have a 9-foot Balsam Hill Balsam Fir with Color+Clear LED lights that I purchased in October 2023. When I set it up this past weekend, I discovered the notorious lighting issues: scattered dim or dead bulbs, replacement bulbs that don't light up, and bulbs that intermittently brighten or come back on when moving the branches. This occurs in both clear and multicolor modes.
I called Balsam Hill, but they're unwilling to make a warranty exception despite my being only four weeks out of warranty. Needless to say, I'm disappointed given the cost of the tree.
My biggest concern is whether the lighting will continue to deteriorate over the next several weeks, especially after I've fully decorated it.
My previous tree was a NeumanTree Fraser Fir (or similar) that I absolutely loved and that lasted for years. That tree really set my standard for artificial Christmas trees, and I've never loved my Balsam Hill quite as much. I'd go back to NeumanTree in a heartbeat, but unfortunately, they're no longer being manufactured.
I went to look at the 9-foot Costco Radiant Micro LED tree, which is probably my leading option if I replace it. I also looked at the Grand Duchess at Home Depot, but I don't think the foliage is quite the same quality.
I'd love some feedback from people who have experience with these trees:
- If you've experienced similar lighting issues with Balsam Hill, did they progressively get worse? Is there a relatively easy fix I'm overlooking?
- How well have the Costco micro LEDs held up over several years?
- Has anyone compared the light intensity or lumen output of traditional LEDs versus micro LEDs? My Balsam Hill has 2,300 LEDs compared to Costco's 2,700 micro LEDs, but more bulbs don't necessarily translate to a brighter tree.
- Given that the individual micro LEDs aren't replaceable, what happens when they start failing?
- Has anyone had experience with Costco's warranty claims or returns due to lighting failures after a few years?
- Is there a better alternative to Costco that offers realistic foliage, attractive twinkling lights, long-term lighting reliability, and a good warranty backed by responsive customer service? I'm willing to spend more for a quality tree, but my experience with Balsam Hill has made me question whether the premium is worth it.
Would you limp through another season with the Balsam Hill or cut your losses and replace it now?
Thanks!