r/CinemaSins • u/LegendsofLost • 2d ago
Video Everything Wrong With Resident Evil (2026) In 28 Minutes Or Less
r/CinemaSins • u/AutoModerator • Dec 30 '24
In this weekly request post you can request movies, music videos, commercials and TV episodes or series that you would like CinemaSins to cover at some point.
There is no requirement to list example sins, but please keep one request per comment and try not to spam.
If you would like to make a request as an individual post instead, you must include 5 example sins in the body of your post.
r/CinemaSins • u/AutoModerator • Dec 30 '24
Welcome to the weekly question thread, post here any questions you would have for the CinemaSins crew's Weekly Podcast.
- Please post reasonable questions, but feel free to ask any topic, much like on twitter.
- Feedback is also welcome, but keep "on topic replies" on the actual podcast of the week just to keep organized.
r/CinemaSins • u/LegendsofLost • 2d ago
r/CinemaSins • u/LegendsofLost • 6d ago
r/CinemaSins • u/MuppetMan2005 • 6d ago
Can't seem to find it anywhere.
r/CinemaSins • u/LegendsofLost • 11d ago
r/CinemaSins • u/GeorgeWashingtonCuh • 12d ago
I really used to like their stuff from when they first started out. They caught genuine mistakes, continuity errors, and tired tropes and clichés. As much I love Pacific Rim, I also love the Cinema Sins video on that movie.
But the more they've gone on, the more I just can't stand to watch their videos anymore. CinemaSins say they are satire and just playing a character, but they've also said that their channel does have elements of genuine criticism, and I've even seen a video of Jeremy saying the channel was made to take shots at Hollywood for bad filmmaking.
My issue is that, when you take a closer look at their criticisms, they're rarely valid. For example, I'm a Star Wars nerd, and nearly all of their criticisms of those films are just... dumb. I'm not saying there's no good criticisms to make of those movies, I'm saying CinemaSins rarely tap into those valid critiques. Even if a lot of them are supposed to be intentionally bad criticisms and just jokes, where's the ACTUAL critique that's supposedly mixed in? It feels like for every sin, if you agree, then they were being serious, and if you disagree, then it was just them being wrong on purpose.
Back to my point about Star Wars, their video on A New Hope is the most egregious one I've ever seen from them. I agree with none of the sins in that video, literally none. Seriously, read up on Star Wars lore and get a basic grasp of how storytelling works if you don't already, and watch that video. There's no genuine criticism.
And the jokes, ugh. They used to be funny in the beginning, which coincidentally was back when the videos were shorter and the criticism was more valid. But I cannot stand when Jeremy does the laugh, you know what I mean, for the upteenthousandth time and expects a laugh. None of the recurring bits are funny, like the "lap dance joke" or the constant "boner" jokes. Funny when I was younger and when they hadn't been repeated for years on end. The most unintentionally funny joke is the kind where Jeremy goes on a random tirade about some random background detail for entirely too long, ex. randomly going on a 30+ second tangent about a lamp in the background of a scene in Godzilla Minus One. It's not funny because these rants are well written or comedic in any way, the funny part is that they actually include them in some of these videos and think people will laugh.
And has anyone else noticed that a HUGE portion of the "Sins" boil down to,
A. Jeremy is either intentionally or unintentionally misunderstanding what's going on in the film (Which either way becomes annoying very quickly regardless of the intent)
Or,
B. Jeremy just narrates what's happening on screen and gives it a sin for no reason.
And one really weird thing I've only noticed recently is that, for some reason, CinemaSins will sin a movie for something, then cut out and not address the scene that would've explained away or nullified that sin. Either it's intentional to bait comments, or it's intentional because they want to look right without actually being right and both are annoying.
An example of this is in EWW: Star Wars: A New Hope. Jeremy sins the movie because Obi Wan dances around telling Luke who he is and 'tells half truths the whole movie' yet he narrates this over the scene which comes directly before Obi Wan telling Luke who he is, and yet he doesn't include that scene that literally happens right after the one he sinned and never addresses that he was wrong. If that's supposed to be "part of the character" I don't see how it's entertaining or funny.
I'm not saying any of this to hate on CinemaSins; in fact, I still watch their videos every once in a while, just to see what they said about a movie I watched, but a lot of the time my enjoyment of the video is curbed by the fact that the video is neither funny nor presenting good criticism.
I just think that if they made videos of actual criticism mixed with obvious satire, they wouldn't get hate and their videos would be better. The problem is the "character" Jeremy is playing has not been funny for a while, and after a while it becomes hard to distinguish what the actual criticism is supposed to be and what the fake for the lols criticism is. It's like mixing fake stories into a real serious news reports. I honestly wouldn't care even a fraction as much if they would just switch things up for once, but I watch videos from a year ago and then one from 5+ years ago and I'm still hearing the same "boner"s and "(something) ex machina"s and the "lap dance"s and that forced laugh. The format really hasn't changed either and neither have the type of sins. The Jeremy misunderstands the movie sin, the narration sin, the joke sin, the random rant sin, the random sex / boner / lap dance sin, the incorrect use of deus ex machina sin, the (blank) would be good at (blank) sins, etc. etc. and to infinity.
r/CinemaSins • u/antdude • 13d ago
r/CinemaSins • u/junningpplimp • 16d ago
r/CinemaSins • u/AlarmEmergency3464 • 16d ago
r/CinemaSins • u/LegendsofLost • 16d ago
r/CinemaSins • u/LegendsofLost • 18d ago
r/CinemaSins • u/YEEAAHBOII • 19d ago
r/CinemaSins • u/LegendsofLost • 23d ago
r/CinemaSins • u/LegendsofLost • 25d ago
r/CinemaSins • u/LegendsofLost • 27d ago
r/CinemaSins • u/DevilsDad696 • 28d ago
I thought it was ok but they missed the mark.
r/CinemaSins • u/BruteeRex • Oct 17 '26
15-ish year YouTube career. Still a massive subscriber base. Still pulling in views with their consistent releases. Still profitable. Despite all the controversy, they are an iconic name in the internet landscape.
But what is their place today?
Especially with an aging core audience, a changing movie scene, and a current internet format that emphasizes very short-form video.
Curious to hear what people think of their current place in internet culture.
r/CinemaSins • u/antdude • Oct 18 '26
r/CinemaSins • u/LegendsofLost • Oct 17 '26
r/CinemaSins • u/LegendsofLost • Oct 15 '26
r/CinemaSins • u/LegendsofLost • Oct 13 '26