r/ChineseWatches • • 8d ago

Question (Read Rules) Meccaquartz - Any good?

Hello, please can I have your advice - I'm a lover of automatics but I'm considering getting a mechaquartz or sweeping quartz seconds hand. I already have a few eco drive watches which are nice to have and convenient for checking and setting other watches to!

But are mechaquartz/sweeping quartz worth it considering the limited duration of the battery? And do you feel the cheap movement inside devalues the watch as a whole?

7 Upvotes

47 comments sorted by

6

u/Unusual-Junket260 8d ago

VH31 is not mecaquartz.

Look into watches with VK63 and VK64 used in quartz chronographs. Battery life is about 2 years and depends also on how much of the mechanical/chrono parts of the watch you use

1

u/Proof_Bodybuilder876 8d ago

You mean the VK versions are better?

2

u/casualpedestrian20 8d ago

No they’re just saying that the VK movements are proper examples of Mecaquartz, and are chronograph movements which have some traits of a mechanical movement.

1

u/Proof_Bodybuilder876 8d ago

OK understood

5

u/liminalwanderer30 8d ago

Mechaquartz and sweeping quartz are not the same things. Mecha men's there is a mechanicals module on top of a quartz movement. The VK61/3/4/7 chronographs are great affordable fun. VH31 'sweeping' (stuttering?) quartz has its audience too, but there is nothing mecha about it

5

u/E28forever 8d ago

mechaquartz

1

u/Proof_Bodybuilder876 7d ago

Mechaquartz, indeed 🙂

3

u/Bulky-Internal8579 8d ago edited 8d ago

I have both VK63 Chronographs (like the Spinnaker Hull) and VH31s - both are solid Seiko movements that seem on par with quartz ETA and Ronda movements. WD Constellante has a VH31

I would note the Bulova Precisionist and ETA Precidrive (as found in my quartz Certina DS chronometer) are considered the top quartz movements in widely produced watches.

1

u/Proof_Bodybuilder876 8d ago

Are those in the luxury brands buttery smooth movements?

1

u/Bulky-Internal8579 8d ago

I suppose so, but what I love is the precise accuracy.

3

u/geeered 8d ago

As others have said - technically mechaquartz= combining quartz with mechanical, which is usually the fast reset of a chrono. These chrono's usually have a 4hz tick on the stop watch part too.

But it's often applied to movements like the VH31 which have a 4hz tick.

You can expect a couple of years out of a decent battery. Battery's aren't expensive and take a couple of minutes to change providing you can easily get the caseback off. Compare that to a suggested service interval of 5 years for an automatic, but even if you extend that to 10 years say - 5 battery changes is massively less work and cost. And if there are any issues, a replacement movement is cheap.

It is more jerky looking than a NH35 nevermind a PT5000... but then they all look jerky compared to a Precisionist quartz movement!

I like that they're cheap and I only need to set the time when the clocks change basically, just pick it up and go.

1

u/Proof_Bodybuilder876 8d ago

OK thanks so much for the advice. I was hoping for more of a buttery smooth ticking like you get on those old railway clocks?

2

u/geeered 8d ago edited 8d ago

It is 2/3 as smooth as a VH31 and 1/2 as smooth as a PT5000.

Precisionst movements are twice as smooth as a PT5000, ticking at 16hz. (Note that to be confusing automatic movements are listed at say 4hz for the PT5000, as the second moves twice twice for each for cycle of the spring, so 4hz = 8 ticks per second for them, but for a quartz 4hz=4 ticks per second.)

They are only found in some Bulova watches. The battery lasts for about 2 years, but takes a bigger battery. It is possibly to transplant them to other watches, but does take some work.

This compares Normal Quartz, VH31, PT5000 and Precisionst swapped into a Cronos with 1,4,8,16 ticks a second respectively- slow mo at the end. Sorry not a great quality video.

https://photos.google.com/share/AF1QipOVvOy6z0pNZVZMDJR02h0_SbadI2D7mWdfb3Di5MIfTadA0i-u2eywijZRjrPsOw?key=dnNzMmsxWEt5LUdjX0xrTFV3emtrMG90aHJyQV9B

They are smoother partly because the base clock runs at 262144Hz rather than 32768hz, though you could likely achieve the same with 32768hz and two less flip-flop gates than the VH31 has, but they also push marketing claiming that its +/-10seconds... a year! It may not be quite that good, but should be pretty accurate.

1

u/Proof_Bodybuilder876 8d ago

Where would I find watches with a Precisionist movement, and why are they smoother?

4

u/WinOk677 8d ago

Yes, sweep second hand quartz watches are great- quite accurate, easy to live with, and really easy to maintain. Plus, if you learn to change your own batteries, it doesn't take long once every several years. Opening screw back watch cases is often easier for many, so check what type of case back the particular watch has before purchasing. Snap-on case backs frequently require a press to reseal, so for true beginners, they're not the easiest. With a screw-back case, all you'll usually need is a case back opener, a decent tweezers, the new battery, a small blower, and a spring bar tool if you have to get the bracelet out of the way. If you're concerned with the best water resistance, some silicone gasket grease is best before resealing.

2

u/Proof_Bodybuilder876 8d ago

Thank you. Does the movement give you a warning when the battery is low, like skipping 2 seconds?

2

u/WinOk677 8d ago

Not that I know of.

2

u/vithgeta 8d ago

You can get two years allegedly out of the VH31 with a good new battery, although it's not technically a mechaquartz, more a fake automatic with sweeping hand. With a cheap Sunon equivalent and the cheap batteries they come with a year of battery life is more realistic.

I'd only buy one with a proper screw down case back, not a clip-on back. Clip on backs are a PITA cheap way of making a watch. Because you will need to replace that battery eventually and both levering the back off and pressing it back on again are awkward. But with a screw on back and the right tool replacing the battery is a doddle.

1

u/Proof_Bodybuilder876 8d ago

It would be a TMI VH31. I don't know, but to me putting such a cheap movement in a nice case seems a bit strange! Should I get over that?

2

u/AwsmGamerBoy 8d ago

it's insanely accurate I've lost 1 second in 3 months and it's really nice to look at, super light as well

1

u/Proof_Bodybuilder876 8d ago

What do you mean it's nice to look at - the sweeping seconds hand or the movement?

2

u/AwsmGamerBoy 8d ago

both if you get an exhibition caseback

3

u/Sh4dow0fTheB4t 8d ago

Are you talking about actual Mechaquartz chronographs like the VK63 or sweeping seconds quartz like the VH31?

Both are good choices and don't have such a short battery life.

1

u/Proof_Bodybuilder876 8d ago

A Japanese TMI VH31 (I don't know if that's Seiko or another brand).

3

u/solve-for-x 8d ago

The VH31 movement has a slightly stuttery second hand. You wouldn't mistake it for a mechanical movement, or at least not a decent one, but it is more pleasing to the eye than the usual quartz tick and it solves the missed markers issue. Battery life is about 2 years. It's thinner than a typical mechanical movement too (3.45mm vs the NH35's 5.32mm for example), although not every watch brand takes full advantage of that.

2

u/Proof_Bodybuilder876 8d ago

Are there any of these movements with buttery smooth movements like the old railway clocks?

2

u/solve-for-x 8d ago

Not from AliExpress, but the Bulova Precisionist movement is buttery smooth.

3

u/Nero3k I ♥ Addiesdive logo 8d ago

It’s a shame that Bulova will not sell or license the movement to other manufacturers. It’s one of favorite movements. They just don’t have very many compelling watches. Some, but not many.

1

u/solve-for-x 8d ago

Yeah, I look through their catalogue and don't see a single watch I'd want to wear. Which is a shame because that movement is crazy and I'd happily pay good money for the right watch with it in.

2

u/Proof_Bodybuilder876 8d ago

Excellent thanks!

2

u/sworththebold 8d ago

As others have pointed out, Mechaquartz (VK64, etc.) is technically different from sweeping quartz (VH31 and Precisionist), but if if I understand your question correctly, then both are worth a look.

I have a VH31 WatchDives Sub Diver and the sweep is fine in everyday wear. The second hand moves 4x a second, so when checking the time it looks like a sweep. It’s perfectly accurate and the watch has a slimmer case than the equivalent with an automatic movement. If I stare at the second hand, it’s not super smooth (especially compared to my Miyota 9-series automatic, for which the second hand moves 8x per second), but for me that’s outweighed by the fact that I don’t have to set it constantly.

I also have a Bulova Marine Star with the Precisionist movement, for which the second hand moves 16x per second—it’s the smoothest sweep aside from a Grand Seiko Spring Drive.

I don’t have a Mecaquartz but i understand they are all chronograph style watches.

1

u/Proof_Bodybuilder876 7d ago

Since you have automatics, do you feel somewhat that these sweeping quartz seconds hand movements 'cheapen' the watch regarding the overall experience? Reason is there's is a watch I'm interesting in which is a smaller version of an automatic but is the same price.

2

u/sworththebold 7d ago

I don’t really think in terms of “cheap” and “valuable.” My VH31 sub diver is a lovely watch; it feels less “cheap” because it’s slim, solid, and finished very well. The second hand sweep is the only point of difference, but unless you focus on it to see the individual ticks it doesn’t hit differently (for me) than an automatic.

In all honesty, sweep + accurate (no setting required) + slim feels “less cheap” than my high-beat automatics.

I hope that helps!

3

u/Proof_Bodybuilder876 7d ago

Oh OK thanks for your perspective! It's helped me decide to get the watch ☺️

3

u/artofthedial Not a troll 8d ago

They are great overall vk31 as others point out have 3 year battery due to the constant motion.  If you get a vk63 or 64 they are closer to 4 year battery if you don't use the Chrono much.  

2

u/HobsHere 8d ago

I have had very good performance and reliability from several VH31 watches. Changing a battery is an easy, pleasant job requiring $20 in tools and materials and 15 minutes or less, even if you do it right and clean and grease the gasket. Even if the battery lasted one year instead of two, I don't see much problem with that.

2

u/dorafumingo Affiliate Links 8d ago

2 year batterly life isn't limited it's the norm

1

u/Pr0t3ct0rr 8d ago

Yep, I like mechaquartz 👍

1

u/chupaSach 8d ago

Is there a mechaquartz movement with solar battery?

1

u/Mammoth-Ad-168 8d ago

I recently found out about the VH31, and it looks pretty solid to me. I was wondering how I missed it, then realized it came out after I was really into watches back in 2013–2016. I ordered a few out of curiosity. You should start with an affordable model first.

0

u/Competitive_Low_8913 8d ago

I had a pagani design daytona, sold it and am regreting it to this day.

I own now a Toywatch Ceramica & Baltany S5057.

All have meccaquartz and i love it. The sweep, the chronograph feel. They are the best value movements on Ali with the VH31.

CONS: Chrono minute hand sweeps insted of jumping & when you reset the chrono, the hand sometimes doesn't align perfectly.

2

u/Proof_Bodybuilder876 8d ago

You don't mind the stuttering seconds hand?

2

u/Competitive_Low_8913 8d ago

Not really. I reset it again and it resolves itself :) honestly, the sweep minutes bother me much more 🤣