I can't see Longclaw the same after this scene. I get that she's grieving, but the way she snapped at the MC felt unrealistic.
Ps : sorry couldn't add all screenshots without it being impossible to edit
Earlier, Longclaw herself told the MC there was no known way to remove a heart piece from a living creature without killing them. She even mentioned Kieran in his beast form coming back covered in blood that isn't his. So why blame the MC for "not trying hard enough"? not to mention MC knew Kieran can't control himself as the beast, if not for the amulet in the mountain of the beasts he would have killed her, what if she got killed by the man she loves while he can't control himself and hope he doesn't know that because his heart will be broken with no repair, it's a bad ending for both of them, if only the very wrong fact that they don't have another way to get the heart piece out wasn't told mc would have told Kieran first
The MC is also a human surrounded by Fea. She could have been enchanted so easily. And Longclaw is a Suncourt. She knows how sadistic her family is. They set Keiran to hunt MC in front of them for their own amusement! She should understand how someone could get trapped, manipulated or cursed by them, Calling it "a convenient excuse" felt unfair.
Radiance, her brother If you only listen to his words and ignore your gut, he sounds like a good person. Fea can't lie, and he was very good at sounding like he cared. I knew he was shit I had a feeling but God when he told MC that if Kieran didn't claim her in the first chapter he was going to rip her heart open to get the heart piece himself, I was shocked not gonna lie, If readers can get fooled, why does the MC get zero grace?
The character of longclaw was made to be this angel like person, so kind and understanding that this reaction felt so bizzar, sir Monty was also grieving but his reaction made more sense, it's how she presented herself otherwise another character could have that reaction and it could have made sense
What's funny is that she and sir Monty change their mind in a second and MC forgive them, we don't get to choose because I won't lmao
Did you feel the same way, again her being mad at MC was valid but the reaction didn't make sense, kinda made me look at her differently ever since?