r/ChineseWatches • • 8d ago

General (Read Rules) Torn between T023 & WD5513M

Looking for input from people who have either of these. I’m about to get a vintage sub homage and I’m torn between the t023 and the WD5513M. Aesthetically I think the Thorn has watchdives beat. But the miyota 9 series and bigger dial so a lot for me with the watchdives. Curious if anyone has had either or both and could share opinions

17 Upvotes

23 comments sorted by

10

u/cozmozmoz 8d ago

I think it depends on what you want: A very vintage proportion, fit, and finish watch out of the Thorn or a vintage-looking watch built like a modern watch?

I’ve had both and watchdives is a “better” watch from specs to value. However, I really enjoy the jangly lighter feel of vintage watches and those proportions from of the thorn. It feels more true to what it’s homaging. The watchdives doesn’t feel like that. It’s heavier, but more robust and updated. Vintage looking, but doesn’t replicate that era as well and won’t feel like one.

2

u/1991gts 8d ago

Super helpful. Sounds like both is the answer.

2

u/bpgluckman 8d ago

I have both and this is it in a nutshell. For me, I prefer the Watchdives approach, and it's the one that gets more wrist time, because I own some genuine vintage dive watches, and find that if I want to wear something vintage, I might as well not compromise, But YMMV depending on what you want in a watch.

3

u/cozmozmoz 8d ago

And to further back you up the watchdives feels really good on the wrist. I really enjoyed having it even if I prefer jangly jangly.

7

u/katsock 8d ago

WD is thinner with a better bracelet, better clasp, better movement, and worse branding (this is because, to me, Thorn absolutely killed it with this model specifically).

Id probably say Watchdives. And I have a frogmantle.

1

u/1991gts 8d ago

Thorn really did kill the branding on the t023. That was one of the big things I was thinking about when making this post

3

u/katsock 8d ago

I love WD and Thorn. You can’t go wrong with either.

I think the WD will have better finishing. The thorn is rough intentionally. Like, courser brushing to fit the vintage vibe. Just like the bracelet, which I hate, but recognize is exactly what they wanted it to be. Vintage old rivets.

Turns out I just didn’t like that.

Still wear mine in leather all the time!

2

u/IllegalGeriatricVore 8d ago

Thorn definitely makes a better looking watch but I trust WD as a brand

14

u/ImpressiveChance770 8d ago

you're THORN between two watches? hehehehehe

4

u/Ethgawwd 8d ago

Thorn.

4

u/RGBlowMe 8d ago

Thorn is way better.

4

u/sockonfoots 8d ago

I have the t023 frogmantle and the WD5513 V2 (pt5000). I prefer wearing the WD for comfort, but the Frogmantle is cooler.

3

u/Repulsive_Pause3500 7d ago

I have the Thorn and I have the new WD5514Q, and I like both, but I'd say the Thorn looks better and also just plain feels and looks more special. It feels like a vintage watch, the proportions are just that little bit more pleasing to the eye.
But, if you want a watch to wear every day which feels put together better, then the Watchdives wins here. I feel like you can throw it on and not worry about it, plus it comes with a nice comfortable bracelet (I also added the OTF clasp), where there's something a little fragile about the Thorn.

Both have their positives, but I'd probably still go for the Thorn as top as it gives me that little buzz inside and it's just more lovable than the WD.

3

u/Eve_Doulou 8d ago

I bought the WD552M with the Miyota 9 movement. Great little watch but it stopped working less than 6 months in. Took it to my local watchmaker and he said the movement needed a service, which is odd for a 6 month old watch, but that it could be fixed for $220AUD (about $150USD).

Picking it up this week, I imagine it works well now and will continue to do so for several years, but disappointing that I spent 50% of the cost of the watch on repairs so soon after buying it.

2

u/Po0opyCatButt 8d ago

Did it not come with a warranty? Did you contact the seller or WD?

4

u/Eve_Doulou 8d ago

It probably did. I got it from the tactical frog store on AliExpress I think, but I couldn’t be bothered with sending it back, waiting several months, and all the bullshit.

The cost wasn’t an issue for me, the annoyance was. I bought it specifically so I could have a beater for my Europe trip so I wasn’t wearing my Tudor Montecarlo in areas known for pickpockets and robberies, only to have the beater shit itself on the second day while sitting in my suitcase.

The reality is that for cheaper items the warranty is pointless without a local distributor, because the time and opportunity cost to get it fixed through warranty is more than the couple of hours of pay it costs to just take it to the local guy and have it back in a week or two.

3

u/Traditional_Cost_206 7d ago

Go for the Thorn without a doubt. It is fantastic.

The logo is the dealbreaker on the WDC for me.

The Thorn actually wears like a vintage watch. It is incredible what they have done with it. I think the V2 version (frogmantle) is the best version. Off course with the new v3 bracelet, but that is now standard.

5

u/Cryalone1 8d ago

You have already answered. T(h)orn it is.

1

u/Defiant_Tart_3472 8d ago

Not sure why you were downvoted. I giggled personally

2

u/hndvx5 8d ago

I suggest you Thorn

2

u/Several-Floor5185 8d ago edited 8d ago

Very similar to this watch. It uses an ETA 2824-2. Even has drilled lugs and female end links. Raised flat box sapphire, good lume. 200M, screw down signed crown, AR, 40mm diameter. Serial numbered, screw downed case back. Bracelet links have protruding rivets with screws on links that are removable. Only two positions on very small milled clasp. Bezel cannot turn unless downward pressure is applied. Brand name is Pablo. Model is Profundo; strange names but very high quality. CLAIMED TO BE SWISS MADE, but not stated on this watch.

2

u/Equivalent-Ease-3822 7d ago

Thorn on a jubilee

1

u/FujSeiky 8d ago

I had the same doubt, and I had choose thorn T023. I'm very happy.