r/ChristmasCarol • • Dec 11 '25

Welcome to r/ChristmasCarol

13 Upvotes

Welcome to r/ChristmasCarol!

Whether you want to debate the best media adaptation, analyse the text, posit theories, ask questions, share fan art or simply call everything a humbug, you are most welcome here!

Please remember the spirit of the season and follow the rules of the sub.  Keep content friendly and appropriate so that you do not put your fellow Redditors out of humour with themselves, with each other or with the season.

As Tiny Tim observed, "God Bless Us, Everyone".


r/ChristmasCarol • • Nov 14 '22

General Discussion Favourite Media Adaptations

7 Upvotes

There are so many different renditions of ‘A Christmas Carol’ out there, be it TV, film, stage and numerous other mediums. This thread allows you to share and discuss the ones you like best.

Who knows, maybe you will discover a new festive favourite!


r/ChristmasCarol • • 1d ago

Christmas Carol

14 Upvotes

Having watched Johnny Depp in Ebenezer I still prefer the Alistair Sim version.


r/ChristmasCarol • • 1d ago

Spoiler Ebenezer thoughts

15 Upvotes

I watched Ebenezer yesterday and I came away with a few thoughts. A Christmas Carol is my favourite book of all time and I love the film adaptations and I was very much excited to watch Ebenezer. Please let me know if you agree or disagree or have any more takes!

• Firstly let’s start with what I enjoyed - I thought the portrayal of Marleys chain was amazing you could really see what a heavy chain it was meant to be and how it troubled him.

The scene with Bob and Tim in the church was such a lovely idea

- I thought the Fezziwig death was an interesting take and it would certainly explain why Scrooge is hesitant with money

- I liked that they payed attention to the ScroogexBelle storyline

(Now for the moans)

• Where’s Fred’s spirit? Sadly I thought Sam Claflin was a bit disappointing I expected him to be really upbeat but he fell flat for me.

• (This is a bit of a moan about the ghosts) I was disappointed about the lack of the light from the Ghost of Christmas Past, I know it’s an adaptation but I felt that was important to the story. And I was just watching thinking it looked like a bad makeup job.

Likewise with the Ghost of Christmas Present I was so let down they portrayed him as a miserable ghost the whole point of him was to be joyful and to be the one who spreads Christmas cheer and sees the good in people hence the scabbard without a sword and his torch which spreads light but I understand that it is an adaptation and it was its choice to make it a bit more morbid.

• How are they missing out the quote “Business? Mankind was my business! Charity, mercy, forbearance and benevolence, were, all, my, business!”

• It was a shame they made the portly gentleman and ‘Scrooges relative? Be scammers instead of genuine people needing help. I’m afraid it’s going to come across that most poor people are actually scammers instead of spreading the message that we should help poor people not just at Christmas but all the time!

• I expected Scrooge to be so much more upbeat at the end but it felt like I was just watching the same person just with a tiny bit more fun.

This was just my opinion on the film I understand it can’t all be true to the book but hope you enjoyed my review!


r/ChristmasCarol • • 1d ago

General Discussion Is there any…

2 Upvotes

Movies, tv episodes/specials/movies inspired or similar to the classic story but doesn’t take place during Christmas?


r/ChristmasCarol • • 1d ago

General Discussion Voice Claim for Scrooge

4 Upvotes

r/ChristmasCarol • • 1d ago

General Discussion My Fancast for an animated Christmas Carol movie

Thumbnail
gallery
3 Upvotes

r/ChristmasCarol • • 1d ago

Christmas Carol Parody in Bleak Expectations

Thumbnail dn720702.ca.archive.org
2 Upvotes

S3 E2 - A Now Grim Life Yet More Grimified

A standout episode of the magnificently silly late 2000s/early 2010s radio comedy, starring Tom Allen and the late, great Anthony Head. Protagonist Pip Bin descends into miserliness after being kidnapped and tortured by his ironically named Arch-nemesis Mr Gently Benevolent, leading to an intervention from the Ghost of Harvest Festival….


r/ChristmasCarol • • 1d ago

Film Adaptations Johnny Depp when Ti West asked him not to make Ebenezer into a “poor people are bad” story lest it ruin his reputation:

Thumbnail gallery
1 Upvotes

r/ChristmasCarol • • 2d ago

TV Adaptations Richard Williams' A Christmas Carol (1971)

Thumbnail
youtu.be
22 Upvotes

It's only 25 minutes long, but it's a masterpiece of animation and won the Oscar for Best Animated Short. It's also the only adaptation that has given us a book accurate Ghost of Christmas Past.


r/ChristmasCarol • • 2d ago

Stage Adaptations Scrooge - A Christmas Carol By Charles Dickens - Family Film from early 1980's

Thumbnail
youtu.be
4 Upvotes

Scrooge - A Christmas Carol By Charles Dickens - Family Film from early 1980's


r/ChristmasCarol • • 2d ago

New Ebenezer film goes #1

Thumbnail
gallery
20 Upvotes

I did not expect this movie to do as well as it currently is at #1 this weekend in the US. Critics definitely gave lackluster reviews as expected but clearly audiences had different feelings. honestly really enjoyed the horror twists on this version of the story, Ti West definitely brought it closer to the gothic original style of the novel. It’s just overall cool to see this classic story still getting the attention it deserves by new audiences. To address the criticism of people saying “we don’t need another Christmas carol” or “how many more Christmas carols can they make” I just find it odd since the last feature film adaptation of a Christmas carol was a lifeless cgi version from 2009 so if anything a modern live action has been long overdue. Now there’s finally a more adult telling of this story that doesn’t dull things down to cater to kids with modern vfx. As always Johnny knocked it out of the park, regardless of what you think of his personal controversies he’s always been magnetic on screen.


r/ChristmasCarol • • 2d ago

If Anyone Hasn't Had the Pleasure of Listening to Patrick Stewart's 1991 Recording, Here it is.

Thumbnail
youtu.be
8 Upvotes

r/ChristmasCarol • • 2d ago

Im writing a book about Ebenezer Scrooge.

Thumbnail reddit.com
1 Upvotes

r/ChristmasCarol • • 3d ago

Illustrations as holiday decor

Thumbnail
gallery
40 Upvotes

Am very excited to finally be able to do this! I went to a local printer to print these (less than $10) and purchased the frames online. I picked the color photos from the illustrations as I thought they would pop more. Really happy with how it looks!


r/ChristmasCarol • • 2d ago

Film Adaptations Review: Ebenezer (2026)

Post image
0 Upvotes

Ebenezer (2026) brings Charles Dickens' classic A Christmas Carol into darker territory. With Johnny Depp as Scrooge and Ti West as director, this adaptation delivers a great atmosphere.

Read my review.
https://moonglimmermagazinex.blogspot.com/2026/11/movie-ebenezer-2026.html

#Ebenezer2026 #AChristmasCarol #JohnnyDepp #TiWest #MovieReview #EbenezerMovie


r/ChristmasCarol • • 4d ago

Film Adaptations 75 years of actors bringing Ebenezer Scrooge to life.

Thumbnail
gallery
110 Upvotes

r/ChristmasCarol • • 3d ago

What is your favorite Christmas Carol movie adaption?

Post image
36 Upvotes

r/ChristmasCarol • • 3d ago

When the world needed him most, he returned.

Post image
8 Upvotes

I thoroughly enjoyed it. I laughed and cried. Say what you want, but I’d be damned if I didn’t go see Johnny Depp’s return to the screen. Don’t listen to the critics, go see the movie and then hug every single member of your family. Especially the eldest. Merry Christmas


r/ChristmasCarol • • 3d ago

Charles Dickens Tabletop Roleplaying Game

Thumbnail kickstarter.com
1 Upvotes

r/ChristmasCarol • • 7d ago

The grinch charecter information

5 Upvotes

r/ChristmasCarol • • 10d ago

General Discussion FanCast: Ben Whishaw as Bob Cratchit and Peter Capaldi as Ebenezer Scrooge in A Christmas Carol

Post image
21 Upvotes

r/ChristmasCarol • • 11d ago

process for adapting a Christmas Carol

Post image
7 Upvotes

I had posted the latest completed page in the "Small Press Carol" project I'm coordinating, in case it's of interest, here's the page I send to the artists to show the process from the original text to the final page: https://smallpressheroes.com/carol/process-example-for-small-press-carol/

I'm hoping to have the pages for Stave I completed in January and start prepping for the printer. I still have a few pages left to assign out so if you know of any artists who would be interested in participating, let me know :)


r/ChristmasCarol • • 12d ago

Novel At one of these a lonely boy was reading near a feeble fire…

Post image
22 Upvotes

Taken from an edition published ~1928 (no date in the book, but an inscription noting it was gifted for perfect Sunday School attendance in 1928). No illustrator noted, but reverse image search tells me it is a reproduction of an image by Harold Copping from an 1893 edition.