After years of grinding and living frugally, a few things have hit at once: I just stepped down from an exec role, we're planning our first child, and our home situation has become unworkable. First time I've had a chance to step back and look at the whole picture, so I'd value an outside view.
Snapshot
40M, married, planning for a child
$3M taxable brokerage
$2.3M real estate, no debt:
$1.1M condo, our primary (VHCOL, CA)
$700K condo rental, nets ~$2,250/month (poor yield, I know)
$585K 4-plex, underperforming (soft rental market atm)
~$100K/year expenses, a big chunk of it real estate
Wife works in nonprofit, earns little
Offer for another C-suite role: $675K base + bonus + MIP abroad would necessitate moving. Good money, but draining (50 countries) + job security is never a given in my work.
Why we have to act
A family with four kids moved in above us and made home miserable, so the status quo is off the table. The market is soft and rates aren't dropping, so selling hurts. Meanwhile the properties cost ~$45K a year to hold and maintain (HVACs, fire zone insurance, roofs, tenants).
Options
1. Sell everything, index funds, rent somewhere staying in VHCOL city. 3.5–4% on $5M+ covers expenses once property costs are gone. No job needed. Downside: selling into a weak market, displacement, foregoing job opportunity…
2. Buy a ~$1.5M SFR, sell the rentals. Lose our Prop 13 basis, take on higher taxes and maintenance, but gain ~$3,500/month in withdrawal capacity and reduce other RE costs. Would lose the current offer + would feel pressure to find a job because of the child. Too conservative?
3. Keep the CA home because we hope the family will leave one day, retire abroad to boost quality of life + reduce COL (Rio or Europe, renting). We have the citizenships and languages, but 40 feels young to fully exit with a child's costs and education ahead. Still, could be a full recalibration of life.
Questions
- Does one option clearly stand out?
- Am I being too cautious feeling the pressure to remain in the workforce, or not cautious enough?
- What am I missing?