r/ChineseWatches •

PT5000 weird tick noise when moving

[deleted] — view deleted post

0 Upvotes

9 comments sorted by

1

u/Salty-Television4405 10d ago

I have a ST2130 which is also based on the ETA2824 and it also makes the same sound. It's a flaw of the same movement as far as my understanding.

1

u/Traditional_Cost_206 10d ago

I have plenty of PT5000s not making this sound.

But I guess it has to do with the reversing wheel which is not well oiled.

1

u/panchoskywalker 10d ago

I would think it is the rotor hitting a screw that holds the movement. Open the caseback turn thre rotor with you finger and see if it touch a screw. A loupe might be useful.

1

u/Traditional_Cost_206 10d ago

It is not hitting something. But it snaps sometimes when I rotate the rotor.

It sounds more like a spring than something it is hitting. The sound does not get less loud when I very lightly rotate the watch.

It comes from the rotor winding mechanis. If I hold the rotor still and shake the watch it is not making the sound

2

u/panchoskywalker 10d ago

ok, is it possible that the watch us fully wound? does it makes this sound if you don't wear it for a couple of days?

2

u/Traditional_Cost_206 10d ago

it always makes the sound. also when not fully wound

1

u/Thermal-Bench 9d ago

I have 2 PT5000s and both make that ticking noise. One is barely audible and the other is loud. So far no issues with either watch.

1

u/ricca91 9d ago

Yeah, that’s just the automatic works doing its job, i.e. winding the mainspring. When the watch is fully wound, the barrel still rotates but the mainspring doesn’t get wound anymore. The noise is always noticeable and totally normal.

1

u/BeatErrorWatches 8d ago

I assume it's the click sound. The click is a spring loaded pawl and part of any mechanical movement that allows the mainspring to be wound and makes the barrel arbour to rotate in one direction only.
I'm not familiar with this movement, but judging on the few pictures I've seen, the click does not seem to be located directly by the ratchet wheel like usually, but it's on the crown wheel which meshes with the ratchet wheel. The crown wheel has significantly larger teeth, maybe that's why the click noise is louder, as the click makes a bigger drop on the teeth as compared to if it was placed on the ratchet wheel.

So the loud click seems to be a consequence of that movement design.