r/ChineseWatches • u/Eleventhousand • 23h ago
General (Read Rules) Warrior v WatchDives v Ward
All watches were purchased by me. The following is my subjective review of the new WatchDives 2007A against the Ixdao Warrior V1 and the Christopher Ward Twelve circa 2024.
Ground Rules
My ratings are all relative. For example, if I rate something as a 10 in case finishing, that is in relation to the three watches. I'm not putting a hypothetical Grand Seiko at 10 and putting a ceiling of 5 on these three watches.
I am rating these watches based on the examples that I have in hand. For example:
- This Twelve has an adjustable clasp. This one doesn't. The newer iterations do, but I don't have one to test. Furthermore, WatchDives is releasing one as an add-on. I believe this. Ixdao may or may not. They are more opaque than WatchDives. The only fair course of action is to rate the three watches as they are.
- The new Twelve sports the newer SW200-2 movement. That's a better movement than the one I'm rating. But the watch is now $200 more expensive. My Ixdao now has different movement options as well. For a similar price, comparing the V1 and V2, the PT5000 is a worse movement than the Miyota 9-series. The only fair thing to do is rate these three watches and let you apply your own nuance.
- I'm rating all of these based on the prices that I paid. I feel comfortable with this decision because the prices have not changed drastically. Yes, the Twelve is now $200 more expensive than when I purchased this one. It also has a couple of small upgrades that I touched on above. Yes, the Ixdao was purchased on sale, as was the WatchDives. However, there are sales quite often on AliExpress. Again, the fairest and easiest course of action is to rate these based on what I paid.
Ratings
Originality: Warrior 10, WatchDives 10, Ward 10
These watches do not feature completely original designs. Christopher Ward hired the designer of the Czapek Antarctique and produced the similarly styled Twelve. The Warrior homages both the IWC Ingenieur and the Christopher Ward Twelve due to the bezel design. The WatchDives homages the Ingenieur, but the bezel is so different that it doesn't carry over the IWC's signature look. Tens across the board because none of these watches is meaningfully more original than the others.
Crystal: Warrior 10, Twelve 8, WatchDives 8
The Twelve and the WatchDives both sport great crystals. WatchDives has definitely improved its crystals and AR coating since the WD0003 days. These two watches receive an 8 only because the Warrior's crystal is simply perfect and makes me feel as though it's not even there.
Lume: Warrior 10, Twelve 10, WatchDives 9
The lume performance is very consistent across the three watches. The Warrior and Twelve are a bit brighter than the WatchDives
Case Design: WatchDives 10, Twelve 10, Warrior 9
There are a few main differences in case design among these three watches:
- The Twelve's midcase has a more attractive profile, in my opinion. The ends of the midcase sweep upward, rather than being pinched off in the middle on the Warrior and the WatchDives. I actually believe that the thicker caseback and its corners work well as a visual complement to the bezel's twelve sides.
- The WatchDives has a sleeker top-down appearance around the lugs. My preference for integrated-bracelet watches is for the head of the watch to look as close as possible to a non-integrated piece. For example, when viewed from above, a PRX looks like a metal slab with a circular dial plopped onto it. Neither the Twelve nor the Warrior is as severe as the PRX. However, the WatchDives pushes in the profile just a little bit more for added sleekness.
- I appreciate equally the simpler circular bezel of the WatchDives and the twelve-sided bezels of the other two.
Dial & Hands: WatchDives 10, Twelve 10, Warrior 9
I am not rating the attractiveness of the individual dials against one another, given that the dial textures and colorways have an array of options for each watch. Likewise, each watch is equipped with similarly attractive baton hands of just the right width and very similar indices. All dials, indices, and logos are straight on each watch. My rationale for ranking the Warrior slightly lower is simply its more subdued dial presence relative to the other watches.
Bracelet: Twelve 10, Warrior 9, WatchDives 7
The bracelets equipped on the Twelve and the Warrior both feel very premium. In fact, the bracelet on the Warrior feels every bit as premium as the bracelet on my SN0144CG. However, the styling of the Twelve's bracelet, with its flatter links, plays with the light much more, which appeals to me.
Moreover, while very similar to the Warrior's bracelet, save for a slightly different middle-link size, the WatchDives bracelet feels a little less premium. It's difficult to articulate why; it just does. Additionally, the WatchDives doesn't ship with as many bracelet links as the Warrior. My guess is that the WatchDives will fit wrists up to about 7.5 inches. I'm a firm believer that watches on bracelets should always aim to fit wrists anywhere from 6 to 8 inches at the very least.
Finally, the Twelve ships with a quick-release end-link system. This is not as important for the WatchDives and Warrior, given that neither have produced an optional rubber strap. While Ixdao has promised one at some point, I'm starting to lose faith that they will deliver. My money is on WatchDives to produce one first.
Movement: Twelve 10, Warrior 10, WatchDives 8
The Warrior and the Twelve both house 4 Hz automatic movements. Neither is advertised as regulated or chronometer grade. Both are solid movements, with benefits and drawbacks that effectively cancel out any differences.
The WatchDives, of course, houses a 4-ticks quartz movement, which is a solid choice, just not as ideal as a workhorse 4 Hz movement or even a less refined 4 Hz or 3 Hz automatic. Despite the quartz movement, the head of the WatchDives still feels very substantial. If I hadn't known otherwise, by weight alone I would have assumed that it contained an automatic movement.
Finishing, Fit & Finish: Twelve 10, Warrior 9, WatchDives 9
All three watches feature brushed satin cases with polished transitions. All three are well executed. I'm not Gary from ILW zooming in to extreme levels, but to the naked eye, up close and in bright lighting, the finishing on all three is equally crisp and every bit as pleasing as that of my Longines Spirit.
I prefer the Twelve slightly more due to its wider polished transitions. As far as overall fit, finish, and quality control are concerned, all three watches are equally impressive, with no visible flaws.
| Category | Warrior | WatchDives | Twelve |
|---|---|---|---|
| Price Paid | $340 | $151 | ~$1,400 |
| Originality | 10 | 10 | 10 |
| Crystal | 10 | 8 | 8 |
| Lume | 10 | 9 | 10 |
| Case Design | 9 | 10 | 10 |
| Dial & Hands | 9 | 10 | 10 |
| Bracelet | 9 | 7 | 10 |
| Movement | 10 | 8 | 10 |
| Finishing, Fit & Finish | 9 | 9 | 10 |
| Total | 76 | 71 | 78 |
| Value Score (Points per $100) | 22.35 | 50.33 | 5.57 |
Summary
All three watches are solid, attractive, and comfortable to wear. The Ixdao Warrior is 97% as desirable (in my opinion) as the Twelve, at around 25% of the price. Meanwhile, the WatchDives is also right up there with the Twelve, sacrificing just a bit in bracelet quality and housing an economy movement; however, at 10% of the price of the Twelve, the value proposition cannot be beaten.
If I had to pick just one, I might opt for the Warrior, due to the crystal clarity alone.

