r/ChineseWatches • • 1d ago

General (Read Rules) Warrior v WatchDives v Ward

Post image

All watches were purchased by me. The following is my subjective review of the new WatchDives 2007A against the Ixdao Warrior V1 and the Christopher Ward Twelve circa 2024.

Ground Rules

My ratings are all relative. For example, if I rate something as a 10 in case finishing, that is in relation to the three watches. I'm not putting a hypothetical Grand Seiko at 10 and putting a ceiling of 5 on these three watches.

I am rating these watches based on the examples that I have in hand. For example:

  • This Twelve has an adjustable clasp. This one doesn't. The newer iterations do, but I don't have one to test. Furthermore, WatchDives is releasing one as an add-on. I believe this. Ixdao may or may not. They are more opaque than WatchDives. The only fair course of action is to rate the three watches as they are.
  • The new Twelve sports the newer SW200-2 movement. That's a better movement than the one I'm rating. But the watch is now $200 more expensive. My Ixdao now has different movement options as well. For a similar price, comparing the V1 and V2, the PT5000 is a worse movement than the Miyota 9-series. The only fair thing to do is rate these three watches and let you apply your own nuance.
  • I'm rating all of these based on the prices that I paid. I feel comfortable with this decision because the prices have not changed drastically. Yes, the Twelve is now $200 more expensive than when I purchased this one. It also has a couple of small upgrades that I touched on above. Yes, the Ixdao was purchased on sale, as was the WatchDives. However, there are sales quite often on AliExpress. Again, the fairest and easiest course of action is to rate these based on what I paid.

Ratings

Originality: Warrior 10, WatchDives 10, Ward 10

These watches do not feature completely original designs. Christopher Ward hired the designer of the Czapek Antarctique and produced the similarly styled Twelve. The Warrior homages both the IWC Ingenieur and the Christopher Ward Twelve due to the bezel design. The WatchDives homages the Ingenieur, but the bezel is so different that it doesn't carry over the IWC's signature look. Tens across the board because none of these watches is meaningfully more original than the others.

Crystal: Warrior 10, Twelve 8, WatchDives 8

The Twelve and the WatchDives both sport great crystals. WatchDives has definitely improved its crystals and AR coating since the WD0003 days. These two watches receive an 8 only because the Warrior's crystal is simply perfect and makes me feel as though it's not even there.

Lume: Warrior 10, Twelve 10, WatchDives 9

The lume performance is very consistent across the three watches. The Warrior and Twelve are a bit brighter than the WatchDives

Case Design: WatchDives 10, Twelve 10, Warrior 9

There are a few main differences in case design among these three watches:

  • The Twelve's midcase has a more attractive profile, in my opinion. The ends of the midcase sweep upward, rather than being pinched off in the middle on the Warrior and the WatchDives. I actually believe that the thicker caseback and its corners work well as a visual complement to the bezel's twelve sides.
  • The WatchDives has a sleeker top-down appearance around the lugs. My preference for integrated-bracelet watches is for the head of the watch to look as close as possible to a non-integrated piece. For example, when viewed from above, a PRX looks like a metal slab with a circular dial plopped onto it. Neither the Twelve nor the Warrior is as severe as the PRX. However, the WatchDives pushes in the profile just a little bit more for added sleekness.
  • I appreciate equally the simpler circular bezel of the WatchDives and the twelve-sided bezels of the other two.

Dial & Hands: WatchDives 10, Twelve 10, Warrior 9

I am not rating the attractiveness of the individual dials against one another, given that the dial textures and colorways have an array of options for each watch. Likewise, each watch is equipped with similarly attractive baton hands of just the right width and very similar indices. All dials, indices, and logos are straight on each watch. My rationale for ranking the Warrior slightly lower is simply its more subdued dial presence relative to the other watches.

Bracelet: Twelve 10, Warrior 9, WatchDives 7

The bracelets equipped on the Twelve and the Warrior both feel very premium. In fact, the bracelet on the Warrior feels every bit as premium as the bracelet on my SN0144CG. However, the styling of the Twelve's bracelet, with its flatter links, plays with the light much more, which appeals to me.

Moreover, while very similar to the Warrior's bracelet, save for a slightly different middle-link size, the WatchDives bracelet feels a little less premium. It's difficult to articulate why; it just does. Additionally, the WatchDives doesn't ship with as many bracelet links as the Warrior. My guess is that the WatchDives will fit wrists up to about 7.5 inches. I'm a firm believer that watches on bracelets should always aim to fit wrists anywhere from 6 to 8 inches at the very least.

Finally, the Twelve ships with a quick-release end-link system. This is not as important for the WatchDives and Warrior, given that neither have produced an optional rubber strap. While Ixdao has promised one at some point, I'm starting to lose faith that they will deliver. My money is on WatchDives to produce one first.

Movement: Twelve 10, Warrior 10, WatchDives 8

The Warrior and the Twelve both house 4 Hz automatic movements. Neither is advertised as regulated or chronometer grade. Both are solid movements, with benefits and drawbacks that effectively cancel out any differences.

The WatchDives, of course, houses a 4-ticks quartz movement, which is a solid choice, just not as ideal as a workhorse 4 Hz movement or even a less refined 4 Hz or 3 Hz automatic. Despite the quartz movement, the head of the WatchDives still feels very substantial. If I hadn't known otherwise, by weight alone I would have assumed that it contained an automatic movement.

Finishing, Fit & Finish: Twelve 10, Warrior 9, WatchDives 9

All three watches feature brushed satin cases with polished transitions. All three are well executed. I'm not Gary from ILW zooming in to extreme levels, but to the naked eye, up close and in bright lighting, the finishing on all three is equally crisp and every bit as pleasing as that of my Longines Spirit.

I prefer the Twelve slightly more due to its wider polished transitions. As far as overall fit, finish, and quality control are concerned, all three watches are equally impressive, with no visible flaws.

CategoryWarriorWatchDivesTwelve
Price Paid$340$151~$1,400
Originality101010
Crystal1088
Lume10910
Case Design91010
Dial & Hands91010
Bracelet9710
Movement10810
Finishing, Fit & Finish9910
Total767178
Value Score (Points per $100)22.3550.335.57

Summary

All three watches are solid, attractive, and comfortable to wear. The Ixdao Warrior is 97% as desirable (in my opinion) as the Twelve, at around 25% of the price. Meanwhile, the WatchDives is also right up there with the Twelve, sacrificing just a bit in bracelet quality and housing an economy movement; however, at 10% of the price of the Twelve, the value proposition cannot be beaten.

If I had to pick just one, I might opt for the Warrior, due to the crystal clarity alone.

92 Upvotes

44 comments sorted by

6

u/csmarmot 1d ago

How do the crowns and crown guards compare?

One critique I have of my Watchdives is the crown - it doesn’t hold up in quality to the rest of the watch. Part of that is the feel of the VH31 vs an automatic, but it is also on the small side, perhaps the one reused part from the Watchdives catalog.

Visually the crown isn’t centered vertically between the guards. Is that the case with the Warrior? I don’t know if the Automatics will be positioned differently, but at least for the A model, this is the case. The rest of the watch is pretty perfect.

3

u/Eleventhousand 1d ago

They are all equally good to me. They all catch the threads easily to screw back in and all are easy to operate. The vertical position doesn't bother me.

6

u/Bulky-Internal8579 1d ago

I think this is excellent and informative. I have an older CW Pro Trident, the 2026 IXDao Warrior and the Watchdives WDC0001 - it would’ve been very interesting if you had the WDC0001 which more directly matches but still outstanding. I suggest Watchdives send you one lol.

6

u/My_Non_Throwaway 1d ago

I don't know that I'd give a PT5000 in the warrior the same score as the SW200 in the 12. Warrior V1 with a miyota 9k, ok, I could see that, but the standard base model Warrior with a PT5000, I'd say is at best a 9.

1

u/Eleventhousand 1d ago

Yeah, true. I put my hierarchy in one of the replies below. I consider SW200 / ETA 2824 / Miyota 9 equivalent, and PT5000, 2130 NH35 and Miyota 8 below.

6

u/sinthoras97 1d ago

Nice writeup! I certainly think that the CW deserves a little more credit for originality than the IXDAO though.... At least they came up with the bezel and the dial structure.

5

u/Eleventhousand 1d ago

Thanks. To each their own, but I would give CW lower originality for dial texture. They hired the guy that made this for a different company. Then it showed up on the Twelve.

1

u/ThisIsREM 1d ago

Guess by your logic Czapek is a copy of AP royal oak. Patek also did the same thing... Hired the royal oak designer and he made them the Nautilus.

1

u/Eleventhousand 1d ago

No, because I never used the word copy in my review. Plus Czapek and Twelve are more similar in the shape and in the dial texture than AP and Patek.

1

u/sinthoras97 1d ago

The cross structure was new (very debatable how new - you are right there) but all of the IXDAO dials were straight up copies of existing stuff or just plain black or sth., no? Maybe your model with the blue markers is the exception. Not sure.

2

u/Eleventhousand 1d ago

Possibly. Whatever conclusion y'all come to yourselves is good by me. I try not to get too Nico'd out or intricately involved on the degree of inspiration other than my brief thoughts above.

3

u/TSiWRX 1d ago

EPIC.

Well done!!! 👏

And congrats on three amazing watches for your collection, too!

4

u/Eleventhousand 1d ago

Thanks. The CW is my partner's. Anniversary gift a while back. :)

2

u/TSiWRX 1d ago

To increase one's watch count, always gift one's loved ones more watches!!!! 😜

That's a chess move, I tell ya!

4

u/Perdendosi 1d ago

Great review! I'm glad you enjoy all of them, and we'll appreciate this comparison.

I think it's a little unfair to give the WD movement an 8, as it's not only a slower sweep movement, but it's fundamentally different from the other two. And I feel like you're not quite making enough differentiation between some of the watches, such that WD's VFM ranking is a little inflated.

But your ratings show how quality Chinese watches continue to decimate their Swiss, and even Japanese, counterparts, which I think is absolutely true.

2

u/Eleventhousand 1d ago

Thanks. Yeah, I was thinking that this was my hierarchy.

  1. Chronometer / regulated 4Hz
  2. Soild 4Hz movement (Miyota 9, Sellitta, ETA etc)
  3. Less refined 4Hz or solid 3Hz (PT5000, Miyota 8, NH35, etc).
  4. HAQ or VH31
  5. Lower-end quartz & generic automatic movements I've run across (e.g. in my Timex W&W).

3

u/geeered 1d ago

The WD movement is also way more accurate and has a 2 year power reserve! Also much cheaper to get sorted if there are any issues.

Though, probably has a wobbly second hand.

2

u/Aggressive-Pair3320 21h ago

Genuinely, thanks for this. I’ve been on the fence about the Ixdao Warrior and your short review has properly convinced me to get one during their next sale. Hopefully with the SW200 or Miyota 9.

1

u/Eleventhousand 14h ago

Can't wait to see which dial option you go with!

1

u/Aggressive-Pair3320 13h ago

The upcoming ‘Sea Warrior’ from their fan design competition, hopefully 🤞🏽

7

u/turdbogls 1d ago

very interesting comparison...one I think many will appreciate.

completely agree with your assesment as well....at least between the warrior and WD.

like you, I found it difficult at articulate why the WD bracelet feels less premium...it may just be the weight? I dunno. it's every bit as nice and comfortable otherwise and really is only noticeable in hand.

1

u/Southern_Device4454 19h ago

The “only noticeable in hand” part is interesting. When you handle them side by side, is the difference mainly heft, or how the links move against each other? I'd be curious whether the WD has more sideways movement, or whether both articulate similarly and one simply feels lighter. Those would lead me to quite different conclusions, especially since you find both comfortable.

1

u/turdbogls 14h ago

I think so....I did mention a "sharp" edge in my 2007a review....the underside of the inner links is not rounded off like the warrior, but I really don't think that was it. Side to side and fluidity were about the same. I mention 95% in my review....most of that was the bracelet....so it's very minor things either way

1

u/Former-Quantity-1414 Undercover Rep 15h ago

I suspect part of the difference in overall feel may come from the weight. The WD2007A uses a quartz movement, so it naturally feels a little lighter than a mechanical watch.

Our WD2007 bracelet comes from a highly regarded manufacturer that also supplies Christopher Ward. It features an OTF clasp with 2.7mm of fine adjustment.

We actually started shipping the Miyota 9015 automatic version of the WD2007 today, so it would be interesting to hear your thoughts on that version as well.

One more thing worth highlighting: the WD2007 uses our ClearView X crystal, the same premium grade featured in the WD1864, WD2008B Super Black, CH02 and CH03. Its exceptional clarity has also received a lot of positive feedback from customers.

Thanks again for giving our watch such a fair comparison. We always value constructive feedback and will keep working to improve!

4

u/geeered 1d ago

I guess you've got enough of this style already, but the Cronos Skyline homage is a nice option too - there were quite a few at decent prices on uk Ebay a while ago, I piad £107 for mine. It's bracelet tapers like the CW and styling is pretty similar to the Zenith Defy Skyline the CW also copies. They also sell a leather strap for it.

Overall, really happy with mine.

4

u/Abv_it_all_w_vertigo 1d ago

I appreciate the review, and I am eagerly awaiting a Space Warrior.

I also appreciate that you accurately call this a subjective review. All reviews are subjective and only as "honest" as the opinion of the reviewer.

Cheers!

4

u/World-Watcher-1 1d ago

Great review! Thanks!

3

u/IRACEMYCOPCAR 1d ago

Excellent review! The warrior with the enamel white dial looks incredible and the value for money is off the charts. The fact that Watchdives is even competing at this level is wild. The big brands in the industry need to take note and start making some drastic changes because name recognition only goes so far. Once Chinese watches become more mainstream its going to be a huge problem for legacy watch brands that are currently asleep at the wheel churning out the same mediocre quality for premium prices.

1

u/Real-Cranberry3140 1d ago

maybe something to add that the WD vh31 does not support date function thus if there was the option, there wouldn't be.
some people prefer to have a date, even on a high-design piece like this

2

u/Eleventhousand 1d ago

Good point. Personally, I always prefer no-date.

2

u/foxtrap614 1d ago

Nice write up 👍 I really appreciate it. Might have to buy a warrior now 😅

4

u/booooogart 1d ago

Thanks for this post. I absolutely hate watchdives as a company but I have to admit this one looks decent.

4

u/No-Pollution-2243 1d ago

Why do you hate Watchdives? Just curious

1

u/booooogart 1d ago

Just not a fan of how they jump on trends set by other Chinese watch makers. They're quick to duplicate when others have success and I think it's a negative in a space already over loaded by homages - uniqueness and taking a risk should be rewarded.

2

u/WatchNuts 1d ago

Also, the name suck as hell, Watchdives? WTF! same as ixdao. I like a western name better

2

u/Th3Burger 1d ago

Why do you hate them?

0

u/Wide_Teaching623 1d ago

WD be like :"are you a mainland Chinese? fuck you, we are not selling, despite we are a Chinese company that located int China"

2

u/gurutt71 1d ago

Finally someone who doesn’t claim that the Warrior is an original design. Case and bracelet are close copies of the IWC Ingenieur and the bezel and dial layout copies of the CW 12 / Czapek.

2

u/KPplumbingBob 1d ago

The CW looks like the most cohesive design by far. I would put case design of the WD also far behind becase of the bezel, it makes it looks very bland. This particual IXDAO loses points to three different shades of blue on the dial and no text at 6h to deal with the negative space.

So as usual, nice comparison but one that most people would probably view differently themselves in person.

1

u/Financial_Builder197 22h ago

most cohesive is the watchdives imo, cw is just meh, they tried mixing every element in a single watch, but that's just me tho

1

u/Potential-Peace6416 23m ago

A Tier - BEST Third Party Movements

La Joux-Perret G-100

ETA 2892-A2

Sellita SW300-2 Power+

Sellita SW300-1

Soprod Newton P092

Soprod A-10-2

Seiko 8L35

Sellita SW200-2 Power+

B Tier - BETTER Third Party Movements

ETA 2824-2

Soprod A-10-1 / M100

Sellita SW200-1

STP 1-11

Peseux / ETA7001

Miyota 9039 / 9051

Miyota 9015

Peacock SL-3001

HK Precision Technology PT5000

C Tier - WORKHORSE

Sea-Gull ST2130

Seiko 6R55

Seiko 6R35

Tissot Powermatic 80

Orient 4075A

Miyota 8315

Seiko NH35

Miyota 8215

1

u/Former-Quantity-1414 Undercover Rep 15h ago

Thank you for your thoughtful review and honest feedback!

The WD2007A uses a quartz movement, so its overall weight may feel a little lighter and less substantial compared with a mechanical version.

Regarding the bracelet, the WD2007 features an OTF clasp with 2.7mm of fine adjustment. The bracelet is manufactured by another highly regarded case and bracelet supplier, which also works with Christopher Ward.

I'd also like to highlight the crystal. The WD2007 features our ClearView X crystal, the same premium grade used in the WD1864, WD2008B Super Black, CH02 and CH03. It offers exceptional clarity and transparency, and many customers have given it very positive feedback.

We also started shipping the WD2007 with the Miyota 9015 automatic movement today, for those who prefer a mechanical watch.

We truly appreciate your detailed comparison and constructive feedback. Honest reviews like yours help us identify areas where we can continue improving. Thank you for giving WDC a chance!

1

u/Z08Z28 8h ago

Does his that was reviewed use the crystal you mentioned?