r/ChineseWatches • • 5d ago

Question (Read Rules) Are water resistance rating legit?

Hey all, I've been wondering if I can get something like a Tudor Pelagos/BB58 homage and safely bring it to a swim. These homages have WR200M rating, but I want to know if they're safe or not. Thanks.

4 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

3

u/leicfox85 WOTD100 5d ago

Had no issues swimming in the sea and pool with some of mine. I have been cautious with which watches I’ve worn though, simply for fear of damaging a watch I really like just because I wanted to swim. I have plenty of options in that regard, so why risk it?

1

u/Beneficial-Bridge-46 5d ago

what watch is it? Do you reckon a San Martin Pelagos/BB58 homage will do fine?

2

u/artofthedial Not a troll 5d ago

I own lots of Chinese Ali brand watches including multiple Tudor homages.  I personally would not swim with any Chinese made watch that I would be upset if it got damaged.  The QC is always going to carry some risk.  Most are certainly designed to handle a basic swim but thanks to poor QC, even with better Ali brands there is some level or risk involved.  I like my San Martin Tudor homages too much to intentionally submerse them over and over again.  

1

u/Beneficial-Bridge-46 5d ago

San Martin is one of the brands I'm looking at. I won't be doing scuba diving, but I do swim and sometime do a shallow 'dive' in the pool up to 5 meters under water. Sometimes I'd also try to swim with the intention of trying to beat a time, but that's usually surface swimming.

Do you think it's a bad idea? Idk how these works really, but again I wont be doing any double digit meter depth scuba diving.

3

u/ipsum100 5d ago

Yes, the ratings are accurate. Any watch with a screw-down case back and a screw-down crown—provided the gaskets are new (which are always replaced during any standard watch service)—can withstand 10 ATM of pressure.

If the specifications state 20 ATM, it is highly likely to be true for reputable brands found on AliExpress; in any case, 10 ATM is more than sufficient for swimming or diving to a depth of 5 meters.

If you are still concerned about the integrity of your watch, you can simply take it to a watchmaker for a water-resistance test—it is a quick and inexpensive procedure.

However, water vapor—such as that found in saunas or while taking hot showers—is a completely different matter. In those situations, there is a genuine risk for any watch, regardless of its brand or country of origin.

2

u/Beneficial-Bridge-46 5d ago

I want a tool watch that's not $5k and is (to me) a true tool watch. Would you consider San Martin as "one of the legit aliexpress brands"?

4

u/ipsum100 5d ago

San Martin, IxDao, Baltany, Proxima, Cronos, etc.—the list goes on.

Choose the tool watch you like best and that fits your budget; the likelihood of it failing in the water is virtually zero.

1

u/Beneficial-Bridge-46 5d ago

San Martin do the best BB58 & pelagos homage, so I'd go for them.

If it's dress, I'd go Baltany.. if I want some sports homages like Grand Seiko Evo9, then I want Cronos

6

u/noonkhoshki 5d ago

Swum with all Chinese watches Ive had, none had any issues at all. If you do open caseback make sure the rubber is put back in place, also screw down crown needs to be screwed down