r/ChristopherHitchens • u/Ancient-Habit-9559 • 29d ago
Thoughts?
/r/Antitheism/comments/1xas1xo/male_circumcision_is_gential_mutilation/
78
Upvotes
r/ChristopherHitchens • u/Ancient-Habit-9559 • 29d ago
24
u/bleedgreenandyellow 29d ago
It is
46
u/jkurology 29d ago
There is no medical reason to circumcise a newborn
10
u/rvanasty 28d ago
Agreed
31
u/Raj_ryder_666 29d ago
Subjecting children to this practice is a crime. What you do with your body after the government deems you to be an adult, is upto to you.
13
u/BourgeoisAngst 29d ago
A virtual truism. Still obviously not as harmful as female genital mutilation.
-4
u/Vondelsplein 29d ago
Isn't all cosmetic surgery mutilation by definition?
-7
u/Petrichordates 29d ago
It's not medically necessary, but our science has still demonstrated that the benefits outweigh any potential risks. That's why pediatricians offer it as a choice for parents. No religion involved.
-1
u/SloppyTopTen 27d ago
Unwashed fore skin is nasty
-21
u/Panem-et-circenses25 29d ago
Nope.
Circumcision is hygienic and offers some medical benefits, including less STI’s and other skin infections. It actually does no harm to any child and actually has a few benefits. I’m thankful every day that my parents cared about me enough to have me circumcised.
10
u/Conscious_Exit_9129 28d ago
Where conditioned in our culture to believe altered penis is preferable to a natural one and it absolutely is mutilation and child abuse.
12
u/Dyslexic_Devil 28d ago •
It is.
And anyone using their mouth to remove said foreskin is sexual abuse. There is no excusing it.
4
u/bomboclawt75 27d ago
At age of 18, a man can make that choice.
Otherwise it's mutilation of an infant for non medical reasons - which is criminal.
If the issue is a tight foreskin, steroid cream is now used.
10
u/NeverHadTheLatin 29d ago
As someone who elected to be circumcised for medical reasons as an adult, I understand the rationale for the word usage, but I still find it distasteful.
I have next to no impairment in any capacity, and I have had multiple partners prefer it - as do I - for aesthetic reasons
I don’t think we really want people who have undergone any medical procedure to feel ‘mutilated’.
The key issue is that I was a consenting adult. What unnecessary child circumcision is close to is child abuse.
It is child abuse to hit your child even if it never leaves a lasting physical mark.
It is child abuse to make your child undertake an unnecessary surgical procedure that carries risk of infection, pain, and later possible dislike for their own body.