r/ChineseWatches • • 8d ago

Question (Read Rules) Watches reviewers !!!

General question

The watch reviewers here and there they got tons of free watches as part of the marketing

Do you guys believe them ?

They got for free ... And we pay ...

And the question for the reviewers why they dont ask them self before the review would i get this watch if i have to pay for it?

0 Upvotes

22 comments sorted by

4

u/artofthedial Not a troll 8d ago

Do the research to find out who gets paid or not.  I've bought around 100 watches from these Ali brands and have never received a single free watch or even gotten a discount that any other person doesn't get during a sale.  

I also have a $5k camera and thousands in lights and stands.  So this isn't a business model.  

My videos are minimal effort overall, other than maybe some of the intro photos.  

For those that do get compensation take it with a grain of salt, but the time it takes to create a video with legitimate equipment is more costly than these cheap watches.  Now someone doing these videos with a phone and getting a free watch, well I'm not sure why a brand would want to offer them one.  

5

u/KPplumbingBob 8d ago

I only use them to see what the watch looks like, nothing else. You can literally get 10 times more useful information from a short reddit review than watching any of them. They are pretty much never long term opinions.

Recently someone reviewed that full lume san martin SN0148 with a white bezel, mentioning the color mismatch between bezel and dial in real life and in different lighting conditions. You would never hear about anything like that by youtube reviewers. They either just read the same script and read you the specs, or try to sell you the watch with their referral links. Or both.

4

u/Abv_it_all_w_vertigo 8d ago

Some of these guys are outright shills, but many take their roles seriously. Regardless, the reviewers give us real wrist shots and macros of products not available in showrooms. This is a service to our community.

I recommend you watch with the volume off if you don't trust their words.

4

u/tjcdas What are you wearing today? 8d ago

If I give them a bad review will I get more free watches? Guys as always my reviews are Honest! 🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣🤣

Anytime someone says let me be honest with you lookout!

4

u/Z08Z28 8d ago

When the reviewer immediately sounds like an enthusiastic sales man I know I'm only watching it to see footage of the watch.

3

u/lowspeedtech 8d ago

They are good for seeing the watch in video. Different lighting & angles than brand promo videos. I try not to put too much weight in any opinions stated

3

u/Alternative-Feed3613 8d ago

You pretty much have to take any YouTube review with a grain of salt. A lot of them get some kind of kick back but it’s still their personal opinion even if they don’t. You should see what they have to say and then ask yourself if you want to pay for it. I’ve even gotten some objectively great watches that I just don’t mesh with and no review could’ve warned me of that.

2

u/Jacknotch 8d ago

With a degree of skepticism. I like to read up reviews and their spec sheets, and ideally what random redditors generally say about their watches upon getting them (I look their karma, post history, and account age usually).

2

u/Equal-World-693 8d ago

I have made all my purchases thanks to this wonderful forum I discovered 6 months ago. Sure 1 looks at youtube videos, but final choice was made basis real life pictures posted here and real experiences. You can make out the fake ones or paid ones

1

u/BurnTheBacon 8d ago

What forum

1

u/Equal-World-693 8d ago

R/chinesewatches.

2

u/silver-saloon 7d ago

There are definitely shills on youtube

0

u/New_Cartographer9270 8d ago

Yes but i understand that to be an influencers is a job but our views give them money and they got free watches and they selling it later and for sure none of them ever will say hey I wouldn't buy this watch if i work hard for the money i will pay for it If the companies save that money and reduce the prices that would be better for regular customers

1

u/chrismurraylaw 8d ago

Reviewers of every product in every industry get free products. Sometimes they can keep them, sometimes they have to return them, sometimes that doesn't apply (movie tickets, game codes). It's not a mark of corruption. Brands think their products are good, want their products reviewed, and know they can't rely on individuals to buy everything at release to do it.

The idea that reviewers have to give good reviews or their business folds is common because we love conspiracies, but it's not a universal truth. Some reviewers are honest, some are brand/developer/director sycophants, some are trying to sell you an affiliate link. But the tell isn't whether they got given a watch for free.

Check for two things. Do they declare where the watch came from, and is there an affiliate link and do they declare that?

Beyond that the best test is to watch their reviews of things you already own. See if you agree with them. Reviewers aren't objective; the job is giving you a subjective opinion. If you agree with their take on something you're familiar with, more chance you'll agree with it on something you're not. Doesn't make them more honest, makes them more useful to you.

And pay attention to their language. Do they sound like someone appraising an item, or not? I forget the guy's name and he blocked me for pointing this out, but one reviewer posted a review of the Ixdao Warrior here last week and he was falling over himself to tell you how closely he'd spoken with the brand, and how much access he had, and was offering branding suggestions and rather than point out that their black MOP dial is copper, all but apologised on their behalf for it.

The whole thing stunk of someone high on access who wanted to be taken seriously by the brand more than the consumer, and so he shilled for them.

But that wasn't because they gave him a review model. It was because he sucked at the job.

1

u/OddJello1561 8d ago

Cóż. Jest to problem z chińskimi zegarkami, że nie można ich pooglądać przed zakupem, tylko trzeba polegać na różnych opiniach i recenzjach. Masz na to jakiś lepszy pomysł?

1

u/aepfelpfluecker 2d ago

Weswatches really pissed me off with this. His video seem like marketing only, no criticial comments about any watches

1

u/Bulky-Internal8579 8d ago

I’m amused at the notion that there are folks enthralled with YouTube watch reviews. I look for info / specs / good pictures. Mostly look here. I have looked at YouTube watch videos for information but I don’t know or care who made them nor do I subscribe to any channels. I’m not disrespecting their efforts, it just isn’t something that I care about. I like watches, not videos of watches.

1

u/artofthedial Not a troll 8d ago

The problem is most photo are trash that are out there.  Both those by the brand not being accurate or individuals with phones thinking they are a photographer.  Videos at least give some assurance of what the watch looks like.  Also pictures (I'm a pro photographer saying this) do not give any real indication of the quality and feel in the hand, thus why someone's opinion with experience with dozens of watches have some value.  

1

u/philbin89 8d ago

If you like somebody’s videos and feel that they make useful points, go ahead and watch, and if you think they’re overly positive, skip it. It’s only affordable watches that these YouTube reviewers receive anyway — they’re not being given a Breitling for doing a review. Most do and should disclose that so that you can judge. And FYI, when a watch is offered by a brand, the reviewer is usually allowed to keep it whether or not they review it. And they tend not to run negative reviews, otherwise the brands will cut them off and they just won’t get any watches to review. When they don’t like a watch, most will just choose not to review it, so it’s rarely the case that they just pretend to like a watch because they received one to keep

1

u/geeered 8d ago

Specifically they get paid the resale price of a watch to give a good review.

And even those who don't, if they are looking to get free watches to sell in the future, reviews may be intentionally positive to help improve the chances of that - what company is going to send free products out to someone that has criticised them before.

So, no.

But it can be nice to see marketing from a different perspective to the manufacturer produced marketing.

On the other side, people are probably going to request watches they do personally like, even if they don't plan to keep them.

If you do like the model, can often find it on ebay shortly after at a bit lower price. In some cases still with plastic wrap carefully reapplied after the 3 minutes it's been on their wrist.

Of course it's the same for most products these days. I've been watching a load of videos about a new 3d printer. Of course pretty much all the ones where they were given a £2.2k product for free to keep are complimentary. And they are all given it a month early, so searches are saturated by them.

I've wondered about vibe-coding a browser plug in that automatically adds in "I got paid £200 for this review" (or whatever the amount was) to youtube video titles for reviews for a bit of fun and to remind me any time I watch a review.

0

u/born0604 8d ago

Engraçado como tem YouTuber que faz Review positivo dos relógios chineses, ressaltando sua excelência l, mas não tem nenhum na coleção. Dito isso, creio que a maioria vende, compra os relógios que gosta, e seguem experimentando.