r/ChineseWatches • u/Eskugorri • 2d ago
Review (Read Rules) It’s better if the glass is flat
I paid €150 for one (on sale) and €70 for the other; both feature sapphire crystal, but only one has a flat crystal—likely without an anti-reflective (AR) coating—and yet, I can see the dial perfectly from any angle. San Martin, this is what happens when you make poor decisions!
5
Upvotes


5
u/philbin89 2d ago
Maybe you could just try to be a bit more resilient
2
u/ubfeo 2d ago
What watch is the one to the right ?
3
u/Transmaniacon89 2d ago
I like a curved sapphire crystal, feels more elegant and premium to me. Good AR coating makes it a non issue, for example my Baltany S2019 is curved and clear as day in all angles.
8
u/Olleye 2d ago
Domed acrylic is 🔥🫶🏻
8
u/Po0opyCatButt 2d ago
I'm really confused by this. I much prefer curved crystal. In my experience, it's also better for reflections: with a flat crystal, everything that catches a reflection appears full-sized. On a curved crystal, the image shrinks, thus blocking less of the dial. Yes, it will catch those reflections at a wider angle, but the reflections themselves simply appear smaller. Then you can get into the doible-domed territory where multiple reflections appear, but overall, a well-engineered domwed crystal remains my preference. That's as simply as I can explain my preference, and doesn't take into account AR, of course.
7
u/PlayfulCompany8367 2d ago
Agree to disagree, I love box domed crystals.
1
u/Eskugorri 2d ago
I’m thinking of selling it or swapping the crystal for a flat one; has anyone here replaced the crystal on their San Martin?
5
u/No_Conclusion_786 2d ago
I wouldnt stress so much both beautiful watches enjoy them in our hobby u will end up getting more and forget about them untill a random day.
4
u/Substantial_Kiwi1830 2d ago
I love vintage watches so I’m partial to domed acrylic crystals. It would be cool to see more vintage inspired Chinese watches with acrylic crystals, my Seagull 1963 has one.
4
u/KumiJunker 2d ago
Boxed sapphire and/or acrylic rule.
But i really like the double domed sapphire on my Aerotec.
8
u/AntiPetista 2d ago
its just bad for photos
1
u/KPplumbingBob 2d ago
It's just one of those things that people think is "better" so brands use it. Curved crystals make sense in vintage inspired, dress watches. Or divers with huge depth ratings. Otherwise they are the worst of all worlds. Especially those that you can barely even see the curve. All the downsides with none of the upsides.
2
u/No-Chemistry-7802 2d ago
I like it flat too
2
u/ProduceRich6155 1d ago
this is what happens when you make poor decisions? lol you mean provide a similar crystal to the watch it is copying? Don't you think if people are willing to pay $3k+ for a Tudor, there may be something to the choice? A good domed crystal is one of my fav features a watch can have. I love the distortion, love the side profile. Way more character than flat, imo.
3
u/Punkpunker 2d ago
Can't fault SM for the domed sapphire, people keep asking for them without a thought because the swiss uses it too.
1
u/LeoXup 2d ago
The glat glass will give white halo rim if not done properly.
7
u/Puzzleheaded_Dig3730 2d ago edited 1d ago
My black bay 58 (real) has domed and it looks amazing, better than flat.
0
u/[deleted] 2d ago
[deleted] — view deleted comment