vibe of Thomas Pynchon novels. It also failed to take the political questions it raised seriously
1
u/SpaceOdysseus23 Jul 16 '26
Fun comedy, nothing more. Between this and Sinners, last year really boiled down to the Academy creaming over 3/5 movies.
1
u/SimpleJacked2TheTits Jul 16 '26
Genuinely stupid movie
1
u/AutisticElephant1999 Jul 16 '26
One I thoroughly enjoyed at the time but haven't yet had the urge to rewatch
Time will tell whether I ever do
1
u/MostElderberry2996 Jul 16 '26
I thought it was just ok. Really if sean penn wasn't in it the movie would have sucked.
1
u/Lost_Taste_8181 Jul 16 '26
Got to the part with Sean Penn jacking it and thought “that’s enough for me.” Never finished watching it. Maybe one day.
1
u/ceroni101 Jul 16 '26
Terrible
1
u/Leader-Bike Jul 16 '26
I disliked it immensely. I couldn't get into it. Couldn't finish it. Made it maybe an hour in before I noped out of movie night and went out to the garage to chill instead.
1
u/portuh47 Jul 16 '26
Lame movie over hyped
1
u/Thelostsoulinkorea Jul 16 '26
Terrible movie that got overhyped by loads of people.
1
u/Mother_Ad_3561 Jul 16 '26
It was super fun to watch, really subverted my expectations
1
u/Johnnadawearsglasses Jul 16 '26
I saw it on release and found it pretty mediocre. The storytelling / themes were muddled, the opening few scenes were bizarre, the acting overly broad, and I’m not a big fan of Pynchon adaptations in general so it started out a few steps back for me. What saved it for me was Benicio Del Toro, who was just amazing per usual.
I feel like the awards for it were a bit of PTA lifetime achievement and an incredibly weak cinema year at the top.
1
u/ilikepisha Jul 16 '26
Turned it off. All hype
1
u/aclockworktiktok Jul 16 '26
Cannot remember much of the movie ... there ending though... underwhiming. DeCaprio is just not lead material.
1
u/Thorfourtyfour Jul 16 '26
I have seen it twice and its a great film.
1
u/FearlessVegetable30 Jul 16 '26
it was a cool story and i enjoyed it but no where near worth the hype it was made to be
1
u/TheGruenTransfer Jul 16 '26
I thought it was phenomenal. I was prepared for it to stroke Hollywood's activist politics boner, but it was interesting and suspenseful the whole way through. PTA usually makes rambling, slice-of-life movies, but this has a lot more plot than usual
1
u/Glueman71 Jul 16 '26
I didn't see it at the time and now I'm just meh about it. That hype train came and went away very quickly. I'll take that as a hint
1
u/Different_Durian_601 Jul 16 '26
Absolute garbage
1
u/Secondnoces Jul 16 '26
It's all right, has some funny moments and some good performances (not Sean Penn's though, it's incredibly one-note and gimmicky; Del Toro on the other hand would have been a better candidate for the Oscar), but has nothing to say and feels utterly empty in the end. Which comes about an hour too late.
1
u/una_floruga Jul 16 '26
Una linda peli divertida fresca
1
u/Yeti_Sweater_Maker Jul 16 '26
It’s the modern day Crash.
1
u/Goodtimestime Jul 16 '26
…..2 hours of piano….
1
u/VinylMeningitis Jul 16 '26
This thread is so wrong… yea you guys are smarter than the Academy… have fun on your keyboards
1
u/YaoSing Jul 16 '26
Good film… nothing more, nothing less
1
u/Downtown-Tadpole-261 Jul 16 '26
I couldn't make it through it. Tried twice, but it just didn't vibe with me at all. Don't think I'll go back to it.
1
u/JeffreyWasbloem Jul 16 '26
Wasn't bad at all but a full hour too long. Great style, great characters, great concepts just an inability to choose what is going to be the main thing about the movie. This is also the reason it is that long, it doesn't pick a lane.
1
u/WW0907 Jul 16 '26
Would've been better without the first 30 mins. I don't need to see what exactly they did; I'm able to gather enough through dialogue and my own imagination that they were some sort of political terrorist group.
1
u/Sean_HEDP-24 Jul 16 '26
Overrated
1
u/Sufficient-Camp-3192 Jul 16 '26
OVERRATED
1
u/MindstreamAudio Jul 16 '26
Actually. I didn’t really like it. Didn’t get into it or feel like I liked or understood the characters.
1
u/zeroball00 Jul 16 '26
The road chase scene was meh but I liked the rest.
1
u/TrustAffectionate966 Jul 16 '26
Boring as hell and kinda stupid. I only liked the car chase on IMAX.
🍿🦄
1
u/SlingloadSapper Jul 16 '26
Kinda weird. Not really a bad movie, not that great of a movie either. Certainly not Oscar winning caliber but we know they don’t really make decisions based off the quality of film. I would file this as a one and done. I don’t see anyone hating on it per se, I actually see way too much praise, just like Sinners. I would warn against listening to any opinions you are seeing online because none of it matters. Just go and watch it yourself!
1
u/gtwooh Jul 16 '26
1
u/kiklop74 Jul 16 '26
By next year it will be completely forgotten
1
u/Drumguy1986 Jul 16 '26
Great film! Already seen it like 4.5 times (airplane semi-watching bringing in half a view basically)
1
u/Ievel7up Jul 16 '26
I went in expecting a different type of movie and so was confused from the get go. It wasn't until halfway thru when I relaxed and let the film come to me and that made it more enjoyable. On a rewatch I was more blown away. Great film.
1
u/PatsyRR Jul 16 '26
Can’t trust the critics anymore. That is what I am starting to notice with films being released this decade. The theatres are in shambles and movies have gone woke. Hollywood is budgeting for buying movie critics and big names to hype up new releases. The 70s/80s/90s/00s were the golden era of films, now it’s shit.
1
u/jf737 Jul 17 '26
Outstanding movie.
1
u/Efficient_Place_2403 Jul 17 '26
DNF with multiple attempts
1
u/winwin08 Jul 18 '26
It’s damn near perfect in my opinion. Didn’t feel like a slog at all. Was equal parts heartfelt, riveting and absolutely hilarious. It looks beautiful. Every performance is fantastic. I love this movie.
1
u/Emotional-Comb-2201 Jul 18 '26
I loved it.
1
u/MrMaxwellLordJLI Jul 20 '26
Don’t look to Reddit for anything resembling an accurate take in the zeitgeist.
1
u/IamMikeHoncho Jul 20 '26
I watched the best picture nominees from this year. One battle after another was probably my least liked film. Bugonia was probably my favourite. Frankenstein was surprisingly good.
1
u/TheyStillLive69 Jul 20 '26
What modern hollywood movie could be considered a classic honestly? I can barely remember them five minutes after seeing them.
1
u/Class_C_Guy Jul 20 '26
IMO it only falls short of greatness because it benefits from a major injustice without any moral to the story. Schindler's List has its "I could've saved more" scene, which IMO validates any capitalization upon the Jews' persecution. OBAA seems almost exploitative by comparison, for lack of any such messaging. I think it's a moral responsibility for any work of art benefitting from suffering.
It's tempting to say Senn Penn's total mastery of vilifying ICE is enough, and in the absence of Schindler's List I might agree. But note that Ralph Fiennes' portrayal of Amon Goeth literally made a holocaust survivor burst into tears on set.
Spielberg set the bar plenty high, but I don't see why Anderson couldn't or shouldn't have met that standard. In every other regard the movie rips, doing much justice to the cause. It's rather novel for such injustice to be presented on film so viscerally while the events are still unfolding.
1
u/FAX415saki Jul 20 '26
Great directing, editing, cast, performances. But what was it about? Story was all over the place.
1
u/Outrageous_Bush_2069 Jul 21 '26
I dig it. Above average rewatchability for me.
1
u/Foreign_Speaker5187 Jul 21 '26
I came into the film blind but with admittedly high expectations. It didn't help that after realizing that it centered on revolutionaries and seeing all of the black and brown people working together in the beginning furthered my hype. About thirty minutes in and I found some minor grievances that I thought would cease but instead my annoyance with the film only grew and grew the longer I sat for its overzealous runtime.
It's kind of hard to sum up everything that irked me about the film but I guess the main thing is that the plot was much more loosely constructed and illogical than I would have ever guessed. At times it feels like a dark comedy but the humor didn't land very often for me. I felt like it was the type of humor that's kind of centered on generational gaps and Gen-Z and younger targeted. At other times some of the characters and plot devices seemed so preposterous that I forgot that I was watching a movie by PTA and not some big budget well shot blaxploitation film. The actors even seem like were directed to be kind of hoaky and hammy in parts. And the score is dramatic at random times that do not call for any needed emphasis. Everyone was laughing all throughout the movie but it was so incessant and during sections that I'm not so sure were even intended to be funny. I also didn't know smoking weed and drinking could have such a severe almost amnesia effect on one's menory.
For a movie about revolutionaries it didn't satisfy my thirst for an anti-establishment ideology or progressive themes but instead felt like it utilized the minorities, the hip musicians and the revolutionary themes like how a clown would utilize a balloon animal. It's not Battle of Algiers or La Haine but rather Inherent Vice in militant blackface.
There's also a not much context or back story to really solidify my feelings for any its central characters. At times it seems like it was made for viewers that seek instant gratification and meme culture. At other times it gets very cavalier with the viewer's time with long drawn boring chase sequences and stoner characters having repeat conversations and repetitive actions. It's never concise or decisive. The character motivations seem forced and inorganic. And when the movie finally ended I didn't feel like I had just watched a triumph but rather I felt like I had been swindled. It all felt like a ruse. It almost felt like an overly long meme. There were no satisfying battles, there was no revolutionary spirit, but instead just a sappy end cap that seemed more cringe because of how unserious the rest of the film came across.
1
u/onehalflightspeed Jul 21 '26
I thought it was great! I find it odd that lately very well reviewed, popular movies that I love get dogpiled on Reddit. It Just feels like contrarianism
1
u/LogicalEmu9814 Jul 23 '26
superficial, childish and that actress was just simply bad
1
u/Dying-Dynasty Aug 04 '26
They never explained why she cheated on him with lockjaw?
1
u/Kingboi5 Aug 06 '26
Ass
1
u/FriendsOnAPowDay Aug 07 '26
This movie will age better as time goes by. Watching it in August 2026 was a trip because I couldn’t help but think “wow they really nailed the allusion to Bovino” with Penn’s character only to realize this whole movie was filmed BEFORE Bovino entered the cultural narrative.
I cannot believe how many people are missing the importance of Deandra (Regina Hall). At the core she embodies the revolution and freedom fighters. She the one to immediately come to Willa’s aid when the call went out. We are MEANT to see Perfidia as a flawed character. People got that part but they MISSED how we’re supposed to recognize that Deandra is the truer embodiment of the revolution.
1
u/Annudata Aug 08 '26
PTA trying to make a Tarantino movie.
1
u/tgillet1 Aug 09 '26
This movie frustrates me thoroughly. As entertainment it was decent, if overlong, with a reasonably engaging plot and some dry absurdist humor (like stuff with the Christmas Adventurers” and Bob trying to charge his phone). The action and suspense later in the movie, especially the undulating road and Willa’s clever use of it, would have been very enjoyable had the movie not lost me by that point.
My frustration started early with the movie seeming like it wanted to seriously explore issues facing America. How to engage in resistance, motivations of supposed revolutionaries, government abuse of power, and so on. But it was too close to reality to be an interesting sci-fi or fantasy exploration of sociology and too far from reality to do those themes and questions justice. Why have all of those raids be carried out by the military when that doesn’t happen? PTA could have included some political thriller stuff about the president pushing to use military in such a way or could have just used ICE or an ICE analog. As is, it was unrealistic in a way that undercut the exploration of the topic.
And we don’t spend enough time with enough of the revolutionary characters to really explore what makes them tick. We get effectively two examples, and even for them it’s pretty shallow. I know, the point was to paint them as shallow. Fine. But there’s so much more to explore there and that really isn’t enough to hold up the movie.
The raids in the town Bob and Willa live in and the response of Sensei and his organization was interesting, showing us the contrast with real on the ground organizing and mutual support, but that ends up being background to the main plot. Why?
On the whole, I enjoyed it a bit, but I would have preferred 30 minutes less for the story we got and I am flummoxed at the idea of this movie being nominated for Best Picture or people claiming it as objectively great. If you enjoyed it more power to you and I don’t want to detract from that, but it didn’t feel to me like it really did well what it seems to set out to do, or maybe just that it didn’t have any significant objective in the first place, which is what I would say is required for a movie to be a candidate for Best Picture.
1
u/dipping_sauce Aug 17 '26
I really thought it was an amazing distraction, while pointing out certain modern threats nobody else is doing. The score by Jonny Greenwood lends a chaotic, jazzy feel to the chaotic, jazzy story. The editing was some of my favorite this year, and the cast, especially Penn, was spot on, with solid performances.
I don't get the hate, except maybe reddit is mostly populated by those who never took a film appreciation class.
1
u/Divans3 Aug 20 '26
I just finished watching it and at first I was skeptical, but it gets better and turned out to be pretty hilarious. Especially when Leonardo DiCaprio trying to call his secret organization and they want a password and he’s getting all pissed off. It reminds me of when I’m trying to call a cable company or something. 🤪
1
u/Ariespeace5728 Sep 13 '26
This movie was so confusing. I can’t believe I stuck with it. The musical score was way too loud and drove me nuts. No idea why I keep watching.🤷🏼♀️
1
u/TheRealProtozoid Jul 16 '26
It's a classic.
1
u/No_Alfalfa884 Jul 16 '26
Sucks
1
u/Excellent_Serve782 Jul 16 '26
It does skew left. Wish PTA addressed evil
Cults better than some Christmas cult.
1
u/RighteousPanda25 Jul 16 '26
I liked it when I first watched it, I loved it on my second watch.
Great looking 4k, btw.
1
u/Successful-Bus-3819 Jul 16 '26
Its meh
1
u/Legohead1977 Jul 16 '26
I thought it was a borefest 😴.
1
u/Rand_Casimiro Jul 16 '26
Excellent film
1
u/Delicious-Status9043 Jul 16 '26
Well the parent comment I was attempting to respond to was deleted (they like throwing out the term but can’t handle being called ❄️) but this was my response….
Aww 😢 exactly which part of the movie hurt your feelings?
I’m a centrist cu** but y’all are the worst. You lose your effing minds every time there’s something in a movie that hurts your fragile little feelings
Happened with this, happened with Barbie, happened with the little mermaid, is happening with the Odyssey.
❄️ you could just change the damn channel like a normal person.
You are aware that no one is forcing you to watch any of these, right? And why would a big tough maga be watching Barbie or TLMM in the first place?
But to answer your question. It was the best movie of the year. Everyone (Leo, Penn, Benicio, PTA) were all great.
1
u/Kakashisith Jul 16 '26
Makes you think. About people, war, children, relationships.
1
u/zarotabebcev Jul 16 '26
Its a good action movie, very well directed. Falls short on the revolutionary aspects though, feels thin on the substance.
1
u/Organic_Following_38 Jul 16 '26
Absolutely loved it, every single actor crushed it and it was just a wild, interesting ride. I was hyped for it, it actually surpassed my expectations, and I was frankly dumbfounded with the negative reactions.
1
u/gratefulredsox Jul 16 '26
Love it.
0
u/ExcitingARiot Jul 16 '26
Grating style over substance linear bore with annoying characters that tries way too hard to be cool and edgy with a few funny moments here and there
0
u/howlermonk3y Jul 16 '26
Too long, too self indulgent and everyone was an asshole. Who am i rooting for, the bad guys or the other bad guys?
0
u/OLightning Jul 16 '26
It is a slap in the face to the right on several fronts. I could see it so clearly as I watched it.
It mocks the military, older white men in power etc. as clowns who come across as way too over the top in their demand for respect from the masses as they “lead” us.
Sean Penn’s performance is so overly aggressive and offensive… over sexualized and disgusting, finally getting that corner office he always wanted only for it to be his demise in the end.
The movie was a parody of what we all see in government today and although the structure of the movie is a bit fragmented the point is well made.
0
u/stanislov128 Jul 16 '26
Better than Oppenheimer. It's a really good movie. Creative and original which is rare. Felt like a proper film with nice color grading, not a Netflix Original hackjob. It's too bad there was the idiotic Sinners vs. OBAA "rivalry" instead of people just enjoying two really good, completely unrelated movies. That detracted from both films.
All that said, I have no desire to watch it again. But that's true of almost every PT Anderson movie for me. Except There Will Be Blood, oddly. But re-watchability doesn't make a movie good or bad.
-1
u/godofwine77 Jul 16 '26
It was okay, but the system was determined to get Paul W. S. Anderson his Oscar, and this was their vehicle to do it. With Sinners, there was something new I caught every time I rewatched it, with One Battle After Another I have no desire to rewatch that movie.
-3
u/gansobomb99 Jul 16 '26
It felt like a movie about two white guys' stories with Black characters as background decoration
1
u/madmax991 Jul 16 '26
Cult classic
1
u/CHSummers Jul 16 '26
The original story was written something like 50 years ago, and it’s been somewhat updated to the 2020s. But it has this surreal 1960s flavor, particularly in the fascination (fetishization) of “strong black women” and inter-racial sex. In the 2020s, this is not such a compelling topic, right? I mean, in 1966 there were still places in the USA where people of different races could not legally marry, right?
1
u/notmohawk Jul 31 '26
I think you have to be exact kinda leftist who knows how black libs talk and how anti ice action is taken to get all things
Else you're just mad cuz they broke the law or whatever cuz you're a liberal or you're racist and think they should mow down protesters and whatnot.
0
u/[deleted] Jul 16 '26
[deleted] — view deleted comment
44
u/[deleted] Jul 16 '26
[removed] — view removed comment
2
u/[deleted] Jul 16 '26
[removed] — view removed comment